Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MineralMan

(146,324 posts)
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 03:29 PM Jan 2018

It is literally impossible to define exactly what is a Christian

It cannot be done. That's because Christianity is so far from being a unified religion that there is too little common ground to use to establish a definition. About all one can say is that Christians worship a man/god who they believed walked the earth, said some stuff that other people wrote down later, and then was executed by the Romans about 2000 years ago and died. After three days, the story goes, he rose from the dead, talked to a few people, and then ascended into heaven.

Christians generally think that if you believe that story, all of your sins will be forgiven and you'll live forever in that same heaven after you die. The theory is that Jesus Christ sacrificed his own life in payment for everyone's sins. If you believe that, you're home free. You should also try to live a good life, of course, but even if you can't it'll be OK in the end.

There are lots more details. Different groups of Christians (there are thousands of such groups) believe all sorts of other things, and they argue a lot about those details. With hundreds and hundreds of millions of believers, such splits and different understandings of things were probably inescapable. But, all of those groups call themselves Christians, and who's to say they're not all saved. Certainly not me. I leave all that to them.

Christians feel all sorts of ways about all sorts of things. Just because you know someone who calls him or herself a Christian doesn't mean that you know much about that person. You have to wait to get to know them before you know how they feel about politics, charity, racial issues, money, sexual matters, and the like, just like with anyone else. Being a Christian doesn't mean anything about anything except what they generally believe about religious stuff. They believe different religious things, too, but that's way too complicated for me to talk about here.

It can be confusing, even for other Christians, really. But it's OK. They're all saved, so you needn't worry about that, assuming you were worried about that in the first place. You can expect them to try to get you saved, as well. That's up to you, of course. If you can believe the story, you can be saved, too, as far as I know. I can't believe it, but apparently some people can.

And that's all I can say about Christians. Really. Good luck in your encounters with them.

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
It is literally impossible to define exactly what is a Christian (Original Post) MineralMan Jan 2018 OP
I have no faith in the Cosmic Jewish Zombie myself, but to each their own... Moostache Jan 2018 #1
Yeah, there's a lot of real world stuff to deal with, for sure. MineralMan Jan 2018 #2
Easy. According to the majority of evangelicals. . . PdxSean Jan 2018 #3
A Xian is a person who says they believe in Jesus Christ. Igel Jan 2018 #4
When it comes to Christianity, I'm a lumper. MineralMan Jan 2018 #5
Believe in him how? trotsky Jan 2018 #7
I think it involves the little story in the OP. MineralMan Jan 2018 #8
interesting.... spicysista Jan 2018 #6
Christianity has a diverse spectrum of belief. PragmaticDem Jan 2018 #9
Hmmm... here: Voltaire2 Jan 2018 #10
To be honest with you I have never encountered them. PragmaticDem Jan 2018 #12
So are not aware of the fact that many christian denominations are massively homophobic, Voltaire2 Jan 2018 #13
That is not what I said. You posted a photo about nationalistic Christians. PragmaticDem Jan 2018 #14
Here is what you said: "And when I encounter Christians I am fine so I don't need luck." Voltaire2 Jan 2018 #15
I think you are being hyper technical. PragmaticDem Jan 2018 #17
Christians used to kill each other here in the US over which version of christianity would be taught AtheistCrusader Jan 2018 #11
Ironic. guillaumeb Jan 2018 #16
Sorry, but - Comatose Sphagetti Jan 2018 #18
Can't disagree with that edhopper Jan 2018 #20
Thanks (NT) Comatose Sphagetti Jan 2018 #21
It's easy for me. They self-identify. (n/t) Iggo Jan 2018 #19

Moostache

(9,897 posts)
1. I have no faith in the Cosmic Jewish Zombie myself, but to each their own...
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 03:46 PM
Jan 2018

I give up on this world and its inhabitants ever latching onto reason and pulling themselves from the morass of idiocy and superstitious beliefs, tribalism and hatred.

We have 'elected' a barely evolved orangutang to be our leader and he is threatening to show everyone whose button is bigger in some kind of bizarre twist on apes battling in the jungles for leadership of the clan, only this time with the real possibility of mushroom clouds and nuclear fire...so my amount of time left to contemplate the more or less harmless (in context of nuclear war starting ape-boys) fictions of other people is definitely less of a prime mover these days...I find myself worrying more about things like access to drinking water, wind and current patterns that distribute fall out and whether or not living in a post-nuclear exchange world is worth living at all...

So in the end, those who wish to self-delude into believing a Jewish carpenter's son, from 1st century Palestine, is the locus of human existence and cosmic significance, more power to them, just keep it to themselves and allow me to worry about the possibility that there may not BE a future much longer...

MineralMan

(146,324 posts)
2. Yeah, there's a lot of real world stuff to deal with, for sure.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 03:49 PM
Jan 2018

I don't know. I'm just trying to make my way through it all. It's interesting, that's for sure.

Igel

(35,337 posts)
4. A Xian is a person who says they believe in Jesus Christ.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 04:18 PM
Jan 2018

There, it's a definition. I suspect it includes everybody who says they're Christians and excludes those who don't. You can't tell just by looking at a person, but then again you can't really tell what language they speak by looking at them. (Oddly, linguists have the same problem definition 'language', with lumpers and splitters duking it out as much as lumpers and splitters in taxonomics do ... Oy, Echinofossulocactus taxonomy!)

It's a general definition, and there are a lot of more fine-grained definitions, but they all miss part of {Christians} (I have no idea how the DU parser will interpret that { and } .)

Often the definition is chosen to exclude part of the set I have in mind, to redefine the set. Most often the other definitions are chosen without awareness or at least active consideration of the range of sectariansms.

Heck, on any given day in which I use the word "Christian" in 4 different conversations I'm likely to use 4 different definitions. Is my co-worker Christian? Sure and not in the least. Is my wife? Absolutely, but not really. Is the Pope? No way, but yeah. But the context had damned well better make clear what the distinction being drawn is.

But if you're going to go with all the distinctions as making no difference, then you're stuck with something like mine.

It's the same with "Democrat." Look at the struggles on DU to define the word. Each person gets to self-define. Doesn't mean DU has to let them stay. But the claim "you're not a true Democrat" always strikes me as specious and supercilious, boiling down to, "I get to define the term based on myself as prototypical, and you, sir, are no me!&quot

MineralMan

(146,324 posts)
5. When it comes to Christianity, I'm a lumper.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 04:33 PM
Jan 2018

As you say, if they say they are, I'm OK with that. I don't need to know more than that, really.

Now, as I get to know a Christian, I might have ideas as to what kind of Christian that person is. But those categories are the same for Christians and non-Christians, really. Are they friendly? Tolerant? Biased? Mean? Kind? Annoying as hell? That sort of thing. But those are separate classifications, as far as I am concerned.

Whatever kind they are, if they say they are Christians, then I won't argue with them about that status. I'll decide what sort of person they are by how they behave in all sorts of areas. They might be smart or simple-minded, gentle or violent, or any other sort of person. Then, I would sort them according to behavioral or other distinguishing categories.

The overall Christian category doesn't really tell me anything, except that they believe some stuff. I don't find that to be useful information, generally. Some other person might be a Muslim, a Hindu, or a Jain. Again, that would tell me very little, other than some stuff they believe.

And I don't really care about what people believe. I care about how they act. That's what matters to me. If someone acts like an asshole, what they believe in religious categories is of little interest to me. I'll try to avoid them. If, on the other hand, a person is a kind, generous, interesting person, the religious category is also irrelevant. I like people like that, so why would I care what they believe about religion?

So, I'm a lumper, but the overall religious category is not of that much interest to me.

trotsky

(49,533 posts)
7. Believe in him how?
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 05:03 PM
Jan 2018

Believe that he existed, and believed that he was a special man of god?

Congrats, you've just defined Muslims as Christians.

MineralMan

(146,324 posts)
8. I think it involves the little story in the OP.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 05:13 PM
Jan 2018

You have to believe all that stuff to believe IN Jesus, see. That's how I've always taken it. However, I have no doubt that someone who is a Christian will be along to tell me how I got it wrong, from some particular point of view or another.

spicysista

(1,663 posts)
6. interesting....
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 04:51 PM
Jan 2018

I've been to many churches throughout the southern region of the country. I used to teach/host conferences for the National Black Baptist Association (very different from the other larger association with a similar name, minus the black). Even in these churches that claim to all be a part of the same association, there are many differences.
Everyone (I'm talking specifically people of faith) has their own unique relationship with God, and everyone should respect that truth. I would gently encourage you to visit a church that has strong ties within the civil rights community. These houses of worship have been on the forefront of progressive policies long before others saw the light. Think : Rev. Barber and the Moral Monday Movement.
Please understand, this is not an attempt to convert you. I'm just offering a way for you to see Christianity from my lens.
Peace and blessings to you, MineralMan.

 

PragmaticDem

(320 posts)
9. Christianity has a diverse spectrum of belief.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 06:42 PM
Jan 2018

And when I encounter Christians I am fine so I don't need luck.

Voltaire2

(13,109 posts)
13. So are not aware of the fact that many christian denominations are massively homophobic,
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 06:59 PM
Jan 2018

misogynist, nationalistic, racist etc.? Just never run into such a christian? Seriously?

 

PragmaticDem

(320 posts)
14. That is not what I said. You posted a photo about nationalistic Christians.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 07:02 PM
Jan 2018

I have never encountered them personally.

Voltaire2

(13,109 posts)
15. Here is what you said: "And when I encounter Christians I am fine so I don't need luck."
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 07:07 PM
Jan 2018

You didn't qualify that at all. Are you fine with all christians?

 

PragmaticDem

(320 posts)
17. I think you are being hyper technical.
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 07:10 PM
Jan 2018

I am well aware through my own experience how cruel some Christians can be. My point is I can handle Christians I personally encounter. Sorry if it wasn't precise for you.

AtheistCrusader

(33,982 posts)
11. Christians used to kill each other here in the US over which version of christianity would be taught
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 06:50 PM
Jan 2018

in schools.

They've mellowed a bit, but they are still basically in a cease-fire.

Comatose Sphagetti

(836 posts)
18. Sorry, but -
Wed Jan 3, 2018, 07:39 PM
Jan 2018

If you believe the Earth is only a few thousand years old.
If you believe a child was born of a virgin.
If you believe Noah put all animals, INCLUDING FUCKING DINOSAURS, on an ark.
If you believe a man parted a sea.
If you believe a man walked on water.
If you believe a dead guy is coming back.
Etc., etc., ad nauseam....

Then that is simply absurd.

All religions arose from a warped interpretation/expression of the emotion/feeling of humility.

edhopper

(33,604 posts)
20. Can't disagree with that
Thu Jan 4, 2018, 09:56 AM
Jan 2018

but I really want to say that is the coolest screen name.

It sounds like a 60s psychedelic band.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»It is literally impossibl...