Young Man, Adult Crime
A teenage boy stands accused of killing an innocent man. Can the criminal justice system acknowledge a juveniles potential to change while also holding him accountable for a terrible act?
This story was written by Dana Goldstein for the Marshall Project, a nonprofit news organization that covers the U.S. criminal justice system. Sign up for their newsletter, or follow the Marshall Project on Facebook or Twitter.
In 2012, Kahton Anderson found a gun.
The .357 Magnum, a revolver with a silver barrel, was hidden inside the radiator in the kitchen of the apartment Kahton shared with his mother and two siblings in the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn. Kahton said he had watched his older brother, Lakim, hide the gun there.
At first, Kahton, who was 12 at the time, only looked at the gun in its hiding place. But he quickly got to know the weapon better, removing it from the radiator, toying with it, and taking pictures of himself holding it. If I could get some bullets for this mag, we would clear a lot of shit out, he boasted to a friend on Facebook. By March 2013, Kahton was writing, When beef come, we ready!
A year later, this boy, with this gun, would take an innocent mans life on a New York City bus. The case was easy fodder for the tabloids, which quickly dubbed Kahton a fiend and thug. It also raised some of the most difficult and pressing questions in criminal justice: What is the right venue for trying a teenager accused of murder? And is there a way to acknowledge a young defendants immaturity and potential to change while simultaneously holding him accountable for a terrible act? Fear of crimes like Kahtons threatens to derail efforts in New York and other states to revise laws that treat teenagers as adults in criminal court. But a closer look at the circumstances that led to his offense illustrates the need for a system that acknowledges the gray space between adulthood and childhoodand that offers more than just adult prison sentences as the response to youthful violence.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2015/06/kahton_anderson_he_shot_and_killed_angel_rojas_on_a_new_york_city_bus_should.html