Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sandensea

(21,688 posts)
Tue Feb 4, 2020, 01:10 PM Feb 2020

Claudio Bonadio, Argentina's "Ken Starr," dead at 64

Argentine Federal Judge Claudio Bonadío, known for overseeing many of the cases involving former President Cristina Kirchner or her cabinet, has died of a brain tumor; he was 64.

Bonadío was widely known as former President Mauricio Macri's "napkin" (pocket) judge - a nickname he first earned in 1996 when a top official under then-President Carlos Menem wrote his name on a café napkin as one of nine judges Menem could count on as cronies.

Amid an economic and debt crisis, the right-wing Macri recently became the first president in Argentine history to lose re-election.

Bonadío oversaw 11 of 13 federal cases against Mrs. Kirchner - despite requirements that federal cases be randomly assigned by lot.

His handling of these cases became known for a refusal to allow defendants access to evidence and case files, as well as for admitting unverified evidence (found to be forged in at least one case) and unrecorded "confessions" of witnesses who later alleged being pressured by the judge.

A raid ordered by the judge on Kirchner's home in August 2018 led to the poisoning of her housekeeper and two others by what the attending physician described as a "contact toxin."

Bonadío, on the other hand, routinely dismissed charges against Macri or his officials - notably the "Panama Papers" case, in which Macri's name was found on at least 50 undeclared offshore accounts.

Napkin judge

Appointed Chief Counsel to President Menem in 1992, at the height of the "Yomagate" scandal involving alleged money laundering by Menem's in-laws, Bonadío was named to the federal bench a year later despite having graduated from law school only five years earlier.

He was promoted in 1994 (at 38) as head of the powerful 11th Circuit Criminal Court - and remained in the post despite 75 formal complaints before the Council of Magistrates for malfeasance, abuse of power, illicit enrichment, and other charges.

A finding of "partiality" in favor of defendants led to his 2005 removal as presiding judge in the case involving the cover-up of the 1994 AMIA bombing - which left 85 dead in a Buenos Aires Jewish community center, and remains unsolved.

The AMIA prosecutor at the time, Alberto Nisman, later accused Bonadío of threats against his life and his family. Nisman was found dead in 2015.

Bonadío's own death comes a year after recordings of indicted extortionist Marcelo d'Alessio, an intelligence (AFI) agent, showed d'Alessio boasting of a shakedown scheme that had netted $12 million since August 2018, and that the scheme was run by a close Bonadío collaborator - the now-indicted Federal Prosecutor Carlos Stornelli.

"Stornelli is Macri," d'Alessio said in the recordings. "Claudio (Bonadío) will want a cut too."

At: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&tab=wT&sl=es&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.pagina12.com.ar%2F245613-murio-el-juez-federal-claudio-bonadio



Claudio Bonadío, 1956-2020.

The public face of former President Macri's weaponized judiciary against opponents, Bonadío remained on the federal bench despite - and perhaps because - of his practice of denying defendants access to evidence and case files, while granting others an immediate dismissal of charges.

Evidence emerging a year ago of a large-scale extortion scheme by a close associate - in which Bonadío was named - led to renewed calls for his removal and prosecution.
2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Claudio Bonadio, Argentina's "Ken Starr," dead at 64 (Original Post) sandensea Feb 2020 OP
Bonadio was a one man judicial crime wave as soon as he graduated, it seems. Unbelievable. Judi Lynn Feb 2020 #1
Judge Claudio Bonadio leaves behind mixed legacy Judi Lynn Feb 2020 #2

Judi Lynn

(160,649 posts)
1. Bonadio was a one man judicial crime wave as soon as he graduated, it seems. Unbelievable.
Tue Feb 4, 2020, 09:26 PM
Feb 2020

Through his outrageous, unforgivable behavior on the bench, aiding and abetting criminality among the country's highest ranking politicians, he was tempting fate throughout it all.

Had no idea he had assailed President Cristina Kirchner so many times. Had no idea higher ups also arranged for him to take so many of the cases, contrary to the law.

Surely hope there's no one as dirty to replace him now. Argentina needs a break from all the chaos and ruin for the average people created by the right wing.

I'll bet they thought he would never leave!

Judi Lynn

(160,649 posts)
2. Judge Claudio Bonadio leaves behind mixed legacy
Sun Feb 9, 2020, 05:43 AM
Feb 2020

YESTERDAY 10:09

The divisive federal judge was seen as a hero to some, while others considered him a spearhead of “lawfare” against Cristina Kirchner and her officials.

Federal Judge Claudio Bonadio, who made his name by launching multiple graft probes and trials against the 2007-2015 governments of current Vice-President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, died of a brain tumour early Tuesday just three days after turning 64.

Bonadio had requested that Cristina Kirchner (protected by senatorial immunity from 2017 until last October’s electoral victory) be remanded in custody in no less than five of the dozen cases against her and succeeded in bringing the three main ones – public works corruption dubbed “cuadernos” for the copybooks chronicling it, money-laundering via her Hotesur Patagonian hotel chain and the memorandum of understanding with Iran – to trial before he died.

While for some he became a symbol of unbending integrity for his crusade against corruption, Bonadio began his judicial career in 1993 on a very different footing – as one of the “napkin” judges owing their name to a list of docile magistrates jotted down on a serviette by then Interior Minister Carlos Corach, a personal friend (Bonadio’s youthful militancy in the rightist Iron Guard brought him closer to 1989-99 president Carlos Menem’s brand of Peronism). In his first years as judge he was better known for shelving than pursuing cases.

After beginning under this cloud, Bonadio’s image suffered a further complication some years later when he became a rare case of a judge taking justice into his own hands – in 2001 two youths tried to hold him up in Villa Martelli, only to be shot dead by their intended victim (a keen hunter in his leisure time). This led to Cristina Kirchner calling him a “trigger-happy judge” in one nationwide broadcast, also slamming him as a “judicial hitman” the day before he died.

More:
https://www.batimes.com.ar/news/argentina/judge-claudio-bonadio-leaves-behind-mixed-legacy.phtml

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Latin America»Claudio Bonadio, Argentin...