2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumDear Liberals: Stop Complaining
by Michael Tomasky Jan 3, 2013 4:45 AM EST
Obama isnt Captain Liberal. Hes the president. And liberal pundits who are up in arms about the fiscal-cliff deal seem not to recognize the difference. By Michael Tomasky.
Heres my New Years resolution: Im going to read less liberal grousing about Barack Obama. At the moment, we have a number of critics of the deal Obama just cut with the Republicans to avert the fiscal cliff. They make some fair points, about the deal and about Obama. But if theres a style of criticism that really bugs me, its that which reproves him for failing to be Captain Liberal while refusing to recognize that the guy has to be Mister President. Heres what I mean.
The standard liberal position in the run-up to the cliff deal, or at least a position taken by a number of prominent liberals, was that Obama should have let the country go over the cliff, because hed immediately have more leverage after Jan. 1. Taxes would go up, the argument went, most of the country would blame the Republicans, and boomity-boomity-boom, theyd come crawling to Obama ready to sign a deal on his terms.
I will readily confess that the logic is, if not impeccable, only mildly peccable. The Republicans would have been over a barrel. Of course predicting what those people will do and how theyll respond to any given situation is risky business, but presumably they would not have wanted to be blamed for middle-class tax rates going up, so theyd have done something vaguely rational.
I get it. But heres what I think proponents of that argument dont get. Obama isnt some co-speaker. Hes the effing president. People want the president to lead. They may blame Republicans more than Democrats for obstruction, and thats a good thing. But they still want the president to Get Things Done, and, however naively, they still think he ought to be able to just assert his will and Get Things Done.
-snip-
continue reading:
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/01/03/dear-liberals-stop-complaining.html
AgingAmerican
(12,958 posts)n/t
One of the 99
(2,280 posts)Thanks for posting.
IDoMath
(404 posts)So stop telling us to sit down and shut up. When we stop complaining we can expect the government to completely stop work for us.
AgingAmerican
(12,958 posts)It is barely left of center.
IDoMath
(404 posts)In 1988 Dukakis ran screaming from the 'L' word. Around 2004 Terry McAulife told democrats to avoid the 'L' word and, instead use the word 'progressive' thereby watering down the meaning.
The Republican party of 1956 is to the left of the DP of 2008. In our "rush to the center" we allowed the wingnuts of the right to pull us over the line.
When Paul Wellstone votes to approve the PATRIOT Act and no one will back Sen Byrd's call to "slow down" before rushing into Iraq, you know something is haywire. The RealPolitik side of the party is in control. That side has one goal - winning. They will sacrifice whatever they need to in order to win.
The brains maybe leading the party but the heart is being cut out.
craigmatic
(4,510 posts)BlueCaliDem
(15,438 posts)where Michael writes, "Obama is not the leader of a movement - he's the leader of a country".
I wished more of the Professional Left understand this very true point.
and rec'd!
Norrin Radd
(4,959 posts)alcibiades_mystery
(36,437 posts)It is not only the right of the Left to complain mightily, it is our duty.
union_maid
(3,502 posts)In that it said that liberals should try to get the president to do liberal things as much as possible. It just is asking the far left to understand the difference between being president and being an advocate for one wing of one party.
1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)that liberals/progressives not pressure/advocate for a liberal/progressive agenda; but rather, as you have said on these pages, that liberals/progressive must accept the reality that the President's primary role is governing ... and governing, in our system of government, with divided government, sometimes requires not getting everything your partisan base would like.
octoberlib
(14,971 posts)1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)Myrina
(12,296 posts)So, no, I will NOT stop "complaining" -- for the sake of my country and the marginalized folks who've been trampled on by the 1% and the perpetual-corporate-apologists both in government and in the lobbying offices down the street.
frylock
(34,825 posts)then stop demanding my vote, assholes.
Filibuster Harry
(666 posts)that even while being obstructed by the Rs, but I will criticize when I think he deserves that. I don't know what either party's reaction would be if we were currently without a deal and over the cliff. I know both parties didn't want to go over it but it would have been interesting to see how much bargaining power the President would have with all those tax rates increasing especially the dividends tax on regular rates and the estate tax.
JoePhilly
(27,787 posts)Herlong
(649 posts)You are making our job of screwing you over so much harder!
craigmatic
(4,510 posts)of winning elections. Have we learned nothing from Bill Clinton? He sacrificed principles for power and all the centrist half measures he passed didn't last 2 years after he left office. In fact the 2 most centrist acts he passed DADT was corrupted by the republicans and the repeal of Glass-Stegal caused this recession.