The Snowden is Ready to Come Home! Story: a Case Study in Typical Media Deceit
The Snowden is Ready to Come Home! Story: a Case Study in Typical Media Deceit
By Glenn Greenwald @ggreenwald 03/04/2015
Most sentient people rationally accept that the U.S. media routinely disseminates misleading stories and outright falsehoods in the most authoritative tones. But its nonetheless valuable to examine particularly egregious case studies to see how that works. In that spirit, lets take yesterdays numerous, breathless reports trumpeting the BREAKING news that Edward Snowden now wants to come home! and is now negotiating the terms of his return!
Ever since Snowden revealed himself to the public 20 months ago, he has repeatedly said the same exact thing when asked about his returning to the U.S.: I would love to come home, and would do so if I could get a fair trial, but right now, I cant.
His primary rationale for this argument has long been that under the Espionage Act, the 1917 statute under which he has been charged, he would be barred by U.S. courts from even raising his key defense: that the information he revealed to journalists should never have been concealed in the first place and he was thus justified in disclosing it to journalists. In other words, when U.S. political and media figures say Snowden should man up, come home and argue to a court that he did nothing wrong, they are deceiving the public, since they have made certain that whistleblowers charged with espionage are legally barred from even raising that defense.
Snowden has also pointed out that legal protections for whistleblowers are explicitly inapplicable to those, like him, who are employed by private contractors (rendering President Obamas argument about why Snowden should come home entirely false). One month after Snowden was revealed, Daniel Ellsberg wrote an Op-Ed in the Washington Post arguing that Snowden did the right thing in leaving the U.S. because he would not be treated fairly, and argued Snowden should not return until he is guaranteed a fully fair trial.
More:
https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/03/04/snowden-wants-come-home-stories-case-study-media-deceit/