Israel/Palestine
Related: About this forumThe Pro-Palestinian Left's Hamas Blindspot
Earlier this week, news that Hamas had barred women from participating in a marathon in the Gaza Strip scrolled across my twitter feed. Instantly, I knew two things. First, that Pro-Israel hawks would lambast the Islamist group without ever considering the way in which Israel and Americas policy of isolating Gaza makes it easier for Hamas to practice the very misogyny the hawks rightly condemn. Second, that the anti-Zionist left would say nothing at all.
Explaining the hawks reaction is easier. Its an article of faith on the American and Israeli right that once Israel dismantled its settlements in Gaza, it discharged all responsibility for the place. Rarely do hawks acknowledge the way Israels restrictions on the movement of people and goods in and out of Gaza have destroyed the Strips independent business class, limited access to Western education and helped Hamas consolidate control. In the words of Sir Tom Phillips, Britains former ambassador to Israel, the partial blockade has helped make Gaza a place where young boys on the streets [have] no role models apart from the Hamas guy in the black shiny uniform on the street corner."
The far left doesnt have that problem. Anti-Zionists rarely discuss Gaza without foregrounding Israels partial blockade or what they often call the siege. But in so doing, they give Hamas an almost total pass. On March 6, the anti-Zionist website Mondoweiss linked, without comment, to an article about the marathon as the 33rd story in its daily rundown of Israel-Palestine news. When I searched for marathon at Ali Abunimahs site, Electronic Intifada, I was directed to a March 2012 story entitled Athlete abused by Israeli soldier for carrying Palestine flag in Jerusalem marathon, and an April 2012 story entitled Egypt Football Association to boycott Adidas due to companys sponsorship of Jerusalem marathon. But I found nothing about the marathon in Gaza.
Every blog misses things. But spend enough time reading the anti-Zionist left and you notice a pattern. Type Hamas into Electronic Intifadas search engine and not a single one of the first twenty headlines suggests harsh criticism of the Islamist group. Type in Abbas, by contrast, and youre met with headlines like Palestinian protesters harassed, beaten by Abbas supporters in Jerusalem and Mahmoud Abbas war against the Palestinian people. At Mondoweiss, theres less animosity toward Abbas and its a little easier to find criticism of Hamas. (In September 2010, for instance, Mondoweiss published an article entitled, Hamas attack was wrong." Still, Mondoweiss devotes far more attention to Israel and Americas policies toward Hamas than to Hamas policies toward the people of Gaza. And it devotes far more attention to the way American and Israeli hawks exaggerate Hamas misdeeds than to those misdeeds themselves.
The Gaza marathon ban is not an isolated event. Its one more example of Hamas frighteningly misogynistic policies. The group has banned women from riding on the back of motorcycles and smoking hookah pipes. It tried to make all women lawyers in Gaza courts wear headscarves. It has promoted policies requiring female students at Gazan universities to wear socially conservative "Islamic dress." It has tried to ban books deemed "salacious and cracked down on film that doesnt meet its reactionary norms. Hamas has prevented students who received scholarships to study in the United States from traveling there for what the group calls "social and cultural reasons," in other words to protect them from Western influence. Male hairdressers in Gaza are no longer allowed to cut women's hair. Hamas has shut down mixed gender water parks. It has cracked down brutally on peaceful protest, especially when the protesters are women, and arrested numerous journalists. You can learn about this from human rights groups, from the international press, from the Israeli press, and from the Palestinian news service, Maan, which has had its own run-ins with Hamas. But youre unlikely to learn about it from Mondoweiss or Electronic Intifada.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/03/08/the-pro-palestinian-left-s-hamas-blindspot.html
shira
(30,109 posts)Very interesting piece from him.
King_David
(14,851 posts)More like outright support !