Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

davidn3600

(6,342 posts)
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 07:54 PM Apr 2016

Teaching consultant claims grades and punctuality is a form of white supremacy

A professional education consultant and teacher trainer argued at the White Privilege Conference (WPC) in Philadelphia that great teachers must also be liberal activists, and described in detail her goal for destroying the “white supremacist” nature of modern education.

Heather Hackman operates Hackman Consulting Group and was formerly a professor of multicultural education at Minnesota’s St. Cloud State University, where she taught future teachers. On Friday, Hackman was given a platform at WPC to deliver a workshop with the lengthy title “No Freedom Unless We Call Out the Wizard Behind The Curtain: Critically Addressing the Corrosive Effects of Whiteness in Teacher Education and Professional Development.” The long title masked a simple thesis on Hackman’s part: Modern education is hopelessly tainted by white supremacy and the “white imperial gaze,” and the solution is to train prospective teachers in college to be activists as well as pedagogues.

----

“The racial narrative of White tends to be like this: Rugged individual, honest, hard-working, disciplined, rigorous, successful,” she said. “And so then, the narrative of U.S. public education: Individual assessments, competition, outcome over process (I care more about your grades than how you’re doing), ‘discipline’ where we care more about your attendance and making sure you’re not tardy than we care about your relationships … proper English must be spoken (which is just assimilation into standard U.S. dialect), hierarchical power structure, and heavy goal orientation.”

While the traits listed may simply be regarded as positive traits for success in the modern world, Hackman described them as specific cultural traits chosen and emphasized to favor whites to the detriment of non-white groups, who are forced to assimilate white traits such as good discipline and goal orientation or else be left behind.

Hackman’s natural solution, then, is to train teachers to move away from all these aspects of white privilege in education. She routinely touted the benefits of collective assessments (measuring student learning at the class level instead of determining whether each student knows the material), as well as eliminating all school grades entirely.


http://dailycaller.com/2016/04/16/professional-educator-grades-showing-up-on-time-are-a-form-of-white-supremacy/

Sorry, but this is nuts.
35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Teaching consultant claims grades and punctuality is a form of white supremacy (Original Post) davidn3600 Apr 2016 OP
Well, that's certainly got the Daily Caller spin on it. Brickbat Apr 2016 #1
I am still trying to figure out when (and why) .... etherealtruth Apr 2016 #31
Believe me, I'm trying to understand her point, but I just can't. BillZBubb Apr 2016 #2
Grades today-employee yearly reviews xmas74 Apr 2016 #3
She's just a hack milking the inclusiveness gravy train Albertoo Apr 2016 #4
WPC... ileus Apr 2016 #5
The irony of suggesting punctuality and good grades are the hallmark of white people is pretty good. linuxman Apr 2016 #6
So black kids should have lower standards? XemaSab Apr 2016 #7
My exact view on affirmative action. nt clarice Apr 2016 #32
What a steaming pantload on nonsense. Odin2005 Apr 2016 #8
I don't think "shaming" is the answer to anything really tkmorris Apr 2016 #24
I think she has a point Nevernose Apr 2016 #9
Yes. Nothing reeks more of white male privilege than insisting on punctuality (nt) Nye Bevan Apr 2016 #10
Or having a degree that says, Igel Apr 2016 #17
Well this is one white guy who missed that meeting. Orrex Apr 2016 #11
What a racist... TipTok Apr 2016 #12
I'm sooooooooooo confused. So Far From Heaven Apr 2016 #13
Wtf???? Takket Apr 2016 #14
Yes, it seems to me that she is the one who is the racist smirkymonkey Apr 2016 #19
The Opening Post says "Sorry, but this is nuts." Jeffersons Ghost Apr 2016 #15
Define "you people" tkmorris Apr 2016 #26
She sounds like a right winger trolling liberals Democat Apr 2016 #16
And why are all the buses yellow? That isn't fair to buses of other color. NightWatcher Apr 2016 #18
I'm sure this has to be true Capt. Obvious Apr 2016 #20
White Privilege Conference Ace Rothstein Apr 2016 #21
From Tucker Carlson's publication---absolute race baiting. Kingofalldems Apr 2016 #22
One more thing--I see some of DU right wingers Kingofalldems Apr 2016 #23
The Daily Caller is awful. Ace Rothstein Apr 2016 #30
"proper English must be spoken" yuiyoshida Apr 2016 #25
Race-baiting bee ess from The Daily Caller. tenderfoot Apr 2016 #27
Vonnegut makes a similar point Orrex Apr 2016 #28
She alienates potential supporters by bringing in White privilege. Want to see competition in snagglepuss Apr 2016 #29
go away, batin' hunter Apr 2016 #33
I doubt the characterization of her work in the OP ... kwassa Apr 2016 #34
How fucking ridiculous. X_Digger Apr 2016 #35

etherealtruth

(22,165 posts)
31. I am still trying to figure out when (and why) ....
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 06:23 PM
Apr 2016

... extreme right wing (read nut job) sources became acceptable here. There was a time when they were held up for derision . Never were they viewed as reliable

BillZBubb

(10,650 posts)
2. Believe me, I'm trying to understand her point, but I just can't.
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 08:21 PM
Apr 2016

A foundation of a good education is making sure the student knows the material--at least well enough to move on to the next level. That has NOTHING to do with white privilege or racism. It is sad that someone is suggesting that.

xmas74

(29,675 posts)
3. Grades today-employee yearly reviews
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 08:36 PM
Apr 2016

In the working world.

Punctuality -a needed skill in their future lives. No one will hire or keep employed someone who is constantly late. And arriving early can be advantageous for any number of reasons.

Proper English - uniformity. It allows for someone to be easily understood no matter where in the U.S.

Goal orientation -that's life. You set goals, reach them, reward yourself and set a new one. Hopefully you learn and grow from the experience.

Determining grades at the class level seems to me to make teachers want to "teach to the test". No individual assessments hinders and could actually punish. A student's learning disability might not be noticed. Another student's gifted status might not be recognized. Both types of students are punished this way.

 

linuxman

(2,337 posts)
6. The irony of suggesting punctuality and good grades are the hallmark of white people is pretty good.
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 08:55 PM
Apr 2016

Truly the tolerance train has come full circle.

XemaSab

(60,212 posts)
7. So black kids should have lower standards?
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 09:23 PM
Apr 2016

Maybe they should have different schools, too, so they don't disrupt the white students when they wander in late.

This is a perfect example of "liberal" thinking that winds up being SUPER racist.

Odin2005

(53,521 posts)
8. What a steaming pantload on nonsense.
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 11:03 PM
Apr 2016

Of course shaming Black kids for using AAVE is racist and should not be done, but the rest of that screed is utter nonsense.

tkmorris

(11,138 posts)
24. I don't think "shaming" is the answer to anything really
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 11:47 AM
Apr 2016

But AAVE is not the language one should use in an educational or professional environment, not if one wants to be successful.

I learned from my parents an odd Appalachian/Kentucky farmer hybrid dialect, and I can tell you that that is NOT the language you want to use in the Washington DC area school system, or really anywhere else, if you want to be taken seriously.

Nevernose

(13,081 posts)
9. I think she has a point
Sun Apr 17, 2016, 11:12 PM
Apr 2016

I don't think educators spend enough time thinking about what the system is teaching, why it's taught, etc. Not the curriculum, but the entire system. It does stand to reason that a system designed by, and primarily for, white males, might tend to focus on the values that 19th century white makes thought were most important.

This is some basic Paolo Freire, Critical Literacy stuff. Her questions are good, in my opinion. Her solutions, and best, are the opposite of pragmatic, and at worst they're dumb. But I think her questions are valuable.

Igel

(35,337 posts)
17. Or having a degree that says,
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 11:09 AM
Apr 2016

"Student X has learned this material" mean, actually, that "Student X may have the degree, but Students Y and Z were the ones who really knew it."

I have a lot of kids like this. They copy answers and say they know it. Then they fail the test, "But I knew this."

Some copy test questions. I continually hope that they get doctors and lawyers with their education ethic. And that they're not responsible for me or my circumstances when I'm unable to take care of myself.

So Far From Heaven

(354 posts)
13. I'm sooooooooooo confused.
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 01:56 AM
Apr 2016

I teach classes having up to 95 percent minority enrollment so maybe my non-white students are different than hers, but every ethnic group I've ever taught had some form of acceptable discipline and goal achievement traits incorporated. Every last one of them.

They may encourage group achievement as a cultural benefit but they also always encourage individual achievement to increase or add to the society as a whole.

What the hell is she talking about?

Individual student assessment is a whole new bag of worms I struggle with continuously and is intentionally left out of my discussion.

Takket

(21,611 posts)
14. Wtf????
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 06:21 AM
Apr 2016

This is what I'm getting out of this: only whites are capable of good behavior and grades, so in fairness to blacks, we need to stop tracking these things.

tkmorris

(11,138 posts)
26. Define "you people"
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 11:54 AM
Apr 2016

Further, as it would appear that you disagree that this is "nuts" (though your commentary is too terse to be entirely certain), could you elaborate on why you think it is not?

Kingofalldems

(38,469 posts)
22. From Tucker Carlson's publication---absolute race baiting.
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 11:31 AM
Apr 2016

I could find someone of no consequence who has an opinion based on nonsense too.

I would say good try but it really wasn't.

Ace Rothstein

(3,183 posts)
30. The Daily Caller is awful.
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 12:08 PM
Apr 2016

But in this case they are literally quoting someone. The content is embarrassing to the left so no liberal rags are going to cover something like the White Privilege Conference.

Orrex

(63,220 posts)
28. Vonnegut makes a similar point
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 11:59 AM
Apr 2016
This was because their English teachers would wince and cover their ears and give them flunking grades and so on whenever they failed to speak like English aristocrats before the First World War. Also: they were told that they were unworthy to speak or write their language if they couldn’t love or understand incomprehensible novels and poems and plays about people long ago and far away, such as Ivanhoe. The black people would not put up with this. They went on talking English every which way. They refused to read books they couldn’t understand—on the grounds they couldn’t understand them. They would ask such impudent questions as, “Whuffo I want to read no Tale of Two Cities? Whuffo?”
From Breakfast of Champions

snagglepuss

(12,704 posts)
29. She alienates potential supporters by bringing in White privilege. Want to see competition in
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 12:08 PM
Apr 2016

education just look at India, Japan, China, Korea. Horribly competitive. None White. The best rated educational system is ultra White Finland which tossed competition out the window as well as other changes that run counter to mainstream thinking about education. Amazing stuff.

kwassa

(23,340 posts)
34. I doubt the characterization of her work in the OP ...
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 07:58 PM
Apr 2016

Due to the extreme bias of the Daily Caller. A tainted source if ever there was one.

X_Digger

(18,585 posts)
35. How fucking ridiculous.
Mon Apr 18, 2016, 08:07 PM
Apr 2016

And downright racist.

Phrased differently, "Black people can't be on time, and can't be expected to remember things and processes."

What.the.fuck.??!??!??

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Teaching consultant claim...