The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsArgh! My Stupid Niece and Her Nasty Girl Drama!!!
She is a verbally abusive, hopefully mentally ill (because then there would be a reason for her nastiness outside of just being a horrible person!) USER person who is being rotten to her 72 year old grandmother (aka my mother!) after having taken financial advantage of her to the tune of thousands of dollars.
The most recent email from her to my mother ends with "kiss my ass and have a nice day o and rot in hell" -- seriously, who talks to their GRANDMOTHER who just paid Rent, Car Insurance, Cable/Internet, Electric and Cell Phone bills for you and your Unemployed "Baby Daddy" for NINE MONTHS so you could go to school, which oh-by-the-way, Grandma ALSO subsidized.
Grandma is now (again, quoting from the email) "just being abusive manipulative" with bonus "the apartment is going to fall into eviction so we can move into our house u will never meet ur great grandson and we want absolutely nothing to do with u" -- the lease has Grandma's name on it.
I cannot say what I think of who this girl has decided to become. How DARE she talk to my mother this way? And why was my mother so blind to her obvious character flaws, leading her to be SHOCKED that this worthless young female who was willing to let her grandmother do without so her boyfriend wouldn't have to Get A Job to support either himself, his OTHER child, or his On-Purpose Pregnant Girlfriend, when the rest of us saw it coming a mile away?
Needed. To. Vent.
NYC_SKP
(68,644 posts)And this sounds very much to me like one of those things where one has to say...
Damn it!
Ya gotta wonder: does helping kids even help, or does helping them just perpetuate the problem?
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)There was NOTHING that could be said to get my mom to stop subsidizing her bad choices, and when she knew she wouldn't get approval for the money she was laying out, my mom hid it.
My mother is still handling her own finances, and if she wants to do this, I can't / won't stop her, but getting treated like a pariah because "the boyfriend wants his cable" is just over the top nuts.
Her baby is still in the NICU. Hopefully they keep him there for a long time, because frankly, the niece is just not very mentally stable and I fear for his safety - she is the type of person who would "shake him" to get him to stop crying, if you know what I mean....
NYC_SKP
(68,644 posts)And again it begs the question, is it better to support this behavior or to end support. And, with the child, wow, I don't envy you all in having to make choices.
Good luck, people can change but I don't know what it would take.
HipChick
(25,485 posts)IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)We don't talk to her after an incident where she threatened to say something inappropriate to/about my children (who fortunately weren't there). Since we (husband and I) thought the issue was "maturity" (she was 18) we made a decree that she had to go three months In A Row without telling either her mother or her grandmother to "F*CK *FF" (which we thought was a reasonable thing).
Nine months later, she *finally* hit the three month mark (but only because my mother and sister stopped "tattling" on her when they realized we were serious). My husband talked to her, discovered she really didn't understand why her behavior had been and would continue to be inappropriate, and started using obscenities with him, so we stayed away some more. At Christmas time we sent a gift for her (then boyfriend's/now baby-daddy) four year old son, and received both text and voice mail explaining we had "ruined Christmas" because apparently the "evil baby-mama" won't let him see his son because he doesn't pay child support.
Do not even get me started on that bit of logic because I just turn into a frothing lunatic when confronted with that type of nonsense. Sigh.
Anyway, we haven't dealt with her since, but do stay posted on her drama with the expectation that she will eventually mature, and a positive relationship will resume.
It has actually been a blessing to only be on the "periphery" of her ongoing drama, but the way she treats my mother just ticks me off.
At the same time, maybe this time Grandma will learn her lesson? Seriously, if having your granddaughter threaten to have you put in jail because you are "blackmailing her" by threatening to stop paying a cell phone bill unless she follows your "blackmail demand" to notify you once a day that she is okay because she is in the hospital ("medical situation unchanged" was sent five days in a row) doesn't get the point across that this Nasty Girl is AWFUL ---
And yes, the rest of us were convinced Grandma wasn't going to jail for refusing to pay for a cell phone, but Niece actually believed Grandma would be forced to continue paying *AND* be put in jail for "blackmail" --
ARGH!!! The CRAZY!!! IT BURNS!!!!!
ismnotwasm
(41,998 posts)Oh my God.
I'm sorry you have to deal with this, can you talk you're Mom into blocking her out? At least for a few months? I have some abusive family members that I ended all contact with. It made my life simpler and much happier.
Btw, this sounds like borderline personality disorder, but that just me being an armchair psychologist.
I hope for a better outcome for you and your family
elleng
(131,032 posts)you're not alone, my older daughter seems to have similar traits, and talks to ME that way. More later.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)I just can not picture talking to my mother that way - let alone my GRANDMOTHER!!!
There has to be something mentally wrong; she's been tested for drugs, and really, there isn't any other logical explanation.
elleng
(131,032 posts)and 'likely' at your end too.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)elleng
(131,032 posts)a very nice guy who knows something about mental/emotional stuff due to his job. I hadn't done so in the past but took a chance today, so we're in touch, he's aware of my concern, she MAY be approaching 'ready' to see a counselor of some sort (due to her father's recent death, which hit her hard,) so we shall see.
pscot
(21,024 posts)IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)The nicer you are, the worse she is.
The attacks seem randomly generated, which is why we won't let her be around our children.
RILib
(862 posts)Does your mother now see that this girl is nuts?
Perhaps you could convince your mother to save her money "so she can help out the great grandchild some day," who will surely need help if he or she doesn't turn out to be an abusive user like the granddaughter. By that I mean, present it that way so she doesn't throw money into this situation any more.
Where are the niece's parents in this mess?
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)Frankly, we have been here before, but Grandma always "forgets" as soon as she says she is "sorry" and the wallet re-opens.
Funny story here: supposedly after the last time (when she wouldn't let Grandma come to the hospital to see the new baby), Grandma had learned her lesson - insert eye roll - and then, right as the May rent came due, she reached out to her, so Grandma was writing a check to cover that month's bills.
I told my mother that I was sick of it, and that she was nothing but a wallet, and since she wasn't being allowed to visit the baby in the hospital for ten days (supposedly NICU rules, but my twins were in the NICU, so Grandma got set straight, plus she was there, so she "knew" she was being lied to, but just didn't want to acknowledge it, if you know what I mean), I thought the niece was just waiting to see if the check would clear. Grandma got indignant, but I was adamant - this has been going on for a LONG time.
So Grandma decided to prove me wrong, and sent an "I am so sorry, but I just had an unexpected financial situation come up, and I can't send you money right now" with tons of apologies, etc.
To which the niece responded, "You BITCH! You will never see me EVER AGAIN!"
Grandma apologized some more, the niece sent more obscenity laden texts, and then Grandma sent the "this was a test to see if you loved me or my money; you failed. I will not be sending you anymore money, and will be turning off anything currently in my name."
To which the niece responded, "ha ha! you will have to pay a $200 cancellation fee on my cell phone!"
If the niece doesn't hand the cable box to the cable people (who are coming to her door, for pete's sake - it isn't an inconvenience!), there will be ANOTHER $200 charge, which is what the niece seems to be going for.
Did I mention she is trying to get another thousand dollars from Grandma so she can move into a new place? But she SAYS she will give it to the apartment complex where the current lease will end in two months....
My can not roll far enough to express my disgust. ARGH!
My sister told my mother not to give her money, and has been on the receiving end of the abuse multiple times. Usually the niece takes turns playing the two of them. Bio dad was not a part of her life (thank heaven!) and is currently in jail; adopted dad (mother's ex-husband) is not involved / helpful / financially responsible (kicked her out when she was doing drugs with a 14 year old in his house when she was 18).
Some people have messed up lives through no fault of their own. Others take every opportunity given them, throw it away, then stomp on it because why the heck not? She is from the second category.
orleans
(34,070 posts)if this was my family member and she was pulling this crap on my mother i'd ask her "what the fuck is wrong with you?" and tell her to "grow the fuck up!"
the 200 and 200 for cell phone and cable box seems like a small price to pay considering everything else.
as long as your mom cuts those ties. (which includes screening phone calls)
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)She made an inappropriate "threat" comment about my children, and I calmly told her she needed to immediately back off and apologize because she was crossing a line I wouldn't let her cross. She doubled down, and hasn't been a part of our lives since. We created a "three month trial" situation where she could demonstrate maturity by not telling either her mother or her grandmother to "f*ck *ff" but it took nine months before she could get there, and I am skeptical she did versus them finally not telling us because we were (gasp!) following through. Later, when my husband tried to talk to her about it, it was obvious that she didn't understand why she was actually crossing a line.
I don't think the ties are permanently cut, but I am *hoping* my mother's wallet is permanently closed!
At the same time, probably not - sigh. Grandma is a push-over, and this one is manipulative. Also, NASTY.
Some times the only way to get people to straighten up is to cut them off. Speaking as someone with alcoholics in the family. It sounds like you have already told your mother this, but it might be worth trying again to tell her the granddaughter will never act like a responsible adult as long as your Mom is "enabling her."
$400 would be cheap to end this, imho, certainly less than the ongoing bills.
datasuspect
(26,591 posts)what are the parents like?
what did they do to form such a nasty little monster? they just don't sprout up out of nowhere, doncha know.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)Bio dad has not been a part of her life. Adopted dad has "issues" and is now my sister's ex-husband. My sister's ex-fiance was adored, until they got engaged/she became a teenager, at which point all heck broke loose, and this disaster started building. Grandma (who I love) did NOT help with the discipline issues, and was *constantly* undermining my sister. For example, at one point my niece was being punished by her mother for being disrespectful to a teacher - and the punishment was having her cell phone taken away. Grandma bought her another one "to keep hidden, just in case". Another time the niece got in trouble for something (sneaking out of the house, I believe?), and had her car taken away, which meant she was going to have to (gasp!) TAKE THE BUS!!! She promptly moved in with Grandma, who started giving one of the "friends" gas money so she could get a ride to school instead of having to take the bus. When she got kicked out of Grandma's house for breaking curfew, she moved back in with her mother, and the pattern repeated.
She has been doing this stuff for several years now, because it works. She truly doesn't fear any consequences from either her grandmother or her mother. She doesn't mess with me; I do *NOT* bluff. At one point I told her if I *ever* heard about her hitting her mother again (I had been an inadvertent witness to her kicking her mother in the stomach when she lost an electronic toy for a week, which I would have stomped into pieces if it were my kid at that point), I was going to shave her bald in her sleep - a terrible threat for a then 16 year old teenage girl. Never heard about her physically assaulting her mother ever again, but never sure if it was because she stopped, or my sister just didn't tell because she was worried I would carry through.
I would have. My sister did NOT deserve the crap that one was dishing out. Grrr....
RILib
(862 posts)Sometimes they do. Perfectly decent parents can have a sociopath.
Physically abusing her mother. I think at that point I could have called the cops.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)They were called several times during her teenage years, but they were ZERO help. My sister tried everything, but "out of control teenager" was kind of an understatement, and with Grandma undermining ("I just think you are too hard on her!" it didn't get better. If she had been put in juvie, my sister would have had to pay for her to be there (and while I don't remember the cost, it was outrageously high/would have left her and the sibling homeless). There was always a hope (and still is) that it was a "maturity" issue -- lots of people behave like crazy folk as teenagers, recover from it, and become functional members of family and society.
Honestly, at this point in time, who cares? Lying abusive scammer - who needs it in your life?
Sigh.
stuntcat
(12,022 posts)You just can't do anything with some people... She will probably never understand what a dick she's being.
I'm sorry for her son.. but mostly for your mom.
For some shitty situations the only way to not FREAK COMPLETELY OUT is to vent!!
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)I wish things were different, but...sigh.
hobbit709
(41,694 posts)IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)Since treating people badly has worked out for her in the past, she really has no reason to change her behavior.
My mother/her grandmother *always* forgives her. I support forgiveness, but I also believe that doesn't mean letting someone continue to abuse you (which is what has been happening).
avebury
(10,952 posts)Can you work on your mother to do what is ultimately in the greater interest of the Great-Granddaughter and start to cut the purse strings? It would be nice if she would just pay for the lease until it ends which would both give your niece time and force her to make alternative arrangements. Notifying the landlord ahead of time would also be prudent. It would be worth it to eat the penalties on the cable and cell phone accounts. The penalties might amount to less money then to continue paying the monthly bills. In your niece's current circumstance, cable is a luxury not a necessity.
If everyone agrees to cut the moocher and her deadbeat boyfriend off, surely it won't take too long to have her declared an unfit mother and to remove the child from her home. Sometimes you have to let someone hit rock bottom in order for them to grow up and take responsibility for their own lives.
The situation sucks because you niece and her deadbeat boyfriend have badly abuse your mother and taken advantage of her. It is just as bad for you and the rest of your family because it is probably impossible to get you Mother to stop paying her granddaughter for the abuse that she receives in return.
I am so sorry for what you are going through.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)The final monies are $200 to cancel the cell phone contract (which the niece gleefully texted grandma about with the message of "ha! ha! you have to pay the cancellation fee - and I already have a new phone!" , and either the return of the cable box, or another $200 to them. The cable company actually *picks up* the box where she lives, and they have made repeated trips to get it, but she won't give it to them, which is why the latest communication started - my mother was asking *very politely* for her to give the cable box to the cable people, which then generated the (latest) abuse string. (There was more, but I included the highlights.) Supposedly there will be an eviction since Grandma won't pay the bills anymore, but she lies so often, who knows? Either way, the security should cover the last month, so worst case, she will be out another month of rent if they take her to court.
I hope the hospital folk have figured out the situation, and will keep her son safely away from her, but who knows? I feel sorry for him.
avebury
(10,952 posts)it certainly puts the rest of the family in a tough situation. I hope that your mother hangs tough. It is all about the baby now and letting the new parents fail on their own. Your niece may have a new cell phone but if she can't pay the bill she won't have it for long. Is your sister or any other members of the family in a position to keep a close eye out for the baby and notify Child Protective Services if it becomes warranted? What about the father's side of the family?
Good luck and I hope you can help your Mom to stay strong in the face of this abuse.
avebury
(10,952 posts)is paying the rent, she should have legal right to have access to the apartment. She might have to start legal action to evict them from the apartment. It might be worth the time and money to consult an attorney to see what is the best way to disassociate herself from the apartment situation (and all other financial agreements) and also how best to protect your Mother from any accusations that your niece may level against her. Let an attorney deal with your niece. Is there a way that you Mother can tape any nasty phone calls from your niece? I would not delete any messages left on a message machine.
I hope that the rest of your family is taking a united front to protect you Mother from your niece.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)the rest of the family is just staying out of it for fear of backlash when the inevitable "but this time is DIFFERENT" occurs.
Odds are good my family will somehow find a way to be pissed off at me about this situation - after all, I am actually TALKING ABOUT IT IN PUBLIC! (swoon!)
One must always keep in mind that a person can either be upset about behavior or the people doing the behavior. My family has definite opinions on where the true outrage lies! Lol!
Also, at a certain point, when someone has screwed you over financially multiple times in the past, and you *still* keep giving them money, it just looks like a hobby or something. None of us can stop her, and odds are better than even that she will do it again in the future - this time, 'for the baby!'
avebury
(10,952 posts)the whole situation. Your mother is just as much at fault as your niece because you mother chooses to pour money down the drain and pay for the privilege of being abused by the ungrateful girl. It is one thing for your mother to choose to go down that path and another for you if you decide to walk away from that path. If your Mother complains to you about how she is treated you have every right to look at her right in the eye and say: "Mom, you have only yourself to blame for how _____________ treats you. This is nothing new and if you choose to enable this situation that is your choice. I really am no longer interested in hearing about it anymore."
Until such time as your mother demonstrates that she is no longer competent to handle own affairs, the niece and/or boyfriend break some law, and/or the child is the victim of child neglect or endangerment - there really isn't anything that you can do but fume about the whole situation.
It sucks all around. Your mother is in effect paying to be abused. The girl is not learning to be a responsible adult and parent. The child may grow up to be just like her mother. If you can't change your Mother or your niece all you really can do is watch for an opportunity to sic child protective services on your niece if you find evidence that she is an unfit mother.
nomorenomore08
(13,324 posts)In all honesty, she comes across in your posts as downright sociopathic.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)Or use obscenities, or threaten to cut them out of your life, or have them thrown in jail for "blackmail" when they ask to be kept informed of your safety? Especially if they are paying your bills for you and your sex-partner?
No wonder you don't understand her - most of us don't!
Seriously, there is a book out there called "The Sociopath Next Door" and while I've only read bits and pieces, part of me wonders....there is just such a sense of "entitlement" that I can't even explain, and a streak of cruelty that absolutely sickens me. And she *always* goes after the people who love/care about her, and help her out the most.
Don't get me wrong: my mother has really brought a lot of this on herself, and my sister has been caused ridiculous amounts of pain as a result, but there is just something "not right" about my niece, and I would actually be relieved if she was on drugs, because then at least there would be an explanation for her behavior, instead of just NASTY CRUEL PERSON.
Loryn
(945 posts)My niece does similar things to my mother.
She begged for money to get her cosmetology (sp?) schooling, didn't go, then told my mom "Oh I just got stuff for the house."
Now she won't speak to her. Wicked little bitch.
IdaBriggs
(10,559 posts)Is there any chance this is an age thing?
Loryn
(945 posts)Can't pass it off as young & doesn't know right from wrong. Sadly she is now a mother herself.
avebury
(10,952 posts)to stand up to her abusing grandchild. Feel free to pass this story along to your mother.
I have a friend whose older sister was enabled for years by her mother. How did her sister turn out? The sister has never become a fully functioning member of society but has been a sponge off of the Government and whatever guy she could latch onto. She had a daughter who was sexually abused by her Mother's boyfriend. Mom looked the other way. It took my friend and the third sister to stand behind the niece and see that charges were pressed against the guy who ended up going to prison. The niece is now an adult out of college. How did the niece turn out? The niece is not a functioning member of society and wants everything handed to her. Both of her aunts finally reached the end of their financial rope and cut her off. The girl did get a college education but has failed to be able to hold down a job. She hooked up with a guy on line and accepted an airline ticket to go be with him and his family in Dubai where she was forced to hold a job (which was not what she expected). The family honestly did not know if they would ever see her again. This girl was ill equipped to survive in this country, forget moving to an Arab country. She did make it back home after a few months, only to learn that she came home pregnant. This girl has no business even thinking about having a baby because she can't even support herself. Mean while, the deadbeat Mother (soon to be grandmother) has now been kicked out of her home by her deadbeat daughter. The odds are, this grandchild will not stand a chance in life.
The moral to this story is that if the niece and her boyfriend do not get their act together, the odd for the child are not good.
grasswire
(50,130 posts)Is it possible there's some dementia creeping into her judgment?
If she is younger than retirement age and fully in charge of her faculties, then it is more difficult. But if she is older, then there are protections for elders who are being abused/threatened/manipulated and I would urge you to take advantage of those services for the sake of everyone involved.