French secularism: Anti-religious or safeguarding freedoms?

[rug]

Latest update : 2016-11-19
By Florence VILLEMINOT

This week we take a closer look at France's cherished state secularism. Laïcité (secularism), a product of French history and philosophy, is central to how France defines itself. But critics say it is anti-religious and increasingly used to stigmatise Muslims. Is laïcité compatible with a multicultural society? We spoke to Jean-Louis Bianco, the President of the National Observatory on Secularism, to find out more.

http://www.france24.com/en/20161117-secularism-religion-state-islam-catholic-church-france-laicite-politics-society-history-phi

[guillaumeb]

1. It can be both anti-religious and guarding freedom.

Much depends on the motivation of the one who speaks. I am in complete agreement with the concept of laïcité because it is intended to ensure a separation of religious practice and the functions of the State.

But nothing in that concept requires a contempt for religion, and nothing in that concept requires discriminatory behavior based on religious belief, such as the "no burqa on the beach" laws that seem to be popular.

[rug]

2. You're right.

Scenes like this are obscene.

[hrmjustin]

3. That was appalling!

Those officers and the people who made the law should be ashamed.

[guillaumeb]

4. It is religious discrimination made legal in the name of secular freedom.

SO secular freedom somehow requires less freedom for believers.

Appalling indeed.