Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Who and How Many Supreme Court Justices Will Be Retiring? (Original Post) romantico Nov 2012 OP
And you are hoping Ruth Bader Ginsburg retires WHY, exactly??? elleng Nov 2012 #1
Well romantico Nov 2012 #4
She is the oldest and pancreatic cancer is rough... Sekhmets Daughter Nov 2012 #6
Fully-agreed. BlueDemKev Nov 2012 #11
So she controls when she is replaced. Hosnon Nov 2012 #7
I feel Ginsburg has been holding on until asjr Nov 2012 #2
Agreed, she may not leave right away but she will retire before his second term is finished.... Sekhmets Daughter Nov 2012 #5
Scalia will not retire while a Democrat holds the WH...we can hope he chokes on his own bile Sekhmets Daughter Nov 2012 #3
He doesn't look healthy RomneyLies Nov 2012 #8
Lots of them...train car loads... Sekhmets Daughter Nov 2012 #13
as far as retirement defacto7 Nov 2012 #15
Realistically... TDale313 Nov 2012 #9
Here's a list of justices who died while holding the office. Not a long list. Gidney N Cloyd Nov 2012 #10
Maybe We'll Get Lucky Andy Stanton Nov 2012 #12
Ginsburg, Kennedy, and Bryer JiminyJominy Nov 2012 #14

romantico

(5,062 posts)
4. Well
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 10:43 PM
Nov 2012

Well, it's her health scare. I'd hate to see her stay in and God forbid have a Republican step in in 2016 and appoint a conservative judge when she eventually does retire. I also thought I heard her say something to the effect that she is thinking about it. Don't get me wrong, I like her. I'm just concerned with her health and age.

Sekhmets Daughter

(7,515 posts)
6. She is the oldest and pancreatic cancer is rough...
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 10:46 PM
Nov 2012

I think she won't gamble on the 2016 election and will retire during Obama's second term...

BlueDemKev

(3,003 posts)
11. Fully-agreed.
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 11:05 PM
Nov 2012

It's like William Brennan and Thurgood Marshall were holding on during the Reagan years hoping that a Democrat would be elected in '88 and then they could retire knowing that they'd be replaced by like-minded judges. Unfortunately, Dukakis blew it and the two men just couldn't hold on until Clinton came along in '92.

Hosnon

(7,800 posts)
7. So she controls when she is replaced.
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 10:49 PM
Nov 2012

Her health isn't top notch and her position is too valuable to risk it being filled by a Republican president.

Sekhmets Daughter

(7,515 posts)
3. Scalia will not retire while a Democrat holds the WH...we can hope he chokes on his own bile
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 10:43 PM
Nov 2012

but short of that it will be Bader-Ginsburg (which breaks my heart) and perhaps Justice Breyer....Clinton appointees. There is a slim chance Reagan appointee Anthony Kennedy may retire. He has never been as rabidly partisan as Scalia and Thomas.

defacto7

(13,485 posts)
15. as far as retirement
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 11:30 PM
Nov 2012

Scalia is old but unfortunately, he's in great health; he'll be around for a while. Thomas is not in good health. Other than Bader-Ginsburg retiring, he's the most likely to drop out because of health or just kick it. I don't know about Kennedy's health.

Scalia is the one I really want to see gone, but it's not likely.

TDale313

(7,820 posts)
9. Realistically...
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 10:50 PM
Nov 2012

Ginsburg and Breyer will probably retire and allow Obama to appoint someone left of center, protecting those two seats from the right wing crazies for the next 20, 25 years. Love to see any of the 4 more conservative justices retire, but feels unlikely. Possibly Scalia. The biggest game changer might be Kennedy. That would change the composition of the court dramatically, and he's no spring chicken.

Gidney N Cloyd

(19,847 posts)
10. Here's a list of justices who died while holding the office. Not a long list.
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 11:01 PM
Nov 2012

Justice James Wilson.....................1789 - 1798...............Washington
Justice William Cushing..................1790 - 1810...............Washington
Justice James Iredell......................1790 - 1799...............Washington
Justice William Paterson.................1793 - 1806...............Washington
Justice Samuel Chase....................1796 - 1806...............Washington
Justice Bushrod Washington...........1799 - 1829................Adams
Chief Justice John Marshall.............1801 - 1835................Adams
Justice William Johnson.................1804 - 1834................Jefferson
Justice Henry Livingston................1807 - 1823................Jefferson
Justice Thomas Todd.....................1807 - 1826................Jefferson
Justice Joseph Story......................1812 - 1845................Madison
Justice Smith Thompson................1823 - 1843................Monroe
Justice Robert Trimble...................1826 - 1828................Adams, JQ
Justice John McLean......................1830 - 1861...............Jackson
Justice Henry Baldwin...................1830 - 1844................Jackson
Justice James M. Wayne................1835 - 1867................Jackson
Chief Justice Roger B. Taney..........1836 - 1864................Jackson
Justice Pendleton Barbour..............1836 - 1841................Jackson
Justice John Catron......................1837 - 1865.................Jackson
Justice John McKinley....................1838 - 1852................Van Buren
Justice Peter V. Daniel...................1842 - 1860................Van Buren
Justice Levi Woodbury...................1845 - 1851................Polk
Justice Nathan Clifford..................1858 - 1881................Buchanan
Justice Freeman Miller...................1862 - 1890................Lincoln
Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase........1864 - 1873................Lincoln
Justice Joseph P. Bradley...............1870 - 1892................Grant
Chief Justice Morrison Waite..........1874 - 1888................Grant
Justice John Marshall Harlan I........1877 - 1911................Hayes
Justice William B. Woods...............1881 - 1887................Hayes
Justice Stanley Matthews..............1881 - 1889................Garfield
Justice Horace Gray......................1882 - 1902................Arthur
Justice Samuel Blatchford.............1882 - 1893................Arthur
Justice Lucius Lamar.....................1888 - 1893................Cleveland
Chief Justice Melville Fuller............1888 - 1910................Cleveland
Justice David Brewer....................1890 - 1910.................Harrison, B
Justice Howell Jackson..................1893 - 1895................Harrison, B
Chief Justice Edward D. White........1894 - 1921................Cleveland/Taft
Justice Rufus Wheeler Peckham.....1896 - 1909................Cleveland
Justice Horace Lurton...................1910 - 1914................Taft
Justice Joseph R. Lamar................1911 - 1916................Taft
Justice Pierce Butler......................1923 - 1939................Harding
Justice Edward Terry Sanford.........1923 - 1930................Harding
Chief Justice Harlan F. Stone..........1924 - 1946................Coolidge/Roosevelt, F.
Justice Benjamin Cardozo..............1932 - 1938................Hoover
Justice Frank Murphy....................1940 - 1949................Roosevelt, F
Justice Robert H. Jackson..............1941 - 1954................Roosevelt, F
Justice Wiley Blount Rutledge........1943 - 1949................Roosevelt, F
Chief Justice Fred M. Vinson..........1946 - 1953................Truman
Chief Justice William Rehnquist......1972 - 2005................Nixon/Reagan

Andy Stanton

(264 posts)
12. Maybe We'll Get Lucky
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 11:09 PM
Nov 2012

And Scalia, Alito and Thomas will get caught up in some major scandal and have to resign.

JiminyJominy

(340 posts)
14. Ginsburg, Kennedy, and Bryer
Fri Nov 2, 2012, 11:20 PM
Nov 2012

all have the age (as does Scalia).

Ginsburg: 80% chance of retiring
Kennedy: 60% chance of retiring
Bryer: 40% chance of retiring

that brings us to Scalia....

he is a bitter bitter man who hates and despises the left more than anything else in this world. there is NO WAY he retires while Obama's in office. he will consider it though if Romney wins.

even if Obama gets 2 appointments that would be pretty awesome. if he gets 3...that'll be a great bonus. if he gets 4....i will make a mess in my pants as will other supporters of left leaning policies especially RoeVWade.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Who and How Many Supreme ...