Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

question everything

(47,486 posts)
Tue Jan 16, 2018, 02:51 PM Jan 2018

Ice Bowl 67, by Chuck Carlson. A book review

Sports fans with a historical bent—which is to say, sports fans—often employ shorthand to describe the landmark episodes of stadiums, arenas and playing fields: The Fifth-Down Game (Cornell vs. Dartmouth, 1940); the Mazeroski Walk-Off Homer (Pirates defeat Yankees in the World Series, 1960); the Immaculate Reception ( Franco Harris’s improbable catch in an AFC divisional playoff game, 1972). And there is another, indisputably one of the legendary moments of all sports: the Ice Bowl.

For devotees of football it is unnecessary to explain that we are talking about the 1967 NFL Championship Game between the Dallas Cowboys and the Green Bay Packers in icy northeastern Wisconsin, where a blast of Arctic air had pushed temperatures well into double digits below zero, with wind chills hitting minus 65 degrees. The game itself is of course at the center of sportswriter Chuck Carlson’s “Ice Bowl ’67,” though he also offers up context as well as interviews with participants and spectators, now thawed but still awed. Reflecting on the weather conditions that day, Dan Reeves, a Cowboy at the time and later a coach, writes in the book’s foreword: “How did we do it? Who knows? Instinct takes over. So did competitiveness. The will to win overrides everything including frozen fields and fingers.”

By game time the field was frozen solid. The players couldn’t get traction. The members of the band couldn’t play because their instruments were too cold. The referees abandoned their whistles for fear they might freeze to their lips, and besides, the little wooden balls inside were frozen in place. Many of the 50,861 at Green Bay’s Lambeau Field suffered frostbite, despite huddling under blankets and sipping from flasks. But surely none of them regrets the experience of being there. Seldom have two more accomplished teams played for an athletic championship.

The Cowboys (9-5) were America’s Team, the Packers (9-4-1) were, in Mr. Carlson’s felicitous term, “America’s comfort food.” The game pit Texas cool against Wisconsin cold; the swashbuckling newcomer Cowboys (founded 1960) against the established royalty of the Packers (founded 1919); Dallas’s cerebral coach Tom Landry against Green Bay’s martinet Vince Lombardi. The principals on the field included a murderers’ row, if you will forgive the mixed-sports metaphor, of pro-football legends: Jerry Kramer. Ray Nitschke. Herb Adderley. Don Chandler. Lance Rentzel. Bob Hayes. Bob Lilly. Jethro Pugh. Not to mention quarterbacks Bart Starr and Don Meredith.

The record book shows that the Packers defeated the Cowboys, 21-17, and that Green Bay’s Starr completed 14 of 24 passes and threw for two touchdowns. But the game lives on well beyond the record books, not least for the moment that clinched a victory for the Packers, the rare late-game play remembered as much for the blocks (Jerry Kramer and Ken Bowman ) as for the touchdown (Mr. Starr in a starring role). The CBS camera angle was perfect—it captured a touchdown made for television—and as a result the play has become endlessly viewable for anyone who missed the game at the time and for generations of sports fans to come.

More..

https://www.wsj.com/articles/review-sub-zero-heroes-1514569505

5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Ice Bowl 67, by Chuck Carlson. A book review (Original Post) question everything Jan 2018 OP
I was working in Dallas during that game and... El Supremo Jan 2018 #1
Thanks for the post GusBob Jan 2018 #2
After further review, I checked out the amazon reviews GusBob Jan 2018 #3
I did. rsdsharp Jan 2018 #4
Yep that's what the reviews said too GusBob Jan 2018 #5

El Supremo

(20,365 posts)
1. I was working in Dallas during that game and...
Tue Jan 16, 2018, 09:11 PM
Jan 2018

couldn't watch it. I was really bummed.

I bet Madinmaryland was still in diapers!

GusBob

(7,286 posts)
3. After further review, I checked out the amazon reviews
Thu Jan 18, 2018, 12:20 PM
Jan 2018

They were less than kind, basically "don't waste your money on this book"

rsdsharp

(9,186 posts)
4. I did.
Wed Jan 31, 2018, 01:25 PM
Jan 2018

I wish I hadn't. The game (to the extent it was discussed) was done two thirds of the way through the book. There was nothing new presented. Facts were wrong -- Lombardi was sometimes a New Yorker (he was) and sometimes from New Jersey (he wasn't). It pretends that the issue of whether Jerry Kramer moved before the snap on the final play is an open question. It's not -- and I'm a huge Kramer fan. Slow motion clearly shows he jumped, although it's impossible to see at regular speed. The book is also filled (at least in the Kindle addition) with typos and other editing mistakes. And the title is redundant. There was only one Ice Bowl -- a point the book makes. Why call it Ice Bowl '67?

GusBob

(7,286 posts)
5. Yep that's what the reviews said too
Wed Jan 31, 2018, 04:15 PM
Jan 2018

Jerry Kramer is the man. His book is much better

I can't believe a published book of any merit would allows typos and errors of fact

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Sports»Ice Bowl 67, by Chuck Car...