Joe or Mick and which one is the John and which one is the Paul

[ArnoldLayne]

Of the Band and why?

[dawg day]

1. Robbie Robertson of the Band looked like Paul McCartney when they were both pretty young thangs

Actually, he looked like John and Paul's lovechild.
https://www.ioffer.com/i/the-band-robbie-robertson-guitar-player-magazine-1976-602907116

[ArnoldLayne]

2. Joe Strummer or Mick Jones

[JenniferJuniper]

3. My first thought too,

Mick was more about the melody; Strummer the lyrics.

So I guess if it's on that basis alone, Joe would be John and Mick would be Paul. But phony Beatlemania has bitten the dust!

[dchill]

4. And which one is the Walrus?

I know I am the eggman. Everyone is the eggman. Good goo goo joob.

[BostonBlue]

5. Mick was George!*