MSNBC Vote: Do you agree with Supreme Court ruling on health care law?

[cal04]

Do you agree with this ruling?

Yes. Roberts provides a rational, nuanced decision in upholding the law.

No. The reasoning in this decision is fractured and incorrect.

I don’t know. I’ll have to read the whole decision, along with the concurring and dissenting decisions, before I decide myself.

http://nbcpolitics.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/28/12459343-vote-do-you-agree-with-supreme-court-ruling-on-health-care-law?lite

Total of 15,544 votes
60.8%
Yes. Roberts provides a rational, nuanced decision in upholding the law.
9,444 votes
35.8%
No. The reasoning in this decision is fractured and incorrect.
5,567 votes
3.4%
I don’t know. I’ll have to read the whole decision, along with the concurring and dissenting decisions, before I decide myself.
533 votes

[lamp_shade]

1. Done.

[NBachers]

2. Me Too Me Too

[Gothmog]

3. Done

I disagree with Roberts and think that the law was also valid under the commerce clause but voted yes in this poll

[Spazito]

4. Done!

I have to say it felt a bit strange to be voting FOR something Roberts supported but I was happy to do so in this instance.

[sadbear]

5. The no's are growing.

Once the Paulbots get done, it'll look like no one in America supported the decision.

[lamp_shade]

6. 58.1% yes - 38.5% no.... 136,273 votes

[lamp_shade]

7. 55.6% yes. 40.9% no. 278,620 votes.