Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

astral

(2,531 posts)
24. x
Mon Aug 10, 2015, 10:03 AM
Aug 2015

i love Donna's voice with the Dead! i read or heard somewhere that the monitor feedback was sometime set up to where she could not hear her voice on stage. in my early Dead days i used to wonder how come Jerry got to sing the lead on most of the songs (lol!) whereas he did not seem to have the best voice. And they all had their bad sound days and sometimes it sounded as if they couldnt carry a tune at all and didnt give a damn. But listening to Bobby sing (songs be didnt write) I believe he is the off-key culprit. i love Bob's voice, though, and also Phil's. sure i learned to love Jerry's voice too, but not really til he started to grow on me, and also i started to hear the Jerry Garcia Band.

i am mystified anyone doesnt adore the Grateful Dead. they make me sing, although its not something i would torture anyone with hearing, some of their songs give me goosebumps, and often make me cry. perhaps having seen them live and having heard and tried to play their music and having it associated with younger periods of my life, sometimes I go through periods where i don't want to hear the Dead, in their many versions and combinations, bc i dont want to feel things deeply and i dont want to cry, and some songs it is near impossible to not sing along to and i just dont want to go there. other times, it’s all I listen to. there's so much variety to what they do. did. do. (Donna's music after the dead is pretty cool, too! although her voice is different.)

like i heard perfectly described (somewhere?) -- there is the Grateful Dead and then there's everybody else.

if you dont love them yet, just listen some more (LOL!) I do not love *all* their songs, but then the great instrumentals can also be hidden in the songs i dont like... depends on the day, the hour of the version of the song...

Was this during the Donna Godchaux years 1972-79? NightWatcher Aug 2015 #1
No. This is a male singer. There was an off key singer in the days when there were only males japple Aug 2015 #2
Donna Jean could carry a tune in the studio, her bailiwick Brother Buzz Aug 2015 #16
Phil had a reputation peacefreak Aug 2015 #3
That was going to be my guess. GoCubsGo Aug 2015 #4
Any of them who sing are not strong singers. And I'm a big admirer of the music The Second Stone Aug 2015 #5
I agree with just about all that. Except for Brent Mydland. Hassin Bin Sober Aug 2015 #6
I hated Vince's tinny keyboards. Didn't much care for his voice The Second Stone Aug 2015 #9
+1 for Dick's Picks Scuba Aug 2015 #23
I'll join in with my stuff: As someone blessed/cursed with perfect pitch, the whole band was.. BlueJazz Aug 2015 #7
auto tune has destroyed music mackerel Aug 2015 #8
It has hurt professional music a great deal and the artistry behind it The Second Stone Aug 2015 #11
I'm tone deaf in my singing much of the time, and I cannot imagine how someone with perfect The Second Stone Aug 2015 #10
You get it. Music is supposed to bring joy to the listener. We don't like exactly the same food ... BlueJazz Aug 2015 #13
I'd guess Jerry too cemaphonic Aug 2015 #12
That was my thinking as well. When they sing some of the bluegrass standards, japple Aug 2015 #14
Hi, japple! Enthusiast Aug 2015 #15
Peggy-O antiquie Aug 2015 #17
Yes, Peggy-O is a favorite. Enthusiast Aug 2015 #18
I listened to a bit of this and couldn't tell who sang which part! japple Aug 2015 #19
Your opinion of the Grateful Dead Enthusiast Aug 2015 #20
I thought they all were off-key. kwassa Aug 2015 #21
I'm a big Dead fan Munificence Aug 2015 #22
Honey child, I wasn't dissing the Dead, so don't get your feathers japple Aug 2015 #25
x astral Aug 2015 #24
At times, they were ALL the "off-key singer in thr group." Miles Archer Aug 2015 #26
the Deads strength was in their accessibility olddots Aug 2015 #27
Off key, Rumbustious Aug 2021 #28
welcome to DU gopiscrap Aug 2021 #29
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Question about Grateful D...»Reply #24