The Afghanistan Papers Confirm America's Longest War Is a Lie
December 12, 2019
Sonali Kolhatkar
Columnist
The Washington Posts Afghanistan Papers, detailing a true history of the nations longest official war, reveals nothing new about the wars futility or about the fact that it was doomed to failure from almost the beginning. The Post fought a legal battle for three years to obtain the documents from the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR), a federal government watchdog agency that interviewed hundreds of officials about their honest assessments of the war.
What the Afghanistan Papers do offer is a confirmation of what critics had already been asserting for nearly two decades: that there is no clearly defined goal or endpoint to the war to help determine when to stop fighting, and that our efforts have been futile at best and deeply destructive at worst.
More than 10 years ago I wrote, together with James Ingalls, a critical assessment of the Afghanistan war. The title of our book was Bleeding Afghanistan: Washington, Warlords, and the Propaganda of Silence (Seven Stories, 2006). Those last three words, the Propaganda of Silence, are a direct reference to poor media coverage and the irresponsible manner in which the press took an uncritical view of the war. The evidence was there for all to see that the U.S. war was doomed to failure once you scratched beneath the surface of officials rosy rhetoric.
The most important function of the Afghanistan Papers is to confirm that government officials have been utterly dishonest with the public about U.S. achievements and progress in Afghanistan. John Sopko, the Special Inspector General at SIGAR, admitted to the Post that the documents prove that the American people have constantly been lied to.
https://www.truthdig.com/articles/afghanistan-papers-confirm-that-the-longest-war-is-a-lie/
BlueMTexpat
(15,369 posts)My husband, who has a subscription to the paper version of the WaPo, saved these articles for me to read now that I am stateside for a few weeks.
His response and this article have only whetted my appetite to read them. I was against the war in Afghanistan, and definitely against that in Iraq. If only ....
But what I am STILL even angrier about is the Reagan Administration's decision to arm radical Muslims in the 1980s, which, IMO, has led inevitably to the current colossal debacle, not only in the ME, but in the entire Muslim world, due in large part to our wretched foreign policy decisions.
I am SO disappointed with those Dems who did NOT feel it necessary to continue with the Iran-Contra investigations when they had to power to do so! The same ugly snakes resurfaced for Bush II and now for 45.
A good book to read about the Afghan Wars (plural) is "Killing the Cranes: A Reporter's Journey Through Three Decades of War in Afghanistan," by Edward Girardet. https://www.amazon.com/Killing-Cranes-Reporters-Journey-Afghanistan/dp/1603583181
I know Girardet personally, and like him, am STILL amazed by how he may narrowly have escaped being killed with Ahmed Shah Massoud shortly before 9-11. That episode is described in his book.
BeckyDem
(8,361 posts)Endless dumb foreign policies, it goes on and on. Thanks for the tip on the book!
I'm surprised this isn't bigger news.