Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hunter

(38,311 posts)
1. Cheap fusion would be among the worst things that ever happened to earth.
Thu Aug 22, 2013, 01:50 PM
Aug 2013

Imagine industrial populations growing and spreading without limit.

Humans would consume what's left of the natural world, turning everything into more humans and more garbage.

If I discovered how to make an H-bomb out of ordinary hardware store materials I wouldn't tell anyone. If I built a working fusion power plant, Tony Stark style, I still wouldn't tell anyone.



Our species is a three year old playing with matches and we've lit the house on fire.

Global warming and overpopulation are symptoms of our civilization's immaturity, not problems that can be "solved" with increasingly powerful technologies.

We have all the tools we need today to stabilize our population at sustainable levels, and provide a good standard of living for everyone.

If we want to stop using fossil fuels now, the solution is simple: Stop using fossil fuels!

The difficult part is not finding a "replacement" source of energy, the difficult part is creating a society where we don't need more energy.

I can easily imagine a society where most people have never smelled gasoline, never driven a car, never seen a high voltage power line, yet still live in comfortable leisurely sustainable ways with good shelter, good food, appropriate medical care, and easy access to worldwide communication and transportation networks.

This can be accomplished with existing technologies. From there, who knows where we might go? But in our current society cheap fusion would simply add fuel to the house fire. We'd build more cars, mine more materials (how about those fusion powered tar sand refineries, eh?), and generally make a bigger mess of things than we already have.



Cheap fusion would be among the worst things that ever happened to earth. hunter Aug 2013 #1
That's completely backwards - the demographic transition is happening. nt bananas Aug 2013 #2
Really? hunter Aug 2013 #3
How much of what you’re talking about is due to constrained resources OKIsItJustMe Aug 2013 #4
We haven't stopped expanding since we started burning coal. hunter Aug 2013 #5
“Suddenly we have no incentive to change anything in our society…” OKIsItJustMe Aug 2013 #6
I'm not so optimistic. hunter Aug 2013 #7
Why on earth would we do that? OKIsItJustMe Aug 2013 #9
Why would we do that? Because most of the infrastructure already exists, but mostly because we can. hunter Aug 2013 #10
I know it's hard, but assume, just for the moment, that people have some sense OKIsItJustMe Aug 2013 #11
A Polywell would generate not hydrogen but electricity FogerRox Aug 2013 #12
Same thing at higher temps... hunter Aug 2013 #14
Proton Boron 11 fusuion creates alphas and helium. FogerRox Aug 2013 #16
I agree wholeheartedly. Humanity is not genetically equipped to handle unlimited amounts of energy. GliderGuider Aug 2013 #8
Super cheap energy would be a boon to the planet. joshcryer Aug 2013 #17
Self promotion type. FogerRox Aug 2013 #13
Thanks for that evaluation. bananas Aug 2013 #15
Thanks for the warm welcome The Polywell Guy Aug 2013 #18
Video Covering All Fusion Research in 5 Min The Polywell Guy Aug 2013 #19
Polywell Guy Here - Sorry I have not been around! The Polywell Guy Feb 2014 #20
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Please welcome "The Polyw...»Reply #1