Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Wonder Why

(3,205 posts)
Sun Feb 25, 2024, 12:49 PM Feb 25

A sad story of what happens when you privatize a major non-profit hospital [View all]

Years ago, there were two big non-profit hospitals in Asheville, Mission and St. Joseph's. Many years ago, they joined forces and became one. Not necessarily bad thing for non-profits as they could work together for the common good. Being the only "big" city on Western NC, they were pretty dominant. In recent years, they began to absorb some of the businesses from smaller hospitals in other towns who either could not provide the facilities, afford the increasing expense of newer technology or had other problems. Not necessarily a good thing but again, a good non-profit should benefit, not hurt, a community. They were the go-to place for Cardiac care and had an excellent reputation.

Then the disaster began. They decided to sell out their community by selling to mega-private Hospital HCA. As a non-profit, they could not do that without approvals because of their non-profit status. With a lot of wheeler-dealing and negative input from the community, they sold Mission for $4B which was to be used for the community. I'm not sure the community ever really benefited but the sale surely did not. That's another issue.

As HCA took over, they dumped more work and lots of terminations on the staff in order to increase profitability. There were lots of complaints from doctors, nurses, staff and patients. Doctors, whose group was associated with them, left their orbit and joined that of the neighboring county's Pardee Hospital, a county-owned facility which didn't have the reputation of leadership in particular care but got awesome reviews of the quality and caring services they provided. As Pardee grew, becoming a highly rated hospital in Consumer Reports national list, so did Mission fall over the cliff.

Just today, there is an outstanding article in a local Henderson County newspaper which I would consider moderate to left in a sea of MAGAT voters trying to thread the fine line between not having enough income and telling the whole truth. It tells of what is happening now and is a warning, IMHO, what the future of privatization means. Please read it fully. It is not long but is well written and deserves recognition. The wrath of Medicare and multiple lawsuits are now in progress.

Mission faces deadline to fix deficiencies

35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
All healthcare should be publicly owned and operated. NT. Voltaire2 Feb 25 #1
Yep. Cuba does it. Marcus IM Feb 25 #3
Not necessarily. Our non-profit hospital is far better than the VA Hospital I also use. While it is Wonder Why Feb 25 #6
If it's owned by the county it is publicly owned. Voltaire2 Feb 25 #7
It was built and paid for by a private donor who gave a huge donation to get it going long ago. It is not Wonder Why Feb 25 #8
It's still publicly owned, no matter who donated the money Warpy Feb 25 #10
The contention of the poster I replied to had the additive AND OPERATED. That is the critical thing. Wonder Why Feb 25 #19
Does it have shareholders, whose interest by law marybourg Feb 25 #14
++ appalachiablue Feb 25 #12
Shitty? tom_kelly Feb 25 #17
That's a strong no from this provider with my own private practice tulipsandroses Feb 25 #22
Similar story in CT and PA - Prospect Medical Holdings RandomNumbers Feb 25 #2
Sadly, counties aren't willing to -- or can't - fund their modern hospital systems. Thus, they turn to private entities. Silent Type Feb 25 #4
Nurses on Reddit hate HCA facilities ismnotwasm Feb 25 #5
"What Happens When Private Equity Takes Over a Hospital" -- Harvard Medical School Gaugamela Feb 25 #9
+1 leftstreet Feb 25 #11
Thanks, people need to know the truth about PE. Soon. appalachiablue Feb 25 #13
It needs to be fixed DownriverDem Feb 25 #15
Medicare Advantage is a corporate enterprise paid for by taxpayers. Big Blue Marble Feb 25 #23
Medicaid is managed the same way as traditional Medicare - not for profit. yellowdogintexas Feb 25 #31
True the funding is from the federal and state governments. Big Blue Marble Feb 25 #32
Insurances won't pay for ambulance to take patients to ER's farther away either wishstar Feb 25 #16
It would appear... GiqueCee Feb 25 #18
America isn't alone. No country has been able to figure out how to have good healthcare systems. Marcus IM Feb 25 #20
You do know that many have better patient outcomes than we do? Big Blue Marble Feb 25 #24
Yes. Did you see the sarcasm smiley? Marcus IM Feb 25 #27
Whoops! Big Blue Marble Feb 25 #33
Totally cool. Marcus IM Feb 25 #34
Somehow private equity needs to be prevented from buying our healthcare facilities. Lonestarblue Feb 25 #21
Private equity firms are insidiously destroying the American way of life FakeNoose Feb 25 #26
+1 dalton99a Feb 25 #29
The local HCA owned hospital misdiagnosed my cancer xmas74 Feb 25 #25
HCA is Evil Incarnate. nt yellowdogintexas Feb 25 #28
hmmm, HCA..where have I heard that acromyn before? onethatcares Feb 25 #30
We desperately need gov. regulation of healthcare. area51 Feb 25 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A sad story of what happe...