Leaving the Tribe
Why Im no longer part of the online atheism community.
You don't change the world by yelling at people on the Internet. (Photo by Creatas Images/Thinkstock)
Dec. 12 2013 8:08 AM
By Martin S. Pribble
For the last five years I have considered myself an activist atheist. I trolled Facebook and Twitter for theists and told them why they are wrong. I made fun of them for their unreasonable beliefs. I would analyze and nitpick their statements, show examples of just where they went wrong and why, and even at times ridicule them when there seemed to be no option left, all in the vain hope that I might be able to sway them to a more rational way of viewing the world and the universe. This could be extremely satisfying, and sometimes I found I could even come to a level of agreement with a believer about the realities of life. I even have friends among my Twitter following who are priests and strong Christians.
But Im through with it, and I no longer want to be part of the online atheist community. What I was once a proud member of, a group who fought against the evils of deliberate misinformation coming from religious groups and people, has become, at least on the surface, a parade of contradiction and caterwauling against theists who have no clue that there could be an alternate viewpoint or understanding of the universe than their own. The times of satisfaction are outweighed by feelings of frustration and hopelessness.
Dont get me wrongIm still an atheist. But I will no longer be dragged into debates with theists who make a ludicrous claim, then base their evidence on the very book from which their ludicrous claim originates. There is no point in it. All this back-and-forth sniping serves to do is to make us feel a sense of superiority to the person making the claims and does nothing for them except leave them with a smugness about their assumption that atheists are all mean. Faith overrides knowledge and truth in any situation, so arguing with a theist is akin to banging your head against a brick wall: You will injure yourself and achieve little.
This will not change an awful lot in what I do online. But I think Ive come to a point where I am only injuring myself if I were to continue engaging in theistic debating about things like the efficacy of the Noahs Ark story. If someone is espousing beliefs that are actively harmfuli.e., promoting intolerance based on belief systemsexpect me to be the first to stand up and say something. I cant allow this kind of thinking, and if I can help it, I will move to sway the believer into rethinking their position. But this will be done with reason and rational discourse, not with contradicting the finer points of the religious texts.
http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2013/12/why_i_m_quitting_the_online_atheism_community.html