SunSeeker
SunSeeker's JournalThe Democrats Are Screwing Up the Resistance to Donald Trump
The Democrats Are Screwing Up the Resistance to Donald Trump -
How Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren misread the election.
By Jamelle Bouie
...
At first glance, this seems well and good: a firm commitment to winning victories where they are available, tied to an absolute line against policies targeting immigrants, Muslims, or any other group. But theres a problem here, and its found in the cast given to Trumps campaign and Trumps voters. Both Warren and Sanders describe Trumps effort as a populist campaign with an almost incidental use of racial prejudice. In this version, most Trump voters simply wanted a stronger, fairer economy. The attacks on immigrants, Muslims, and black Americans were regrettable, but not a part of the appeal.
Warren and Sanders are wrong, and in a way that signals a significant misreading of the landscape on the part of the most influential Democrats. The simple truth is that Trumps use of explicit racismhis deliberate attempt to incite Americans against different groups of nonwhiteswas integral to his campaign. It was part and parcel of his populism and told a larger story: that either at home or abroad, foreigners and their globalist allies were cheating the American worker, defined as a white working-class man with a factory job. To claw back the dominion he once enjoyedto make America great againTrump promised protectionism and law and order. He promised to deport immigrants, register Muslims, and build new infrastructure. This wasnt populism; it was white populism. Writes historian Nell Irvin Painter for the New York Times: This time the white men in charge will not simply happen to be white; they will be governing as white, as taking America back, back to before multiculturalism.
It seems reasonable for Warren and Sanders to make a distinction between Trump as blue-collar populist and Trump as racist demagogue. But that distinction doesnt exist. Supporting a Trump-branded infrastructure initiative as a discrete piece of policy where two sides can find common ground only bolsters a white-nationalist politics, even if you oppose the rest of Trumps agenda. It legitimizes and gives fuel to white tribalism as a political strategy. It shows that there are tangible gains for embracing Trump-style demagoguery. Likewise, it seems reasonable to want to recast support for Trump as an expression of populism. But Trumps is a racial populismbacked almost entirely by white Americans, across class linesthat revolves around demands to reinforce existing racial and status hierarchies. Thats what it means to make America great again. It has nothing to offer to working-class blacks who need safety from unfair police violence just as much as they need higher wages, or working-class Latinos who need to protect their families from draconian immigration laws as much as they need a chance to unionize.
To gesture at individual voters and say they arent raciststhe usual rejoinder to this argumentis to miss the point. White voters backed Trump as a bloc. They ignored his bigotry and elevated his call for a new nationalism, centered on white Americans. Whatever their actual intentionswhether they were partisan Republicans, hardcore Trumpists, or simply disgusted with Hillary Clintonthey voted for white nationalism, full stop.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2016/11/the_democrats_are_already_screwing_up_the_trump_resistance.html
Profile Information
Gender: Do not displayHome country: USA
Current location: Southern California
Member since: Sun Mar 20, 2011, 12:05 PM
Number of posts: 51,745