Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
Wed Oct 10, 2012, 06:52 PM Oct 2012

Hydrogen Cars: A Dream That Won't Die

http://www.technologyreview.com/news/429495/hydrogen-cars-a-dream-that-wont-die/
[font face=Serif][font size=5]Hydrogen Cars: A Dream That Won't Die[/font]

[font size=4]Better technology and high battery costs have revived interest in hydrogen-guzzling vehicles.[/font]

Peter Fairley
Monday, October 8, 2012

[font size=3]By the mid-2000s, the dream of hydrogen-powered cars had faded in the face of stubborn practicalities like the lack of charging stations and the inefficiency of fuel cells. But as the auto industry wrestles with the limitations of battery-powered electric vehicles, the dream lives on. That is apparent at the Paris Auto Show.

When the show opened last month, battery-driven electric vehicles stood front and center (see "Renault and Others Debut Electric Cars at Paris Show&quot . But hydrogen-fuel-cell vehicles were also omnipresent. Show visitors could test-drive seven fuel-cell cars from leading automakers (including an SUV that Hyundai plans to begin leasing this winter), and a bevy of snazzy concept cars conjured up visions of a hydrogen-fueled future.

Automakers are showing new interest because key problems with fuel cells—their limited capacity to convert hydrogen to electricity and their susceptibility to freezing—have largely been overcome in recent years. At the same time, the first mass-produced electric vehicles based on batteries—the fuel cell's technological rival for the zero-emissions mantle—have seen sales slow because their range remains disappointing and their prices high.

Even Nissan, which leads the global electric-vehicle market with its Leaf subcompact and has vowed to sell 1.5 million battery-powered vehicles by 2016 with corporate partner Renault, is showing a powerful fuel-cell SUV as a concept car in Paris. The company's strategy reflects widely held views in the automotive industry, according to consultancy KPMG. Of the 200 executives polled in its 2012 Global Auto Executive Survey, those predicting that electric-car buyers of 2025 will prefer a fuel cell outnumbered those backing battery technology by 25 percent.

…[/font][/font]
16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
 

2on2u

(1,843 posts)
1. Prieto battery will change all that but I still like a fuel cell vehicle, what I imagine is a Prieto
Wed Oct 10, 2012, 07:14 PM
Oct 2012

battery pack being used to break down water into hydrogen and oxygen.... then sending the hydrogen to the fuel cell for production of electrical potential. Then send this "clean" electricity (depending on where the lion cells got their electrical charge from) to the motors. What isn't used by the motors could be sent back to the batteries. I'm pretty sure I have just committed several engineering sins however I can see it working even if they can't. They being the smart people who actually get to design these vehicles.

 

2on2u

(1,843 posts)
3. There are losses associated with each transfer of energy..... but they can be minimized with all
Wed Oct 10, 2012, 07:36 PM
Oct 2012

the cool stuff we have today... dll's, image files, bourbon and magical incantations.

FogerRox

(13,211 posts)
8. Doesnt Hydrogen leak thru any container wall its enclosed in
Thu Oct 11, 2012, 05:06 PM
Oct 2012

Distributed generation. Each Gas station can make its own hydrogen.

 

2on2u

(1,843 posts)
10. Hydrogen, possibly methane and other gaseous fuels can be absorbed by chicken feathers and or
Thu Oct 11, 2012, 06:07 PM
Oct 2012

carbon nano-fibers.

http://newenergyandfuel.com/http:/newenergyandfuel/com/2009/07/03/chicken-feathers-can-store-lots-of-hydrogen/
Chicken Feathers Can Store Lots of Hydrogen

July 3, 2009 | 4 Comments

Carbonized chicken feather fibers can hold vast amounts of hydrogen according to Richard P. Wool, Ph.D., professor of chemical engineering and director of the Affordable Composites from Renewable Resources program at the University of Delaware in Newark.



Chicken feather fibers are mostly made of keratin, a natural protein that forms strong, hollow tubes. When heated, the protein creates cross links, which strengthen its structure, and it also becomes more porous, increasing its surface area. The result is carbonized chicken feather fibers, which can absorb as much or perhaps more hydrogen than carbon nanotubes or metal hydrides, two other materials being studied for their hydrogen storage potential, Wool says. Plus, they’re dirt-cheap.

The project goal is to develop new low cost hydrogen storage substrates from the waste material chicken feathers (some 6 billion lbs/yr in U.S. alone). The results show that carbonized chicken feathers have the potential to meet the DOE requirements for H2 storage of 81 grams H2 per L in 2015 and are competitive with carbon nanotubes and metal hydrides at a tiny fraction of the cost. When keratin based chicken feathers are heat treated by a controlled pyrolysis process, hollow carbon microtubes are formed with nanoporous walls. Their specific surface area increases up to 450 m2/g by the formation of fractals and micropores thus enabling more hydrogen adsorption than the raw, untreated feather fibers.

Wool estimates that it would take a 75-gallon tank to go 300 miles in a car using carbonized chicken feather fibers to store hydrogen. He says his team is working to improve that range.


http://www.nanowerk.com/spotlight/spotid=4154.php
New carbon nanotube hydrogen storage results surpass Freedom Car requirements
(Nanowerk Spotlight) Two of the major challenges of our modern, mobile society are the shrinking of available fossil energy resources on one hand and climate change associated with global warming on the other. Continuing population growth multiplied by the increase in consumption and living standards, especially in developing countries, will require more and more oil, coal and natural gas to 'power' humanity. Notwithstanding efforts like the Kyoto Protocol - which wasn't signed by the two major CO2 polluters China and the U.S. - an ever increasing rate of fossil fuel usage means that the increasing emission of CO2 is likely to cause an acceleration of the climate change that is in progress already.

Transportation, in particular passenger cars, is one of the areas where new technology could lead to environmental beneficial change. Never mind that GM is still selling 15-20,000 Hummers a year, or that Tata is planning to sell millions of its new Nano car. One of the much touted technological solutions is to substitute fossil hydrocarbon based energy with the energy from carbon-free sources like the sun, nuclear energy, or the hot interior of the Earth and use hydrogen as an energy carrier (read more about this in "The Hydrogen Economy&quot .

Hydrogen can be produced from water using energy from carbon-free sources [editor's note: unfortunately it can also be produced from dirty fossil fuels; see the Nanowerk Spotlight "Nanotechnology could clean up the hydrogen car's dirty little secret"] and can serve as fuel in fuel cells to generate electricity, either stationary or on board of vehicles. Considerable research efforts are going into the evaluation of various nanostructures, such as carbon nanotubes, to find the most suitable hydrogen storage materials.
Safe, efficient and compact hydrogen storage is a major challenge in order to realize hydrogen powered transport. According to the DOE Freedom CAR program roadmap the on-board hydrogen storage system should provide 6 weight % (wt%) of hydrogen capacity to be considered for the technological implementation.

Currently, the storage of hydrogen in the absorbed form is considered as the most appropriate way to solve this problem. Thus, a media capable of absorbing and releasing large quantities of hydrogen easily and reliably is being actively sought. Since claims by Dillon et al. that single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNT) can store hydrogen, this material has been considered as a candidate for hydrogen storage media ("Storage of hydrogen in single-walled carbon nanotubes&quot .

 

AverageJoe90

(10,745 posts)
4. I certainly hope these problems can be solved.
Thu Oct 11, 2012, 12:41 AM
Oct 2012

And, in the meantime, we need to focus on other alternative energy sources, too. Hemp, anyone?

tinrobot

(10,903 posts)
5. So... buy hydrogen instead of gasoline from big energy?
Thu Oct 11, 2012, 01:11 AM
Oct 2012

Not my idea of progress.

I can charge my EV with sunlight. Making hydrogen and compressing it is a much more expensive and complex task for the individual.

 

RobertEarl

(13,685 posts)
12. Hydrogen... it has been in the news
Thu Oct 11, 2012, 11:40 PM
Oct 2012

Oh yeah, I remember now.

It's what blew up two huge buildings in Japan... so they say.

If true that is some killer stuff, ok?

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
13. At least you didn’t mention the Hindenburg!
Fri Oct 12, 2012, 05:13 PM
Oct 2012

Better stop eating grain! That stuff is dangerous.
http://news.google.com/?q=grain+elevator+explosion


Gasoline has been known to explode… that doesn’t stop millions of people from using it in their cars every day. However, hydrogen is safer.

Kennah

(14,277 posts)
14. Read "Hype About Hydrogen" by Dr. Joe Romm
Sat Oct 13, 2012, 01:32 AM
Oct 2012

Lots of technological challenges with fuel cell cars. Cost, leakage, our main source of hydrogen would be from natural gas at present.

In time, fuel cells will regularly make it into buildings and ships. It's already happened in cost cases, but it remains very rare.

EVs are already here. Might not be perfect, but they will get better and EVs are here. We don't a sophisticated charging network, but we have an electric grid and we can add chargers and EVs are here. Batteries will get better, or maybe a battery swapping scheme will come together, and EVs are here. The prices will come down, and EVs are here.

Fuel cell cars are like nuclear fusion--it will be great once they arrive, but in the decades until that happens we need to do something.

Kennah

(14,277 posts)
15. Check the fracking cost
Sat Oct 13, 2012, 01:47 AM
Oct 2012

See notes that fuel-cell vehicles have another crucial hurdle to overcome: the dearth of hydrogen fueling stations. There are currently no more than 280 worldwide, and many are not publicly accessible, according to Ulrich Buenger, coördinator for H2Moves, a 20-million-euro fuel-cell demonstration project funded by the European Union. Boosting their numbers will be pricey, since hydrogen filling stations cost around a million euros to install.

Buenger predicts that the cost of hydrogen stations will decline towards 300,000 euros, the price of a natural-gas pump, with each one installed—a process that is accelerating in Europe. Germany has 14 hydrogen stations open to the public, and a public-private collaboration announced early this year aims to roll out 36 more by 2015—enough to link most cities. Denmark laid out a comparable plan this spring. And on Friday, global chemicals producer Air Products announced plans to build two hydrogen filling stations in London, which would give the city a total of five.

Such plans are missing in the United States, though, where a U.S. Department of Energy website lists just seven public stations nationwide—all of them in California.

There is one big reason to be optimistic that this could change, says Buenger—an abundant supply of natural gas flowing from hydraulic fracturing (or fracking) wells, which provides a ready source of hydrogen. "There is already more and more interest in fuel-cell technology because of the new natural-gas resources," he says.

*****************************************

I believe I've read that Level 3 EV charging stations cost around $50K, but those are too expensive compared to a million euros for a hydrogen refueling station? Seriously?

But hey, fracking will solve it all.

Oy.

hunter

(38,321 posts)
16. The best way to solve the car problem is to get rid of cars.
Sat Oct 13, 2012, 12:41 PM
Oct 2012

Restructuring our cities and denser suburbs so that cars are simply unnecessary is the best solution.

Instead of building new cars we could be building public transportation systems and neighborhood markets.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Hydrogen Cars: A Dream Th...