General Discussion

exoskeleton

(44 posts)

55. This is the right answer.

Tue May 7, 2024, 08:59 AM

May 7

Not all Jewish people agree with Netanyahu. Not all Republicans agree with Trump. It just seems like those with the lowest control of their sphincter spew the most excrement.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

69 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Is blaming US Jews for Israel's policies anti-semitic? [View all] ripcord May 6 OP

Absofuckinglutely! 50 Shades Of Blue May 6 #1

Agree debm55 May 6 #27

Post removed Post removed May 6 #2

And yet it's a concept some people have trouble with unblock May 6 #4

I wish that were true! Unfortunately it has been made very relevant, your protestations notwithstanding. tritsofme May 6 #18

Yes, clearly is Johnny2X2X May 6 #3

Blaming any Jew for Israel's policies is anti-semitic. GumboYaYa May 6 #5

yes but isnt netanyahu jewish? many seem to blame him for Israel policies nt msongs May 6 #7

LOL, I should have made that exception. GumboYaYa May 6 #9

Is it also okay to blame those who support his policies? Redleg May 6 #24

Does anyone have room in their condemnations to blame Hamas wnylib May 6 #39

Of course. Eko May 6 #42

Hamas doesn't lead a democratic government and hasn't been subjected to elections in nearly 20 years. Crunchy Frog May 7 #61

I have blamed Hamas plenty Redleg May 8 #69

If it was just Bibi, then Israel wouldn't be a democracy. Crunchy Frog May 7 #60

Netanyahu is not a US Jew. He is a corrupt, self-interested, right wing Israeli politician. N/T lapucelle May 6 #29

Is Netanyahu a US Jew? lapucelle May 6 #26

Isn't the OP about blaming US Jews for Israel's policies, and not about Netanyahu? wnylib May 6 #33

Agree 100%!! AloeVera May 6 #10

This is the right answer. exoskeleton May 7 #55

Many if not most American Jews and many in not most Israelis do NOT support Bibi Netanyahu LetMyPeopleVote May 6 #6

What's that got to do with the OP topic of blaming wnylib May 6 #35

Yes mcar May 6 #8

It can be. Eko May 6 #11

Which Israeli policies are you referring to? wnylib May 6 #36

It doesnt have anything to do with ones I support or dont support. Eko May 6 #41

"israeli policies" is a sweeping statement that needs clarification. wnylib May 6 #44

The whole question was a sweeping statement. Eko May 6 #45

There's also lots of room to blame America's hard core Christians. Crunchy Frog May 7 #62

I don't know if it's anti-Semitic... appmanga May 6 #12

Absolutely! JustAnotherGen May 6 #13

"Is blaming US Jews for Israel's policies anti-semitic?" J_William_Ryan May 6 #14

Yes Progressive dog May 6 #15

I find this to be a really strange question for anyone on DU. Biophilic May 6 #16

Yes it is. comradebillyboy May 6 #17

Yes, unless Diraven May 6 #19

... lapucelle May 6 #30

This! sheshe2 May 6 #32

"A viable two-state agreement is only attainable if America's support for Israel is ironclad... Martin Eden May 7 #49

There is no unconditional US aid that is funding expansion. N/T lapucelle May 7 #58

So then, which of our aid is conditional? Martin Eden May 7 #59

Sorry. That doesn't work on me. lapucelle May 7 #67

Ignoring the fact that Netenyahu IS the far right, Crunchy Frog May 7 #63

Seems that they have a couple Palestinian counterparts wnylib May 6 #43

How influential are they in US politics compared to AIPAC? Crunchy Frog May 7 #64

I don't understand the basis of the question. grumpyduck May 6 #20

An interesting take. Beastly Boy May 6 #25

Given what i read in the news nowadays, grumpyduck May 6 #38

Jews are not Israelis. Israelis are not the Netanyahu Government. brooklynite May 6 #21

Yep Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin May 6 #22

Simple question, simple answer sarisataka May 6 #23

Yup, including in this VERY thread. Behind the Aegis May 7 #46

Yes RandySF May 6 #28

Of course. Further, not even all Israelis are to blame for Israel's policies. Silent3 May 6 #31

Yes. sheshe2 May 6 #34

It's A Stupid Generalization HandmaidsTaleUntold May 6 #37

Yes Joinfortmill May 6 #40

ANY broad-brush casting of BLAME on the basis of race, creed, religion is WRONG Martin Eden May 7 #47

Yes SocialDemocrat61 May 7 #48

Yes. Oopsie Daisy May 7 #50

Yes. betsuni May 7 #51

Yes, because "American Jews" are NOT a monolith. no_hypocrisy May 7 #52

Yes catrose May 7 #53

Yes, of course! nt ecstatic May 7 #54

Yes ismnotwasm May 7 #56

Can we revisit the topic again tomorrow? Chakaconcarne May 7 #57

100%, no question. nt LexVegas May 7 #65

Yes! peggysue2 May 7 #66

Absolutely and liberalhistorian May 7 #68