Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Grumpy Old Guy

(3,211 posts)
34. That's the depth of the character.
Tue Dec 19, 2023, 03:46 AM
Dec 2023

He wasn't searching for her to save her. He was following her to kill her because she was, in his words, ( not mine), "been with a buck." That was the depth of his hate, fueled by past massacres. Likewise, the Commanche chief was also avenging the past massacre of his own family. The Duke, who almost always played the hero, was the villain in this film. He was also avenging the death of his brother's wife. She had been in love with him, but married his brother when the Duke went off to war.

The movie was loosely based on the life of Cynthia Ann Parker, who was abducted as a child. Her uncle unsuccessfully searched for her for years. She was "rescued" in her thirties but wanted to stay with the Commanche. Her son was Quanah Parker, the last great chief of the Commanches.

WHAT is your Favorite Movie OF ALL TIME ???? [View all] DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 OP
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest Skittles Dec 2023 #1
2005 Pride and Predjudice. fierywoman Dec 2023 #2
These NoRethugFriends Dec 2023 #3
Casablanca. Pulp Fiction. Maltese Falcon. Shawshank Redemption. brush Dec 2023 #4
Three out of four... 'Pulp Fiction', I could not get beyond the first 5 or 10 minutes--- DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #23
We have similar tastes. Give "Pulp Fiction" a try. It's worth it. brush Dec 2023 #38
You should give Pulp Fiction another chance. Jeebo Jan 2024 #46
The Pumpkin and Honey Bunny scene was intended to shock you I think Shermann Feb 2024 #79
So many! Bayard Dec 2023 #5
I loved Benny & Joon mahina Dec 2023 #9
I will! Bayard Dec 2023 #21
Oh yes! Also, Little Bird, The Great Match, (Grand Finale) The Truffle Hunters, The Brand New Testament, mahina Dec 2023 #22
I just rewatched 'Dances With Wolves' the other night! DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #24
The Searchers Grumpy Old Guy Dec 2023 #6
the searchers leaves me empty: spoiler alert rampartc Dec 2023 #32
That's the depth of the character. Grumpy Old Guy Dec 2023 #34
too much to hope that american's attitudes towards comanches rampartc Dec 2023 #37
"Once Upon A Time In Th,e West" is one of my favorite movies. (spoiler alert) Grumpy Old Guy Dec 2023 #41
that first scene with jack ela, is great rampartc Dec 2023 #42
thanks for that, grumpy rampartc Dec 2023 #43
Uh, guys, no mention of the spectacular Claudia Cardinale? blm Feb 2024 #52
She was incredible! Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2024 #66
Heheh. I was a schoolgirl at the time blm Feb 2024 #68
The theme of the movie is that the feminine spirit tames The West. John1956PA Feb 2024 #59
The Third Man, 1949, B&W Basic LA Dec 2023 #7
Everything is Illuminated today. Tomorrow: Down By Law mahina Dec 2023 #8
Wouldn't say I have one, but Wizard of Oz was fun, elleng Dec 2023 #10
Love Moonstruck! MaryMagdaline Feb 2024 #69
I've never seen Fiddler On The Roof. I will some day. applegrove Feb 2024 #72
Groundhog Day usonian Dec 2023 #11
Classic! I saw that one in the theater.... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #25
You're supposed to see it over and over (I got the DVD) usonian Dec 2023 #33
I DID watch it many times, many years ago....... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #39
You know, I haven't seen one up here in 8 years. usonian Dec 2023 #40
Reading this 2/3. Haha AKwannabe Feb 2024 #49
Wow. I posted that in December. usonian Feb 2024 #50
Well the thread is revived now AKwannabe Feb 2024 #56
A Groundhog Day miracle! usonian Feb 2024 #62
Ben-Hur, 1959 Jeebo Dec 2023 #12
I saw parts of 'Ben-Hur' many times since childhood, as it was a TV favorite for a time.... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #26
Wuthering Heights Polly Hennessey Dec 2023 #13
One of my favorites, too... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #27
So difficult to pick one EverHopeful Dec 2023 #14
I loved "The god's must be Crazy" Walleye Dec 2023 #18
I love that movie! nocoincidences Feb 2024 #61
Two Films nwliberalkiwi Dec 2023 #15
Sugar Man was great. Loved the music. applegrove Feb 2024 #73
Happy birthday! CBHagman Dec 2023 #16
The Lion in Winter is one of my favorites Walleye Dec 2023 #19
"I saved my first drink to have with you.... here...." DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #28
Lord of the Rings Shermann Dec 2023 #17
I was a fan of the books back in my D&D days.... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #30
Being a child of the Cold War I'm gonna have to go with "Dr. Strangelove" Walleye Dec 2023 #20
I finally watched that crazy thing in its entirety this past year..... DemocraticPatriot Dec 2023 #29
A Hard Day's Night Cartoonist Dec 2023 #31
The Lion in Winter. PoindexterOglethorpe Dec 2023 #35
Brazil LastDemocratInSC Dec 2023 #36
The Sound of Music joshdawg Dec 2023 #44
To Kill A Mockingbird. applegrove Feb 2024 #74
The Shawshank Redemption, Clerks, Rocky Horror Picture Show, Jean de Florette and Ziggysmom Dec 2023 #45
Casablanca ificandream Jan 2024 #47
Overboard AKwannabe Feb 2024 #48
Night of the Hunter (mitchum) or Monty Python's Holy Grail Tom Yossarian Joad Feb 2024 #51
2001: A Space Odyssey bif Feb 2024 #53
I just watched that on TCM NT XanaDUer2 Feb 2024 #75
Mine too. yesphan Feb 2024 #81
Modern Times GreenWave Feb 2024 #54
Dr. Zhivago rurallib Feb 2024 #55
Dr Zhivago for me too. I watch once a year and I know a lot of the dialogue by heart. Nanuke Feb 2024 #57
Somehow I just get so immersed in it rurallib Feb 2024 #60
It's A Wonderful Life, Groundhog Day, Back To The Future, Michael, Forest Gump Uncle Joe Feb 2024 #58
The Big Lebowski Birdcage walkingman Feb 2024 #63
I love The Big Lebowski, DemocraticPatriot Feb 2024 #70
Animal House WheelWalker Feb 2024 #64
Bell, Book, and Candle, Time Bandits, Alien, Dune, Cabaret, The Fifth Element k55f5r Feb 2024 #65
Alien would be in my top five Shermann Feb 2024 #77
Barfly enid602 Feb 2024 #67
The Sound of Music. Missing. Platoon. My Brilliant Career. applegrove Feb 2024 #71
West Side Story (original one, from 1960s)... Jrose Feb 2024 #76
Gladiator Groundhawg Feb 2024 #78
The Princess Bride FalloutShelter Feb 2024 #80
Wings of Desire eyewall Feb 2024 #82
Wow! What a great list of excellent movies solara Feb 2024 #83
All About Eve... choie Feb 2024 #84
The Iron Giant and It's a Wonderful Life. Stuart G Feb 2024 #85
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Classic Films»WHAT is your Favorite Mov...»Reply #34