General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)War vs Peace [View all]
Q: Speaking of land, what do you think of a homeland for the Palestinians?
Chief Paul Waterman: They own land. They always have. There is enough room for them and the Jews. This conflict isnt just about land. Its about who controls the land that produces money. Its not about religion. The Creator isnt taking sides in a conflict over money.
(From the interview I did with Onondaga Chief Waterman, shortly after 9/11.)
The violence in Gaza is unacceptable. No matter if one favors the Israelis or the Palestinians, the level of violence that is destroying human lives is terribly wrong. That people have strong feelings about who is at fault is understandable. Yet it is the emotional currents that sweep rational thinking away, and leaves death and destruction in its wake.
Over the many years that I knew Chief Waterman, I came to recognize him as one of the wisest human beings I had met. The Onondaga Nation, which serves as the Fire Keepers of the Six Nations Iroquois Confederacy, has long held other tribal peoples around the globe in high regard. This, of course, includes the Israelis. It also includes the Palestinians.
Yet, I do not completely agree with Pauls position on this topic. Land is certainly a central issue in the conflict in the Middle East. This includes the idea of controlling land that the Israelis believe is necessary to secure their peoples safety. The Jewish experience, and not limited to the horrors of Nazi Germany, is obviously a significant factor which explains Israels foreign policy. One does not have to believe that this justifies any or all of that nations recent behaviors, to appreciate that thinking.
Add to this the frequency of threats to destroy Israel by some of the Islamic extremists from that region of the world, and we see why, at least in their own minds, the current leaders of Israel engage in the often brutal behaviors that we see too often. I am reminded of something that basketball great Bill Russell said: Chose your enemies carefully, for they are often who you come to resemble most closely.
The experiences of the Palestinians is also a story of great suffering. By and large, they have been the victims of a modern world that places little or no value upon their well-being. Land that is historically theirs has been stolen from them. Their only real compensation has been a culture of poverty, which no one would consider a good deal.
In many instances, which tend to be ignored, the average people in this region get along without hatred. This, too, is a part of the human experience. Its far easier to fear and despise a group of people you dont know, compared to individuals who you know as neighbors. Obviously, this is not always the case -- there are people whos being is so saturated with hatred, that they will always pose a threat to others. Yet, I think of a recent middleweight contender, an Israeli who trained in a Palestinian gym. This created a mutual respect between those individuals. While it is but one tiny example, it shows that people can get along. For hatred is nor inherent -- rather, it is a passion that must be taught and practiced, not completely unlike boxing skills.
Being an old man, living in the wilderness, I often prefer to read (and re-read) books on a given topic, rather than limit my thinking to the materials provided by the mass-media. Ive picked out two books, to carry out to my pond for my afternoon reading. One is Thomas Cahills The Gifts of the Jews: Desert Nomads Changed the World With the Word. The second is Reza Aslans Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth.
I find myself wondering why neither the Israelis nor Palestinians are producing non-violent leadership -- not within that group that are identified as political leaders per say, and not even limited to their religious leadership. I do remember that Ho Chi Minh said that Gandhi was fortunate to be opposed to the British Empire, for if he attempted his campaign against the French, he would have died, unknown, as soon as he started.
Still, I am convinced that there is no military solution to the current warfare, much less the ongoing cycle of violence in the Middle East. Indeed, the only long-term resolution could come only from brave individuals who are willing to risk peace. And that really should come from both sides.
These are troubling times we live in. I am going out to my pond, to spend the day reading, praying for peace and justice to break out, and to feed the fish and birds.
Peace,
H2O Man