Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

SDANation

(419 posts)
Sat Mar 7, 2020, 02:36 PM Mar 2020

Just a word on why masks are useless to general public [View all]

So at the hospital, if we are to receive a Covid-19 patient, we are to place the patient in a negative pressure room with enhanced and airborne contact precautions.

Enhanced contact means gown, gloves and MANDATORY hand washing with chlorhexidine wash, no hand sanitizer.

Airborne means we are required to wear N95 masks. At the start of every year, in our facility we are MANDATED to do fit testing. Fit testing is done every year because people gain and lose weight and mask “fitness” changes. We are fit tested for tuberculosis primarily.

During this fit testing, first your face is sized to mask size. Then the tester places a hood on you and sprays and cloyingly sweet spray into the hood. Then you are asked to count to 10 while moving your head up and down left and right. At the conclusion, they ask you if you can taste any of the spray. If no, you pass and that is the mask that will protect you from airborne virus, they have you remove the mask and breathe and the taste makes you want to gag. If you taste that godawful stuff, you won’t forget it and have to try a different mask.

If you taste it, it means that tiny particles can still reach your airway, putting you at risk of exposure.

So if covid 19 is as infectious as is assumed, if you are not fit tested in this manner, this is why the CDC is saying it won’t protect you. You’re more likely to pick it up through contact, so that’s why they are saying hand washing may be more effective.

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Not only the need for fit testing, but likewise training in removing without self-contamination hlthe2b Mar 2020 #1
Exactly! SDANation Mar 2020 #2
Regarding masks customerserviceguy Mar 2020 #3
Not really csziggy Mar 2020 #6
It is also absurd to claim that the masks are useless to the general public... Kaleva Mar 2020 #8
Interesting studies and we can hope they are true csziggy Mar 2020 #12
I bought masks in January but don't intend to use them unless there's outbreaks in my area. Kaleva Mar 2020 #16
CDC recommends N95 masking for healthcare workers SDANation Mar 2020 #14
Most of us aren't health care workers Kaleva Mar 2020 #15
That's what I'm trying to convey SDANation Mar 2020 #17
I've cited several studies that found that masks can be effective. Kaleva Mar 2020 #19
Yes, the articles that talk about the flu SDANation Mar 2020 #21
But they are transmited much the same way. Kaleva Mar 2020 #24
Yes, but covid is smaller and they are still trying to nail down SDANation Mar 2020 #27
But COVID-19, like flu viruses, can ride on droplets or dust particles which facemasks can stop Kaleva Mar 2020 #31
your "next to useless" is the part stopdiggin Mar 2020 #26
It's not gear. It's a disposable mask. SDANation Mar 2020 #28
And the articles are based on the Flu not Covid 19. SDANation Mar 2020 #29
so you're sticking with "next to useless?" stopdiggin Mar 2020 #32
No, sticking with standard of practice SDANation Mar 2020 #33
Then health-care workers customerserviceguy Mar 2020 #9
Since the "leader" for communication right now in the USA is Pence csziggy Mar 2020 #22
Thanks for posting those videos customerserviceguy Mar 2020 #23
Here is an article on the CDC site about respirators csziggy Mar 2020 #30
Several studies say that masks can be effective. Kaleva Mar 2020 #4
CDC recommendation is to use N95 for protection SDANation Mar 2020 #13
I agree that N95 masks are a step up from facemasks. Kaleva Mar 2020 #25
This message was self-deleted by its author SDANation Mar 2020 #5
It's still better than nothing. silverweb Mar 2020 #7
Masks are just one tool in the toolbox. Kaleva Mar 2020 #10
Of course. silverweb Mar 2020 #11
I'd do some more reading about adding oils to masks before doing so. Kaleva Mar 2020 #18
PubMed has quite a bit. silverweb Mar 2020 #20
Virus also enter through eyes. How to protect them? As far as "it wouldn't hurt"... uppityperson Mar 2020 #35
Perhaps glasses to help protect the eyes? silverweb Mar 2020 #37
I think the mistake you are making is equating the needs of health care workers with the public Kaleva Mar 2020 #34
Masks good for something I never considered... RealityChik Mar 2020 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Just a word on why masks ...