Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Divernan

(15,480 posts)
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 05:00 PM Jul 2015

"Hillary Clinton attends Fox Chapel fundraiser as poll numbers sag"

There are 2 competing newspapers in the Pittsburgh/southwestern PA area. One is the conservative Tribune-Review, long owned and subsidized by the recently deceased billionaire, Richard Scaiffe. Scaiffe endorsed HRC in 2008, and donated to the Clinton Foundation, and Bill Clinton gave the eulogy at Scaiffe's memorial service. The other paper is the traditionally Democratic leaning Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. I've given links to both articles.

The conservative Trib was at the fundraiser, interviewed many of the guests and had lots of pictures of HRC both outside and inside the estate. The Post-Gazette? An old photo of Clinton from last May in Las Vegas, a photo of the backs of cars lined up on a road awaiting entrance to the estate (along with a caption,"Cars line up on Hawthorne Road from Fox Chapel Road, heading to a private fundraiser this morning for Hillary Clinton. Security personnel said only invited guests were allowed down the street during the event.&quot and a picture of HRC with a handicapped young man, provided to the Post Gazette by his father, who would have been required to donate $2700 for having his son's photo taken w/HRC. The PG article stated the event was closed to the press. It seems the conservative/Scaiffe paper was allowed to attend the event, while the Democratic paper was frozen out. Do read the comments of the readers to both papers. There are some very harsh and nasty opinions of HRC there. They substantiate the prediction that if HRC is the candidate, she will increase the turnout of Republicans who harbor very negative (to put it mildly) feelings for her.

From the Trib:
(Headline) "Hillary Clinton attends Fox Chapel fundraiser as poll numbers sag"

Hillary Clinton made a quiet entrance into a private fundraiser Wednesday as her motorcade pulled into the driveway of a Fox Chapel home about 10 miles northeast of Downtown Pittsburgh. The “Conversations with Hillary” fundraiser, expected to draw about 100 to 125 attendees, requested a minimum contribution of $1,000 per person, according to the email invitation Clinton's campaign finance team issued.

Clinton's fundraising blitz comes as a new Quinnipiac University Swing State Poll shows her numbers sagging in several key states and her favorability falling. Guests shelling out $2,700 get a photo with Clinton. Individuals who bundle supporters to raise $10,000 become event co-hosts. For $27,000, they get to be event hosts and secure membership in the campaign's Hillstarters program.

Released Wednesday, the poll of registered voters suggests Republican contenders Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida, former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker all lead Clinton in Colorado, Iowa and Virginia in potential head-to-head matchups. She led all three in an April 9 Quinnipiac poll. Voters' favorability was below 50 percent in all three states: 35 percent in Colorado, 33 percent in Iowa and 41 percent in Virginia.

“Hillary Clinton's numbers have dropped among voters in the key swing states of Colorado, Iowa and Virginia. She has lost ground in the horserace and on key questions about her honesty and leadership,” said Peter A. Brown, assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Poll. “On being a strong leader, a key metric in presidential campaigns, she has dropped four to 10 points depending on the state and she is barely above 50 percent in each of the three states.” Later Wednesday, Clinton is scheduled to attend a fundraiser at a home in Raleigh, N.C.

Read more: http://triblive.com/politics/politicalheadlines/8761531-74/clinton-campaign-fundraiser#ixzz3geVS2ujZ
Follow us: @triblive on Twitter | triblive on Facebook

And in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:

Hillary Clinton appears at private fundraiser in Fox Chapel
Presidential candidate and former first lady Hillary Clinton was scheduled to make a stop in the Pittsburgh area this morning for a private fundraiser.

Clinton, also former secretary of state, was to appear at the Fox Chapel home of Cynthia Shapira, the wife of David Shapira, the executive chairman of Giant Eagle’s board of directors.

The Clinton event was closed to the press and the candidate had no public events scheduled during her brief Pittsburgh trip. A spokesman for her campaign said they would have no comment on the visit or how much money they hoped to reap from it.

http://137.117.100.210/news/politics-nation/2015/07/22/Hillary-Clinton-appearing-at-private-fundraiser-in-Fox-Chapel/stories/201507220176
13 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Divernan

(15,480 posts)
5. Thanks.My OP was so long, didn't want to get into the sordid Clinton-Scaife history
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 06:36 PM
Jul 2015

Given the history of bitter, bitter hatred between the Clintons and Scaiffe, one wonders what on earth quid pro quo HRC promised Scaiffe in exchange for his personal and paper's endorsement. It sure shocked the hell out of both conservatives and democrats. She lost that presidential primary, and he's since died, so we'll never know.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
11. Thank You ...Here's an Excerpt from the Article:
Thu Jul 23, 2015, 01:55 PM
Jul 2015

After what Richard Mellon Scaife put the Clintons and the Country through--it sure seems strange that the Clinton's cozied up to him...but the article explains some of it:

From the Politico Article:

Speaking at a private memorial service in southwestern Pennsylvania for Richard Mellon Scaife, who died last month, Clinton recalled how, after his presidency, he built a “counterintuitive friendship” with the conservative billionaire, according to an account of the speech in one of the newspapers Scaife owned.
“He fought as hard as he could for what he believed, but he never thought he had to be blind or deaf” to other views, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review quotes Clinton saying of its former publisher. A spokesman for Clinton declined to comment.

Scaife, who inherited a fortune from the Mellon banking and oil empire, steered millions of dollars to groups that savagely attacked the Clintons throughout the 1990s. Scaife backed media outlets and nonprofits that pushed scandal after scandal that buffeted the Clinton administration — from the Whitewater real estate controversy to the Paula Jones and Monica Lewinsky sex scandals to raising doubts about the deaths of Clinton aides Vince Foster and Ron Brown.

Scaife confidant Christopher Ruddy, who rose to prominence on the Clinton scandal beat at the Tribune-Review, arranged Clinton’s appearance at Saturday’s memorial. Afterward, he acknowledged his former boss “was the bete noire of the Clinton administration during those years, sort of like what the Kochs are to the Obama administration today.”


--------------
And Ruddy predicted that her husband’s willingness to reach across the aisle will cause some major Republican donors who fought the Clinton administration alongside Scaife to be less hostile if Hillary Clinton runs for president in 2016.

“There is a realization among high-level donors and sophisticated politicos on the Republican side that Hillary Clinton is a centrist Democrat who is pro-American business and is very strong on national security,” he said. “There is a sense that she and her husband share a similar worldview.”


Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2014/08/bill-clinton-richard-mellon-scaife-eulogy-109670.html#ixzz3gjo4r89X

Agony

(2,605 posts)
4. people with lots of money and power that promote damaging policy
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 06:06 PM
Jul 2015

are too often the ones that Hillary looks to to fund her campaign. In this case policy counter to her statements about concern for climate change.

Cynthia Shapira is on the Airport Authority board that allowed fracking on the Pittsburgh airport properties. Not that Hillary has been on the right side of the fracking/fossil fuels issue. So maybe this is not an accident and we should assume that this is a tacit endorsement by Hillary of fracking as appropriate energy policy?

Metric System

(6,048 posts)
6. "if HRC is the candidate, she will increase the turnout of Republicans" But Sanders the Socialist
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 06:36 PM
Jul 2015

will not? Folks on the Right don't like that word.

frylock

(34,825 posts)
7. People ave been waiting over 20 years to cast their vote against Clinton..
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 06:45 PM
Jul 2015

they will not be nearly as motivated to get out to vote against the scary socialist.

Divernan

(15,480 posts)
8. Sort of a reverse two for the price of one
Wed Jul 22, 2015, 06:59 PM
Jul 2015

They see voting against her as also voting against Bill. I don't know of anyone who likes or dislikes only one of the Clintons. They have always presented themselves as a package deal and that is how they are regarded.

blue neen

(12,328 posts)
9. I don't see where The Trib was actually inside at the fundraiser.
Thu Jul 23, 2015, 06:36 AM
Jul 2015

It looks like they were outside.

The picture of the inside of the house with Hillary was provided by an attendee, Andi Irwin. Check the picture credit. All other pictures are taken outside.

"Andi Irwin, 41, an artist from Squirrel Hill, said she last saw Clinton during a Downtown event at the Rivers Club during her 2008 campaign, when Irwin thought Clinton came off as “very tense.”

“I definitely left (the fundraiser) more inspired than last time,” said Irwin, whose husband, Steven Irwin, is a Downtown attorney. “She was so much warmer, and she just seemed really relaxed. She seems to have really evolved as a candidate and as a politician.”

Read more: http://triblive.com/politics/politicalheadlines/8761531-74/clinton-campaign-fundraiser#ixzz3gi2PXM00

The Trib also made sure they included pictures of the protestors outside. Both articles had quotes from attendees. Only the Trib made any mention of poll numbers.

Divernan

(15,480 posts)
10. I think the Trib reporter & photog were invited guests and here's why.
Thu Jul 23, 2015, 08:36 AM
Jul 2015

6 of 7 Trib photos were by Trib photographer (The Trib photographer was Andrew Russell/Trib Total Media.) 5 of those were inside the grounds of estate, 1 (of Onorato) was on the private road where only invited guests were allowed.

By contrast, the only Post Gazette photo by its photographer,(credited to "DarrellSapp/Post Gazette&quot was of the backs of cars lined up down a road & was captioned:

Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette: Cars line up on Hawthorne Road from Fox Chapel Road, heading to a private fundraiser this morning for Hillary Clinton. Security personnel said only invited guests were allowed down the street during the event. my emphasis added to caption.


The Trib article featured 7 photos, 6 of those by its own photographer, Andrew Russell. 5 of Russell's photos were taken on the estate, such as HRC getting out of her car right by the front of the home. Based on the statement that only "invited guests" were allowed down the street, the Trib-Review's photographer was an invited guest.

The Trib Reporter referred to interviewing a "dozen or so" guests and got her story on line by around 3 p.m. that day. Although her report attributes quotes and opinions to others, the description of what HRC said does not quote others:
In Fox Chapel, Clinton stressed the importance of improving education options and mental health programs, pointing to her concerns over rapidly ballooning student loan debt and the nationwide heroin epidemic, according to several guests, who contributed either a minimum of $1,000 per person, $2,700 for a photo with Clinton or bundled $27,000 to secure membership in the campaign's Hillstarters program.

During a roughly 30-minute speech inside the home of Cindy Shapira — community activist and wife of the CEO of the Giant Eagle grocery chain — Clinton warned that her GOP competitors threaten to undo progress in health care she attributed to the Affordable Care Act. She lamented that President Obama has not received enough credit for the nation's recovery from the Great Recession.

Read more: http://triblive.com/politics/politicalheadlines/8761531-74/clinton-campaign-fundraiser#ixzz3giOfMSDf

According to standard journalism practices, the reporter heard these statements herself. Additionally, if the Trib reporter was not at the estate, she would have had to contact all the " nearly a dozen" attendees she quoted after they had returned to their various offices in downtown Pittsburgh/private homes/etc. Don't think she could possibly have done that and gotten her article on line by mid-afternoon.

Given the up close photos of people like Peduto standing right outside the house, and the fact that she got the story on line by around 3 p.m., and the fact that her report describes content of HRC's comments without attributing them as "according to (any guest)" it seems reasonable to conclude the Trib had both a photographer and a reporter as "invited guests" who were granted access to the private road and the estate itself, and that the reporter was inside, listening to HRC's talk.

Although no new photos have been added, the content and the headline of the Trib article have been updated, changed and/or expanded today - my comments were based on its original article. The quote you referred to was added in the update.

And to be very clear, my OP used yesterday's Trib's original headline - which the Trib also changed in the updated version today, and I referred to it specifically as the headline:
(Headline) "Hillary Clinton attends Fox Chapel fundraiser as poll numbers sag." I did not imply that both papers referred to the poll numbers. Again, I used the Trib's own headline as the lead for my thread - posters have been harshly criticized on DU for paraphrasing a headline from an OP's link, and included the PG's headline within the body of my post. I did not editorialize or change either headline.




blue neen

(12,328 posts)
13. No, you didn't imply that both papers referred to the poll numbers.
Thu Jul 23, 2015, 06:15 PM
Jul 2015

I just found it interesting that The Trib would include them.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
12. She was in North Carolina yesterday at one of those Private Fundraisers....
Thu Jul 23, 2015, 02:08 PM
Jul 2015

Small group of people at a private home and then off to meet with another group of high level fundraisers. All closed off. Reports got some shots of the outside of the private home but she didn't bother to even talk to the media. NC went for Obama in 2008 and it was close in 2012 but we got gerrymandered and voting hours were cut back after Repubs took over in 2010.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»"Hillary Clinton att...