General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSnowden's leaks forced NSA reform on Congress. The US would still jail him
By Trevor Timm
The catalyst for Congress historic vote on NSA reform on Tuesday the same person who led to a federal court to rule that NSA mass surveillance of Americans was illegal remains exiled from the United States and faces decades in jail. The crime hes accused of? Telling the American public the very truth that forced Congress to restrict, rather than expand, the spy agencys power for the first time in over forty years.
The passage of the USA Freedom Act is quite simply a vindication of Edward Snowden, and its not just civil libertarians who have noticed: hes forced even some of the most establishment-friendly commentators to change their opinions of his actions. But its a shame that almost everyone nonetheless ignores the oppressive law under which Snowden was charged or the US governments outrageous position in his case: that if he were to stand trial, he could not tell the jury what his whistleblowing has accomplished.
The White House told reporters on Thursday that, despite the imminent passage of NSA reform, they still believe Edward Snowden still belongs in prison (presumably for life, given his potential charges), while at the same time, brazenly taking credit for the USA Freedom Act passing, saying that historians would consider it part of Obamas legacy. Hopefully historians will also remember, as Ryan Lizza adeptly documented in the New Yorker, that Obama was handed every opportunity to reform the NSA before Edward Snowden, yet behind the scenes repeatedly refused to do so. Instead, the Obama administration was dragged kicking and screaming across the finish line by Snowdens disclosures, all while engaging in fear-mongering that would make Dick Cheney proud.
Snowden is now the most influential whistleblower of his generation. Even his biggest detractors, the same people who once all but refused to utter his name, have recently had to concede his influence. Take, for example, this amusing article at the Huffington Post quoting various Senators across the political spectrum who were forced to begrudgingly admit that they wouldnt even be having the debate over reforming the NSAs surveillance practices if it wasnt for Snowden. You can almost hear the contempt coming out of their mouths as you read their reactions.
more
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/03/snowden-leaks-nsa-reform-congress-still-facing-jail
BillZBubb
(10,650 posts)Snowden should be a national hero (he is one to people who oppose the national security state). Clapper should be in jail. Obama should admit he was wrong on the NSA and apologize, then issue a full pardon to Snowden.
Obama taking credit for reining in the NSA is disgusting. He did everything he could to let the NSA keep doing what it wanted to do.
questionseverything
(9,656 posts)i also wonder how reigned in this bill makes the nsa?
they kept the 215 section...i don't have time to research it today but i wonder if any real changes happened or not
cui bono
(19,926 posts)Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)The Masters of the Universe forced by some low level dweeb with boxes in his garage to do something goes down with them like gargling drain cleaner and rusty razorblades.