Why we should bulldoze the business school
There are 13,000 business schools on Earth. Thats 13,000 too many. And I should know Ive taught in them for 20 years.
By Martin Parker
Visit the average university campus and it is likely that the newest and most ostentatious building will be occupied by the business school. The business school has the best building because it makes the biggest profits (or, euphemistically, contribution or surplus) as you might expect, from a form of knowledge that teaches people how to make profits.
Business schools have huge influence, yet they are also widely regarded to be intellectually fraudulent places, fostering a culture of short-termism and greed. (There is a whole genre of jokes about what MBA Master of Business Administration really stands for: Mediocre But Arrogant, Management by Accident, More Bad Advice, Master Bullshit Artist and so on.) Critics of business schools come in many shapes and sizes: employers complain that graduates lack practical skills, conservative voices scorn the arriviste MBA, Europeans moan about Americanisation, radicals wail about the concentration of power in the hands of the running dogs of capital. Since 2008, many commentators have also suggested that business schools were complicit in producing the crash.
Having taught in business schools for 20 years, I have come to believe that the best solution to these problems is to shut down business schools altogether. This is not a typical view among my colleagues. Even so, it is remarkable just how much criticism of business schools over the past decade has come from inside the schools themselves. Many business school professors, particularly in north America, have argued that their institutions have gone horribly astray. B-schools have been corrupted, they say, by deans following the money, teachers giving the punters what they want, researchers pumping out paint-by-numbers papers for journals that no one reads and students expecting a qualification in return for their cash (or, more likely, their parents cash). At the end of it all, most business-school graduates wont become high-level managers anyway, just precarious cubicle drones in anonymous office blocks.
These are not complaints from professors of sociology, state policymakers or even outraged anti-capitalist activists. These are views in books written by insiders, by employees of business schools who themselves feel some sense of disquiet or even disgust at what they are getting up to. Of course, these dissenting views are still those of a minority. Most work within business schools is blithely unconcerned with any expression of doubt, participants being too busy oiling the wheels to worry about where the engine is going. Still, this internal criticism is loud and significant.
-snip-
The sort of world that is being produced by the market managerialism that the business school sells is not a pleasant one. Its a sort of utopia for the wealthy and powerful, a group that the students are encouraged to imagine themselves joining, but such privilege is bought at a very high cost, resulting in environmental catastrophe, resource wars and forced migration, inequality within and between countries, the encouragement of hyper-consumption as well as persistently anti-democratic practices at work.
Selling the business school works by ignoring these problems, or by mentioning them as challenges and then ignoring them in the practices of teaching and research. If we want to be able to respond to the challenges that face human life on this planet, then we need to research and teach about as many different forms of organising as we are able to collectively imagine. For us to assume that global capitalism can continue as it is means to assume a path to destruction. So if we are going to move away from business as usual, then we also need to radically reimagine the business school as usual. And this means more than pious murmurings about corporate social responsibility. It means doing away with what we have, and starting again.
https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/apr/27/bulldoze-the-business-school
ThoughtCriminal
(14,049 posts)Which leads us to this guy:
The know-nothing "PHB".
appalachiablue
(41,182 posts)catrose
(5,075 posts)One each of micro- & macroeconomics. I don't know if that's still standard.
appalachiablue
(41,182 posts)took business courses at colleges at a time when there weren't yet real majors or separate degrees in business.
jmowreader
(50,566 posts)Both these men graduated from business schools.
SWBTATTReg
(22,176 posts)destructive and greedy capitalism, plain and simple. Basically it teaches one how to steal someone else's lunch instead of being productive and making your own, regardless of the environmental damage(s) you'll cause, that's for someone else to worry about.
JI7
(89,278 posts)that has to do with that business.
business school is the biggest waste. taking classes in history, sociology, literature etc would all help you more in business than business school.