A Bottom-Up Solution to the Global Democracy Crisis
Before the no vote on Scotlands independence, The New York Times, carried a post by Neil Irwin in the Upshot making the point that the then upcoming vote shows a global crisis of the elites. He argues that the independence drive reflects . . . a conviction one not ungrounded in reality that the British ruling class has blundered through the last couple of decades. He also thinks that this applies to the Eurozone and the United States to varying degrees, and is . . . a defining feature of our time.
Irwin then updated his first post last night, expanding it and recognizing the victory of the no votes in the referendum. His new post did not add anything essential to his global crisis of the elites diagnosis, so the references and quotations below come solely from his pre-vote post. But the points made apply equally well to his update.
To summarize his argument, for decades now, the elites in major modern, industrial nations have committed leadership blunders and created great discontent among the citizens of their nations, to the point where their polices have contributed to damaging their economies seriously, and the rise of popular resistance embodied in extremist parties and independence movements. Elites have had vast power, but have not lived up to their responsibilities to serve the people of their nations. Discontent with their actions and results is so high that many are questioning the legitimacy of the very governing institutions that claim to serve them, and are exhibiting a greater and greater willingness to do something about these institutions and the policies that they and the elites are generating. Scotland is but one example of that, and his implication is that more examples are in the offing.
Its significant, some might say even remarkable, that Irwins article appeared in The New York Times, since it is a flat out criticism of elite leadership over a number of decades and a warning to elites to improve their performance or deal with the consequences. But I think it still misses the most important question. That question is whether there is a global crisis of elites or a global crisis of democracies? Im afraid I think that the crisis of elite leadership is only a symptom of the underlying cause of a broader global crisis of democracy.
The Global Crisis of Democracy
Think about it. Irwin is describing a situation in which the elites have been failing their citizens for decades now, following neoliberal economic policies that have resulted in increasing inequality and the renewed appearance of extreme economic instability, and doing this while they continuously mislead the public about their poor performance, using the power of the money that supports them and permeates the mass media.
http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2014/09/bottom-solution-global-democracy-crisis.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+neweconomicperspectives%2FyMfv+%28New+Economic+Perspectives%29
dougolat
(716 posts)good diagnosis and discussion at the link.
Lydia Leftcoast
(48,217 posts)these were not "blunders." The elites absolutely intended to rob the rest of us blind.