Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

niyad

(113,349 posts)
Tue Sep 20, 2016, 10:12 PM Sep 2016

Indians and Cowboys: The 2016 Version of an Old Story on a New Planet

Indians and Cowboys: The 2016 Version of an Old Story on a New Planet

?itok=PrghRm2K
"An economy hooked on carbon is threatening life on Earth," writes Ward. "Perhaps it’s time to finally listen to and learn from people who lived here sustainably for thousands of years." (Photo: Sacred Stone Camp/Facebook)

Cowboys and Indians are at it again.

Americans who don’t live in the West may think that the historic clash of Native Americans and pioneering settlers is long past because the Indians were, after all, defeated and now drive cars, watch television, and shop at Walmart. Not so. That classic American narrative is back big time, only the Indians are now the good guys and the cowboys -- well, their rightwing representatives, anyway -- are on the warpath, trying to grab 640 million acres of public lands that they can plunder as if it were yesteryear. Meanwhile, in the Dakotas, America’s Manifest Destiny, that historic push across the Great Plains to the Pacific (murdering and pillaging along the way), seems to be making a return trip to Sioux country in a form that could have planetary consequences.

Energy Transfer Partners is now building the Dakota Access Pipeline, a $3.7 billion oil slick of a project. It’s slated to go from the Bakken gas and oil fracking fields in northern North Dakota across 1,100 miles of the rest of the Dakotas and Iowa to a pipeline hub in Illinois. From there, the oil will head for refineries on the Gulf Coast and ultimately, as the emissions from fossil fuels, into the atmosphere to help create future summers so hot no one will forget them. Keep in mind that, according to global warming’s terrible new math, there’s enough carbon in those Bakken fields to roast the planet -- if, that is, the Sioux and tribes allied with them don’t stop the pipeline. This time, in other words, if the cavalry does ride to the rescue, the heroes on horseback will be speaking Lakota.

Last Stand at Standing Rock

If built as planned, the Dakota Access Pipeline will snake through the headwaters of the Missouri River, a life-giving source of fresh water for millions of people who live downstream, including Native Americans. It’s supposed to pass under that river just a few miles from the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation that straddles North and South Dakota. Protestors point out that, eventually, the pipeline is likely to leak into that vital watershed and the contamination could prove catastrophic. The Army Corps of Engineers, which green-lighted the project’s design, and Energy Transfer Partners have continued to insist that there is no such risk -- even though, suspiciously enough, they decided to change the pipeline’s route to avoid the water supply of North Dakota’s capital, Bismark. As ever, tribal leaders point out, they were ignored rather than consulted in the planning stages, even though the project was to pass directly through their lands.

. . . . .

"Where this goes next is anyone’s guess."Keep in mind that such a project wasn’t exactly a first for the native peoples of the region. In the wake of their defeat and confinement to reservations in the nineteenth century, they lived through a profound transformation of their landscape. Settlers let cattle loose on meadows cleared of wolves, cougars, and bears. The rude stamp of progress followed: fences, roads, dams, mines, sawmills, railroads, power lines, towns, condos, resorts, and in the twenty-first century, vistas increasingly pockmarked with fracking’s drill rigs and service roads. In the Dakota prairies, hundreds of species of grass and flowers were replaced by monocultures of soy and corn, while millions of cattle were substituted for herds of free-roaming bison. As recently as the 1950s and 1960s, the neighboring Sioux and Cheyennelost 200,000 more acres of valuable reservation farmland to dams built without their permission. Entire villages had to relocate. The Dakota Access Pipeline is just the latest of these assaults and yet, in every way, it’s potentially more disastrous. As Lakota Chairman David Archambault puts it, “To poison water is to poison the substance of life.”

. . . . .

http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/09/20/indians-and-cowboys-2016-version-old-story-new-planet

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Indians and Cowboys: The 2016 Version of an Old Story on a New Planet (Original Post) niyad Sep 2016 OP
The governor of ND called out the National Guard... malthaussen Sep 2016 #1
as horrifying as that prospect is, that is exactly the outcome that some wish, it appears. niyad Sep 2016 #2
Oh, I definitely agree. malthaussen Sep 2016 #4
it is deeply depressing to realize how hate-filled, ignorant and ugly some people are. niyad Sep 2016 #5
I had a similar experience after 9/11... malthaussen Sep 2016 #6
. . . niyad Sep 2016 #3

malthaussen

(17,204 posts)
1. The governor of ND called out the National Guard...
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 10:51 AM
Sep 2016

... all it takes is for one moron to issue live ammo to those troops, and we could be having ourselves the first good Indian massacre since Wounded Knee.

-- Mal

malthaussen

(17,204 posts)
4. Oh, I definitely agree.
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 12:41 PM
Sep 2016

It drives me crazy, all the people of more-or-less good will who keep screaming about how bad Mr Trump is, and why don't his supporters realize it? As though it were unfathomable to them that Mr Trump is exactly what these people have been wishing for.

-- Mal

niyad

(113,349 posts)
5. it is deeply depressing to realize how hate-filled, ignorant and ugly some people are.
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 12:57 PM
Sep 2016

that is especially true when it comes to people we thought, at least until the moment they openly admired drumpfy, were at least semi-sane and intelligent.

I know I had that experience with a woman I have known, and liked, for years. Have not spoken to her since.

malthaussen

(17,204 posts)
6. I had a similar experience after 9/11...
Wed Sep 21, 2016, 01:35 PM
Sep 2016

... a friendship of 27 years standing broke up (in part) because we disagreed on the Iraq War/Patriotism/Terrorism issue. Oh, there were many other contributing factors, but I think that she lost any faith in me when I didn't jump on the flag-waving bandwagon.

I do have a cousin in FLA who wants to take her country back again, but we never were close. I am quite certain that if my brother were alive today, he would be pro-Trump, but again, we never were close.

-- Mal

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»Indians and Cowboys: The ...