General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWow they just keep coming, denying Pres. Obama his right
Republicans want a "strict constitutionalist" to replace Scalia while denying Obama his constitutional right to nominate a justice
https://twitter.com/igorvolsky
WhaTHellsgoingonhere
(5,252 posts)As of right now, the Supreme Court is more liberal. Ties are broken by lower court rulings. That gives us a much better chance than it getting kicked to the SCOTUS.
If they block Obama, they'll block Hillary and Bernie. Similarly, if they block Obama, we'll block Trump or Cruz or Rubio.
It's not the worst of all situations IMO
Travis_0004
(5,417 posts)The senate has the power to vote however they want. Eventually they have to compromise, but one cant take away the senates constitutional right to vote how they want.
cal04
(41,505 posts)even if it is their job to confirm or not
http://trailblazersblog.dallasnews.com/2016/02/cruz-rubio-mcconnell-insist-that-new-president-fill-scalia-seat-on-supreme-court.html/
Ms. Yertle
(466 posts)that they will "insist" he not nominate someone. He can nominate, and they can refuse to confirm. And will, most likely.
cal04
(41,505 posts)Ms. Yertle
(466 posts)and I'm seeing it differently. I think they are stating that they won't confirm anyone Obama nominates. That's far different from telling a sitting president he can't nominate.
I guess it could be interpreted either way.
cal04
(41,505 posts)I think the many different articles like this are saying it so many ways I may have interpreted it wrong
In a swift statement designed to warn Barack Obama against even nominating a replacement, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/scalia-obama-replacement_us_56bfabe4e4b08ffac1258cf5
Ms. Yertle
(466 posts)In 1968, after announcing he would not seek another term as President, Lyndon Johnson attempted to replace the retiring Chief Justice Earl Warren with Associate Justice Abe Fortas. Johnson also nominated Homer Thornberry to fill the Fortas seat. The Senate Republicans filibustered the Fortas nomination and threatened not to reconfirm Fortas in his Associate Justice seat unless Johnson backed down on the nomination of a Chief Justice. The Republicans with help from some Southern Democrats prevailed and lame duck Johnson allowed the next President to nominate the next CJ. That set a precedent for Lame Ducks not choosing Supreme Justices. Homer Thornberry was withdrawn and the Court ran with 8 justices until Nixon chose Warren Burger.
It's happened before.
Mosby
(16,318 posts)spanone
(135,844 posts)hey wing nuts