PA appellate court ruling: legislature must show proof before redacting legal bills

[FakeNoose]

Spotlight PA link: https://www.spotlightpa.org/news/2023/07/pennsylvania-legislature-legal-bills-redactions-commonwealth-court-ruling/

HARRISBURG — Nearly two years ago, Spotlight PA and its partner newsroom, The Caucus, asked Pennsylvania’s legislature for details about how much money lawmakers spend on private lawyers — and why they were hired.

Both chambers turned over hundreds of pages of financial records, but in many instances, they wholly blacked out the reason for hiring those attorneys, leaving the public in the dark about why they were spending taxpayer dollars. An appellate court ruling this week could help shake loose some of that secret information.

- snip -

In decisions released this week, Commonwealth Court Judge Patricia A. McCullough agreed the legislature cannot use attorney-client privilege — or the reasoning that the unredacted material would reveal private work product — to “categorically” redact the subject matter of its legal engagements. Instead, she said the General Assembly bears the burden of providing evidence of those privileges on a case-by-case basis.

- snip -

Paula Knudsen Burke, the RCFP attorney who represented the news organizations, called McCullough’s decisions “a win for access,” as they reaffirm that the legislature must produce evidence in every instance it seeks to shield information about why it is hiring private lawyers.

- more at link -

This is a win for investigative journalism. Thank you Spotlight PA!

[Karadeniz]

1. Sounds good !!!!