General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhoa! Sounds like Harry is ready to pull the nuclear trigger on filibusters:
@NowWithAlex:
Its time to change the Senate before this institution becomes obsolete -@SenatorReid
'Bout time!
whttevrr
(2,345 posts)Someone should link all the disparate threads that are about to be started...
Here's two so far:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10024069293
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10024069250
lame54
(35,293 posts)renie408
(9,854 posts)KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)Lochloosa
(16,066 posts)They have blocked 3 nominees so far that I'm aware of.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)ffr
(22,670 posts)spartan61
(2,091 posts)that the nuclear option would only be for filibusters for judicial nominees. Did anyone else hear that?
Nictuku
(3,614 posts)Blue Owl
(50,414 posts)And by Frank I mean Harry.
vi5
(13,305 posts)...from the risk or at least possibility of losing the majority.
I was in favor of him doing this, but any point during the previous 5 years the same thing could have been done and it would have garnered the same reaction and fainting couch antics on the right, but it would have helped more legislation pass and it would have enabled better legislation to pass. It would have resulted in better appointments being made (judicial, amabassadors, cabinet, etc.).
scheming daemons
(25,487 posts)So we might as well get a year out of it.
napkinz
(17,199 posts)The day the GOP retakes the senate, the filibuster is history.
So let's do it now.
AAO
(3,300 posts)... the point is, should they ever retake the Senate, they WILL do away with the filibuster, regardless of what Harry does today.
The GOP talks about blowing up the rules.
The GOP has been blowing up the rules for years now. Protocol and compromise have been expunged from their vocabulary.
AAO
(3,300 posts)vi5
(13,305 posts)...which it is, then we should have done it sooner and gotten through more and better legislation and more and better judicial appointments.
jeff47
(26,549 posts)It's only for judicial and executive nominees, except for the SCOTUS. Legislation and SCOTUS nominations can still be filibustered.
ladyVet
(1,587 posts)Just in time to ruin a majority for Dems in 2014. Typical.
scheming daemons
(25,487 posts)Filibuster reform will allow senate to get shit done, which will make it likelier that we hold the senate.
hatrack
(59,587 posts)They might even like us if we just do what they want.
Wake up.
vi5
(13,305 posts)I said the same thing above. Not that we shouldn't do it now, it's that we should have done it much SOONER if we were going to do it at all.
CatWoman
(79,302 posts)It's all over now.
karadax
(284 posts)This is a bad idea. It gives Republicans more fuel to toss on the fire.
scheming daemons
(25,487 posts)A) the obstruction in the house is still there
B) this only affects appointments, not legislation.
All the wailing from "supposed" liberals when the Democrats show a spine is amusing to me.
Can you guys be more transparent?
tkmorris
(11,138 posts)For some reason you single out "supposed" Liberals, but the guy you are responding to has all of 38 posts here. I dunno who he is and I'm betting you don't either.
As for the swipe at Liberals, I am an unabashed one and I have been bitching at Reid to pull this trigger for years, and would be absolutely delighted if he does so now.
Maybe this isn't the best topic or place to start bashing Liberals, especially when your argument leaks like a rusty sieve.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Last edited Thu Nov 21, 2013, 04:13 PM - Edit history (2)
But if they do, we can kiss Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, ACA, EPA and every other thing that came from or grew out of the New Deal goodbye forever.
These fascists are not playing around and they are very close to dividing this nation up into little Koch kingdoms. Complacency or bickering is not the answer to 2014.
Lose that and there are red states aplenty who can and will call for a Constitutional convention to repeal all the amendments after the 10th. All they need is 38 states with GOP majority in their state houses to overrule the millions of us who don't live in those states, while they grind their own citizenry under crony capitalism and theocracy.
The nihilism of the right and the left will meet under the guise of rooting out their special demons, welcoming a new way of doing things, or so they think. Only to be swept away by media propaganda, by, for and of the rich only. We see this more and more, they won't stop while the ultimate prize they want, the federal government is up for grabs. Which is what a Constitutional convention does.
Americans have lived under those protections such as the 14th enshrined, Birthright Citizenship, Due Process and Equal Protection Under the Law, with they entail and the laws that have been based on them. Those go all the way through women's right to vote, and have been in place for so long they believe they are a written in stone. The GOP wants the Articles of Confederation back.
Even the first ten amendments did not end slavery, period, but the Tenthers don't care. The first ten did not allow full suffrage. They did not allow women any control of their bodies. It did not allow direct elections. The GOP does not want that, they want the rich and powerful to be in charge of that process. These facts are conveniently left out in diatribes about privacy and civil liberties.
The left is in denial, thinking that cheering media mockery was sufficient. It never was, it was added into politics to divide and not find solutions. They ignored the clear voices from the right on their intentions, national personhood laws, right to work laws with no minimum wage, voting rights, regulations, ending all the social safety net.
Both extremes now revel in the destruction of the old ways they mock, as Democrats comfort themselves with the notion 'wiser heads will prevail' and walk away from their civic responsibility. They have decided they don't need to show up in local and state elections to affect regional policy and then the national policy.
One example of many, charter schools and other regressive institutions didn't come out of D.C., no matter who wants to point the finger there. D.C. is reacting to the reality on the ground in the states, being voted in by supporters of theocracy and maniacs put in state office in yearly and the midterms.
The 2010 midterm virtually destroyed this nation, and those put in office by propaganda have not slowed their agenda, as the money keeps pouring in to buy new adherents. Those who didn't vote for reasons they have now forgotten, still point fingers upward, and it changes nothing.
Reid has been rightfully afraid of changing the rules. He is not a coward, he is a realist. He has seen these maniacs up close; we only see glimpses. This is a clever form of treason in slow motion and Reid gets no help from the sleeping public who doesn't vote to replace these demagogues.
Ryan's plan is close to reality, with calls for a Constitutional convention. The GOP will rewrite the nation's legal framework according to the ALEC model. It will be full fascist rule, nowhere to turn for redress. People will be forced to deal with those who expect a bribe to be paid to do anything. For those without the money to bribe, they will get nothing and likely lose all they have.
People have been asleep at the ballot for too long, falling for the media tactics and not voting, being distracted by anything to demoralize us. We haven't seen anything yet and it is coming. If we lose in 2014, that's it for me, I won't even bother to talk about any of it anymore.
jeff47
(26,549 posts)The giant hole in your "concern" is that Republican majority you fear could also change the rules.
Lugnut
(9,791 posts)malaise
(269,053 posts)ReTHUGs would have pulled it four years ago. Enough with the fugging sabotage
Lint Head
(15,064 posts)Skidmore
(37,364 posts)another Dem are holdouts on this vote. Perhaps we can help with that.
brooklynite
(94,594 posts)We can afford to lose two votes