Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Environment & Energy

In reply to the discussion: wind-watch.org [View all]

caraher

(6,279 posts)
19. Reading the article only reinforces the view that the author is misinformed
Thu Sep 19, 2013, 04:27 PM
Sep 2013

or deliberately misinforming:

In this country, greenhouse gas emissions resulting from electrical generation are outweighed by other man-made sources 2-to-1, while anthropogenic emissions as a whole account for about 3 percent of the world total; the remaining 97 percent comes from natural sources such as oceans and bogs.


Given that, absent human activity, that 97% or so was exactly balanced by equal absorption of greenhouse gases into the ocean, etc., it's obvious that this comparison, even if the numbers are correct, is entirely inappropriate, and crafted only to minimize the significance of our unleashing fossil carbon into the air and water on a scale large enough to cause a rise of around 50% in the atmospheric CO2 level so far - a rise that shows no signs of abating.

So thanks for the invitation to dig deeper - it only confirms my negative gut reaction.
wind-watch.org [View all] iamthebandfanman Sep 2013 OP
I googled some of the officers named at the bottom of their website. amerikat Sep 2013 #1
They are one of the first astroturf antiwind organizations to spring up kristopher Sep 2013 #2
astroturf? Fridap Sep 2013 #3
You expect astroturf groups to self-identify themselves? kristopher Sep 2013 #4
oh man, I heard about how dangerous they are Kali Sep 2013 #5
You. Crack. maddezmom Sep 2013 #8
Paid propaganda mongers that spew lies about wind power. jpak Sep 2013 #6
Nice of you to sign up to DU to support them here though. Nihil Sep 2013 #7
Just the visuals are a huge tipoff caraher Sep 2013 #9
Inspiring 350.org? Fridap Sep 2013 #23
Perhaps so (re: private registration) caraher Sep 2013 #24
A new symptom of an astroturf org, eh? FBaggins Sep 2013 #25
Nor is it hard to read the About page at Wind-Watch.org Fridap Sep 2013 #26
Another "lefty" anti-wind essay by Wind Watch prez Fridap Sep 2013 #27
Wow. Fridap Sep 2013 #10
Two posts and you're already calling others' pathetic? FBaggins Sep 2013 #11
I think I have some names now caraher Sep 2013 #12
Thanks. kristopher Sep 2013 #13
Maybe not almost incalculably so, but still small Fridap Sep 2013 #14
Wind, solar and energy efficiency are the key elements to decarbonizing modern society kristopher Sep 2013 #16
No, using drastically less is only way Fridap Sep 2013 #18
Read the article, not the teaser. Fridap Sep 2013 #17
Reading the article only reinforces the view that the author is misinformed caraher Sep 2013 #19
I agree Fridap Sep 2013 #20
It does suggest the author has nothing to contribute beyond a distaste for wind turbines caraher Sep 2013 #21
Building wind is quite different from reducing carbon Fridap Sep 2013 #22
Interesting Fridap Sep 2013 #15
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»wind-watch.org»Reply #19