2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumA clip of Romney bullying a helpless old man could really turn this thing around
That debate was a yawn
A bad night for Obama is a bad night for audiences, too
BY WILLA PASKIN
In hindsight, the first five minutes of last nights Barack ObamaMitt Romney debate was a microcosm of the painful 90 minutes to come: Jim Lehrer explaining that the audience had been instructed not to applaud or cheer lest the proceedings feel as that they had any life to them. Obama and Romney arriving on stage in their party-appropriate ties. Obama opening by referring to himself as the luckiest man in the world for being married to Michelle Obama, a line that was a lot sweeter before it had been said verbatim so many times in public. Obama promising Michelle a better anniversary next year, all but jinxing this one to be awful. Obama giving an oblique opening statement. Romney, making a good-natured joke about Obamas anniversary, and then giving a much clearer, more compelling opening statement of his own. In five minutes, the tone of the night had been established the rest would just be painful, painful for Obama and painfully dull.
Because of the format of the debate and particularly Jim Lehrers toothless questioning essentially asking the candidates their positions on various huge topics, and then letting himself be bullied into not interrupting or directing them in more specific directions the exchanges were not pointed, but meandering. The debate was a 90-minute wash of words. Even paying strict attention, the thing had the feel of white noise, with Romney, much more so than Obama, occasionally breaking through and saying something that registered, like a bit of talk radio come through the static perfectly clear.
Romney effectively used specific anecdotes or a list broken out by numbers public speaking 101 to get the audience to refocus their attention. If he was on the attack it was only in comparison to Obama, who didnt manipulate his material or modulate his voice to make much of anything stand out (he got a little better as the night went on). Romney didnt get in any good zingers except of course at Big Bird but he wasnt opaque and dull every time he spoke, and he laid a good man-handling on Jim Lehrer. (In the age of viral videos, the DNC might want to rustle up a Romney interrupts Lehrer video ASAP. A clip of Romney bullying a helpless old man could really turn this thing around.)
http://www.salon.com/2012/10/04/debate_makes_for_dull_television/
godai
(2,902 posts)ChairmanAgnostic
(28,017 posts)KurtNYC
(14,549 posts)Shazam!