Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 02:11 PM Oct 2013

Roaster Oven Pot Roast for 10

My wife announced on Saturday that three relatives were showing up at her mother's house the next day and told me that she had volunteered me to prepare dinner for everyone. With other local relatives, there would be 10 at the table. Now, I like the out-of-town relatives, and wanted to be able to spend some time with them, so I wanted the meal to be a no-brainer and not require a lot of attention. It's Fall, and the days are getting cold, so Pot Roast seemed like a good option. Here's the recipe I used. I cooked this in one of those old-fashioned big roaster ovens, which I've owned for decades. Everyone should own one.

Ingredients
Two 3.5 lb. Boneless Chuck Roasts - Not the expensive ones...any will do. Choose ones with not too much fat.
30 medium red potatoes - three per person. Some will just eat two, and others will eat four. Cut them in half, lengthwise. Don't peel.
2-3 lb. Medium Carrots - Cut into three inch lengths and don't pare them.
1 Big bunch of Celery - Cut the entire bunch into three inch lengths. Include any leafy parts.
4 Large White Onions - Quarter these lengthwise after peeling.
2 Small Heads White Cabbage - Cut in half, lengthwise, then cut each half into thirds, lengthwise. Discard loose leaves. Retain the thick part at the base of the cabbages to keep leaves together.
1 tsp. salt or to taste
2 tbs. Italian Seasoning
Coarsely chopped garlic, if liked, to taste.
Coarse ground pepper to taste.
4 cups water.
1/4 cup vegetable oil.

Wine Pairing: For this hearty meal, I recommend a big, fat, luscious Merlot or Syrah. You want it to have lots of fruit and less tannin. It's an unsophisticated meal and deserves an unsophisticated big red to go with it.

Preparation
Begin preparations four or five hours before dinner, or even longer, if you wish. It doesn't matter, but you need at least four hours.

Preheat roaster oven to 350 degrees. Pour water into roaster oven. Add salt and italian seasoning.
Dump all vegetables, except cabbage into roaster oven and distribute evenly on bottom.
In large, heavy skillet, brown chuck roasts on both sides on high heat after adding the vegetable oil. The meat will still stick, but never mind. Just use a metal spatula. Do these one at a time, unless you have a really, really large skillet.
Add roasts to roaster oven, putting one on each end, leaving a space between them. Season with pepper.
Add cabbage to the space between the roasts.

The meat goes on top. The meat always goes on top. It shouldn't touch the water.

Cover Roaster oven with lid and go away for an hour. After an hour, turn down temperature to 300 degrees and go away to spend a good long time with guests. Forget about dinner. It's done. Don't worry about timing. It will be ready whenever you are, later. Allow at least four hours from the time you finish preparations. However, if it goes longer than that, it doesn't matter. After four hours, you can reduce the temperature to 200 degrees. Don't pay any attention to this meal. Go enjoy yourself and forget about it. Have some wine and conversation. The aroma of the pot roast and its accompanying vegetables will fill the house. When it's time to eat, people will let you know. Have some more wine and conversation. Enjoy the company.

Service
You'll need one very large platter and one very large shallow bowl, or two large shallow bowls.

Remove roasted meat and place on platter. It will break into chunks. No worries. Just get it out of the roaster and onto the platter. Pretty it won't be. Delicious it will be.

With a slotted spoon, transfer the vegetables into the large shallow bowl or the two smaller bowls. Don't try to separate them. Just put them in there. You can, if you wish, put the cabbage in a separate bowl. That's up to you. In fact, the cabbage is optional. I don't eat it, but some of my wife's family is partial to it. You could also add some turnips, rutabagas, or other root vegetables, if they are liked by the guests. I don't like them, and I haven't asked my wife's family if they like them. I don't care. I don't like them, so I don't add them. Yuck!

Using a ladle, remove some of the broth from the roaster oven and pour over meat and vegetables. No need to thicken it. It's very rich and flavorful, and is good to sop up with bread when the food is gone. Put large serving spoons, etc. on the platters. No knife is required for the meat. It will come apart easily with the serving spoons. No worries.

Take the steaming platters to table, which should already have been set by someone else. You may have to remind someone ahead of time that dinner is ready and that the table needs to be set. You may have to do this more than once. The cook should not set the table. He will be busy transferring food to the platters and bowls.

This meal needs nothing but some rolls or croissants to be complete. Sit down at the table, pour yourself a big glass of wine, and let everyone use their boarding house reach to serve themselves. Once they're done, serve yourself and enjoy. Watch people keep going after more pot roast and vegetables. Watch your relatives stuff themselves with the ultimate comfort food. Hear the silence, as conversation stops while people eat.

After everything is gone, allow others the pleasure of clearing the table and cleaning up the mess. You cooked this well-appreciated meal, after all, slaving as you did for hours in its preparation. Do offer to clean up the roaster oven, though. Put it back in the car. At home, put it on the lawn, and wash it all out the next day.

Bon Appetit!

5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Roaster Oven Pot Roast for 10 (Original Post) MineralMan Oct 2013 OP
Sounds absolutely delicious Freddie Oct 2013 #1
Pot roasting is a great way to turn tough cuts of meat into a treat. MineralMan Oct 2013 #2
Thanksgiving turkey Freddie Oct 2013 #3
It's great for a bone-in ham. MineralMan Oct 2013 #4
Sounds delicious and I love cooking a pot roast until it is falling apart. cbayer Oct 2013 #5

Freddie

(9,267 posts)
1. Sounds absolutely delicious
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 03:02 PM
Oct 2013

My church has semi-annual roast beef dinner fund-raisers, open to the public. We serve 300-400 meals and prepare the meat almost the same way. Large eye roasts cooked all day in about 20 of those roaster ovens with celery, garlic and onions (veggies for the meal are cooked separately). They cook the meat from 7 am til about 3pm, then slice it and keep in warm in the oven in big pans with the broth. Meat falls apart and is wonderful.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
2. Pot roasting is a great way to turn tough cuts of meat into a treat.
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 03:13 PM
Oct 2013

Your church dinner roasts sound great to me. Pot roast was a frequent meal in my childhood home. Mom would put it together early and we'd do family things all day. Then, at the end of the day, it was all ready to eat, with no further effort. For me, it's not a frequent dish, but it works great in situations where you'd rather enjoy the company than be tied up in the kitchen.

It's old-style church lady cooking, but I've never had anyone turn up a nose at it. Not a delicate meal, but very homey and satisfying, all the same. It's one of those dishes I use for big family gatherings and once in a while when I'm called on to cook for food snobs. I can do detail-oriented fine cookery, but if someone I trade dinners with gets a little snobbish about competing with food, I break out a pot roast and reset the contest. Oddly enough, it's always a hit, even with the food snobs. Everyone remembers it from their childhood, and it has a certain pleasure-producing homeyness.

Roaster ovens are still available at reasonable prices and are a must-have thing if you sometimes have to prepare a bunch of food for a large group. I've made chili with beans for 30 people in mine, and it's always a big hit. It cooks for hours without attention and is then ready to eat whenever people want. Pot roast is a similar thing.

Freddie

(9,267 posts)
3. Thanksgiving turkey
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 03:22 PM
Oct 2013

Is why I bought mine (was cheap, maybe $50). First couple years the turkey came out dry until I read this advice: preheat to the highest temp and cook turkey the first hour at this, then turn down to 325 for the rest and do not open the lid until a half hour before dinner for the "resting" before carving. Was nice and moist but still falling off the bone done.
Have you ever made a ham in it? Thinking of trying for Christmas dinner.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
4. It's great for a bone-in ham.
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 03:47 PM
Oct 2013

I don't have the exact times, but it's pretty much the same as the turkey. Cook at 325-350, allowing about 15-20 minutes per pound. Put a couple of cups of water in the bottom of the roaster, and then go away. Check it after about 4 hours with a meat thermometer. Once it hits 140 degrees or so, turn the heat down to 200 and it will hold just fine. Add water if needed during cooking, but you probably won't have to. It won't brown much, but it will be tender and taste great. If you want to glaze it, wait until half an hour before serving.

Glazing idea: For a great tasting orange glaze, brush orange marmalade on the ham. That's it. A real time-saver, with great flavor, and the little strips of orange peel add a nice zest to the glaze. Try it.

It'll work fine. I've done turkeys, too, but they don't brown much. They do taste great and get really tender. It can be hard to remove a turkey from the roaster, so use something like one of those folding turkey lifters, put in the roaster before the turkey goes in.

The think I like about the roaster oven for Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Easter is that it frees up the oven for other stuff. I usually cook in the roaster oven in the basement, just to keep it out of the way.

You can Google roaster oven recipes, and you'll find all sort of cool ideas for this handy appliance.

cbayer

(146,218 posts)
5. Sounds delicious and I love cooking a pot roast until it is falling apart.
Tue Oct 29, 2013, 06:42 PM
Oct 2013

I brown in a dutch oven, then add my liquid into the same pan and cook for hours on the stove top.

My favorite is to cook with an Asian flavor - soy sauce, sherry, star anise, garlic.

I add my vegetables late and generally stick with onions, carrots and potatoes. They usually go in for the last 30 - 45 minutes only.

And I like to take some of the cooking liquid, thicken it and serve as a gravy.

Best yet, it's just as good leftover.

Peasant food at it's best, imo. It's amazing what you can do with an inexpensive cut of meat like this.

Enjoy.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Cooking & Baking»Roaster Oven Pot Roast fo...