Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Federal Wildlife Agents Shoot 14 Wolves from Helicopters [View all]ProgressiveProfessor
(22,144 posts)44. Citations are not always required, despite your fetish for them.
"..the white-tailed deer has reached record populations in many states and will continue to grow. Densities may exceed 40 deer per square mile in some rural areas.."
http://wildlifecontrol.info/deer/pages/deerpopulationfacts.aspx
http://wildlifecontrol.info/deer/pages/deerpopulationfacts.aspx
That citation you used in post 27 is a poor basis for discussion of deer herds in Idaho since the site clearly has an east coast focus. That does not make it wrong, but limits its applicability to the western states. What is accurate in New York about white tail deer populations is not true in Idaho and Montana. That is important since predators were being culled to preserve the game animal herds, while in the east, they could use some predators, not that the populace would go along with that.
In post 32 I pointed out the dramatic differences between the western and eastern US when it comes to deer herds, due to the lack of predators in the east. I also discussed in CA due to the ban of hunting cougars, the deer herds were even smaller.
Like many others, you seem to believe that deer are as plentiful in the western US as they are in the eastern US. A clear fallacy for any number of reasons. In the eastern US, deer over population is a serious problem. There are few if any natural predators for deer in places like Maryland or Vermont. They take out cars and motorcycles with some regularity. Its different out west where there are wolves, cougars, etc that do prey on deer. Deer are not nearly the nuisance that they are back east. Finally there is California where in 1990 Prop 117 banned the hunting of cougars. The result was a population growth in the big cats, who's primary prey is deer. Eventually Malthus caught up with them too, and we had a spate of attacks on humans. Things have balanced out somewhat since then, but the California deer herds have never recovered. My comment about asking any California deer hunter was sarcastic, since most go to Utah and elsewhere to hunt...the deer are that sparse here and plentiful over there. The data that supports the above is clearly available form the California Dept of Fish and Game. The page titled "Long Term Trends in California's Deer Population" is somewhat misleading, you need to dig to find the census data deeper down.
Everything I said could indeed have citations, but they are well known and obvious to anyone with knowledge in the field. . However if you want to argue against obvious facts, we might have a flat earth group around here somewhere on DU3
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
56 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
When it comes to wildlife and wilderness, in particular, this administration is as abysmal
villager
Mar 2012
#23
Yup. This, to me, is one of his biggest failings..and yet it gets surprisingly little play...
truebrit71
Mar 2012
#38
Neither the prey nor the predators restrict themselves to NPS boundaries
ProgressiveProfessor
Mar 2012
#14
Elk is much better eating that deer...that does not sound like trophy hunting to me
ProgressiveProfessor
Mar 2012
#25
"Elk is much better eating than deer", so you're not arguing for "subsistence hunting" anymore?
red dog 1
Mar 2012
#27
Your cited source is less than accurate...just ask any deer hunter in California.
ProgressiveProfessor
Mar 2012
#28
"Your cited source is less than accurate...just ask any deer hunter in California"??
red dog 1
Mar 2012
#29
"You then made false statements about deer populations"........"I rebutted them"?
red dog 1
Mar 2012
#39
One of our Oregon wolves from NE Oregon was tracked from there into California and is now
DeschutesRiver
Mar 2012
#43
This is a "No Brainer" for Obama. It keeps the hunters happy, and saves wolves lives as well/
red dog 1
Mar 2012
#31
Actually humans control other predators so there will be more prey for humans to consume
ProgressiveProfessor
Mar 2012
#49
My point was it is not about the shooting, its about the consumption
ProgressiveProfessor
Mar 2012
#51