Court Overturns Some Blagojevich Senate-Seat Convictions
Source: ABC News
A federal appeals court Tuesday overturned some of the most sensational convictions that sent former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich off to a lengthy stint in prison, ruling prosecutors did not prove the Democrat broke the law as he appeared to try to auction off an appointment to President Barack Obama's old Senate seat.
It wasn't immediately clear whether the stunning decision from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago means the 58-year-old, currently Inmate No. 40892-424 in a Colorado prison, will serve less than his original 14-year sentence.
The two-term governor proclaimed his innocence for years on talk shows, on NBC's "The Apprentice" reality show and while impersonating Elvis his idol at a block party. Taking the stand at his decisive retrial in 2011, a sometimes-tearful Blagojevich said he was a flawed man but no criminal.
His appeal echoed a familiar refrain in public and in court: Blagojevich had merely engaged in legal, run-of-the-mill political horse-trading that pols everywhere engage in.
Read more: http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/court-overturns-blagojevich-convictions-32599632
Seems to me like there is a pretty fine line between politics as usual and illegal "pay to play".
samsingh
(17,601 posts)if dems do anything they get put into prison.
Elmer S. E. Dump
(5,751 posts)samsingh
(17,601 posts)former9thward
(32,093 posts)And was sent to prison for the same stuff Blago did.
samsingh
(17,601 posts)former9thward
(32,093 posts)He was not convicted of as many counts as Blago. Senator Durbin asked Bush to commute Ryan's sentence but Bush refused.
samsingh
(17,601 posts)former9thward
(32,093 posts)And Ryan never tried to sell a Senate seat.
happyslug
(14,779 posts)The court basically ruled that if something involves "Logrolling" it is NOT criminal but if it involves the exchange of money it is illegal. Thus where actual money was involved, those counts were upheld, but if the act involved politicians doing favors for each other those counts were ruled legal. Thus this is a limited reversal and it is noted the court also commented that the sentence was BELOW the Federal guidelines for even the charges it upheld. Thus the Judge can re-sentence the Governor to the exact time he was sentences before.
Lets work this through statute by statute. Section 1951, the Hobbs Act, which underlies Counts 21 and 22, forbids interference with commerce by robbery or extortion. Blagojevich did not rob anyone, and extortion, a defined term, means the obtaining of property from another, with his consent, induced by wrongful use of actual or threatened force, violence, or fear, or under color of official right (§1951(b)(2)). The indictment charged Blagojevich with the color of official right version of extortion, but none of the evidence suggests that Blagojevich claimed to have an official right to a job in the Cabinet. He did have an official right to appoint a new Senator, but unless a position in the Cabinet is property from the Presidents perspective, then seeking it does not amount to extortion. Yet a political office belongs to the people, not to the incumbent (or to someone hankering after the position). Cleveland v. United States, 531 U.S. 12 (2000), holds that state and municipal licenses, and similar documents, are not property in the hands of a public agency. Thats equally true of public positions. The President-elect did not have a property interest in any Cabinet job, so an attempt to get him to appoint a particular person to the Cabinet is not an attempt to secure property from the President (or the citizenry at large).......
The convictions on Counts 5, 6, 21, 22, and 23 are vacated; the remaining convictions are affirmed. The sentence is vacated, and the case is remanded for retrial on the vacated counts. Circuit Rule 36 will not apply. If the prosecutor elects to drop these charges, then the district court should proceed directly to resentencing. Because we have affirmed the convictions on most counts and concluded that the advisory sentencing range lies above 168 months, Blagojevich is not entitled to be released pending these further proceedings.
bucolic_frolic
(43,342 posts)THIS IS THE GREATEST THING SINCE THEY DIGITIZED "XANADU"!!!!!