General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Gen Z Is Listening to What Netanyahu Is Saying. Is Biden? [View all]Martin Eden
(12,875 posts)Last edited Sat Jan 27, 2024, 08:44 AM - Edit history (1)
Obviously, the Israeli prime minister and his intelligence services were tragically mistaken.
Was it really that difficult to assess the intent of Hamas, given their sworn goal to eradicate the Jewish state? While the cash and the work permits marginally improved conditions in the Gaza strip, it hardly satisfied the statehood aspirations of the Palestinian people or resolved the overall conflict evidenced by the ongoing violent flare-ups in Jerusalem and the West Bank.
The conflict is one of seemingly irreconcilable differences between two peoples who both want the same relatively small land of what was once Palestine on older maps, but is now Israel.
How can this be resolved, especially given the historical religious significance of Jerusalem as the center of a Holy Land for Jews, Muslims, and Christians?
Palestinians are unwilling to accept disapora, departing their homeland with their people scattered as residents into other Arab countries.
The Jewish people who survived the Holocaust had historical roots in the Holy Land, and understandably believed their future depended on having their own nation state where they would not be a minority subject to shifting tides of prejudice against them.
As an American born in 1957 who has followed politics since the Vietnam War, the only solution I can think of to resolve this conflict is for the two peoples to learn to live together peacefully in a single nation.
I have never been religious, but do have some understanding of the compelling significance Jerusalem and the Holy Land has for the people of all three major Abrahamic religions. If they truly embrace the core tenets of their faiths which all worship the monotheistic God of Abraham, should not Jerusalem be an international city of peace and brotherhood?
Yes, I know the two-state solution has long been embraced by the United States and much of the international community, but I really don't see ANY Israeli government forcibly removing West Bank settlers from their homes (some of which have been lived in for generations) -- especially as a series of events triggered by the Oct 7 atrocity committed by Hamas.
Perhaps, almost certainly, the single state of peace and brotherhood is an even more unlikely scenario.
And so we go on. The long history of horrible violence between the faithful is an inescapable feature of human civilization.