General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhy didn't George Zimmerman try starting a conversation with Trayvon Martin instead of killing him?
Why not just announce "I'm the neighborhood watch, is everything OK?" even if Trayvon couldn't be seen, or even when he did visibly see Trayvon, perhaps when he was driving and pulled up next to him. He could have kept announcing it allowing Trayvon to earn his trust, not be afraid, and explain who he was and where he was going.
It seems like a million different scenarios could have prevented what happened, unless of course Zimmerman WAS looking for a confrontation. Even law enforcement announce themselves.
It sure seems like George Zimmerman desperately wanted a confrontation, while Trayvon Martin desperately DIDN'T, hence Trayvon eventually running AWAY from creepy stalker.
It's just sickening that so many different scenarios could have played out without confrontation yet Trayvon ends up dead (RIP).
There's a certain gun mentality.
grasswire
(50,130 posts)Perhaps it is the law enforcement training he began, perhaps he associates with racists. Maybe he was just raised that way. Clearly, he profiled Trayvon and acted accordingly.
Coyotl
(15,262 posts)Recursion
(56,582 posts)JaneyVee
(19,877 posts)Hugabear
(10,340 posts)This is evidenced from his prior 911 calls.
Shooting Trayvon made sure that he wouldn't get away
Vattel
(9,289 posts)What evidence is there that Zimmerman desperately wanted a confrontation, or that Martin desperately wanted to avoid one? The evidence suggests that Martin approached Zimmerman when he was in his car. The evidence suggests that Martin had plenty of time to get home and enter his house while Zimmerman was on the phone with police. No eye witness contradicts Zimmerman's claim that Martin confronted him and not vice-versa.
HipChick
(25,485 posts)because he was looking for trouble..he was looking for a fight...
Response to HipChick (Reply #6)
Name removed Message auto-removed
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)CTyankee
(63,912 posts)GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)CTyankee
(63,912 posts)GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)Therefore, I decline to speculate.
CTyankee
(63,912 posts)GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)CTyankee
(63,912 posts)HangOnKids
(4,291 posts)Because I have yet to see any examples of the best Of Zimmy. Maybe you have some stories of him rescuing cats or feeding the homeless?
Cirque du So-What
(25,989 posts)Just because he is a fucking asshole who beats the woman he supposedly loves?
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2012-03-21/news/os-george-zimmerman-domestic-violence-20120321_1_petitions-documents-injunctions
Or who can't control his little temper to the extent that he tries to fight with cops?
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/03/27/10894561-zimmerman-accused-of-domestic-violence-fighting-with-a-police-officer
That's a real charmer to whom you've chosen to give the benefit of the doubt.
Before any further attempt at rehabilitating poor, misunderstood Zimmy, I want to point out that although he self-identifies as 'Hispanic,' if it weren't for Judge Daddy, he'd still be cooling his heels in the Graybar Hotel instead of getting off, which may have led to delusions of 'untouchability' around Sanford, FL. Perhaps if he'd taken his punishment like a man at least once in his life, we wouldn't be pleasantly conversing on a Saturday afternoon about how fucking virtuous or villainous is the man who ended the life of Trayvon Martin.
Anansi1171
(793 posts)Travis_0004
(5,417 posts)It seems like neither people in the dispute were saints.
csziggy
(34,138 posts)I haven't seen that claim made in any reputable news source, just right wing blogs.
So, give me a link for that claim, please. For an example of how it's done, check out the message above that provided links for each claim about Zimmerman.
csziggy
(34,138 posts)And a Facebook account that has proven to not belong to the dead Trayvon Martin.
"The kicker? The photo on the right was of a different Trayvon Martin. One that was still alive and in no way related to the deceased.
"You might be asking, Well, how could she have known? She and her Team should have known because the photo in question came from a Facebook profile belonging to a living breathing, middle-finger-flipping Trayvon Martin who lists his school as Myers Middle School not Dr. Michael M. Krop Senior High School. Additionally, all of his relatives are listed as living in Savannah, Georgia. The late Martin grew up in Miami Gardens."
- See more at: http://restoringtruthiness.org/13700/malkin-bias-twitchy-com-posts-fake-photo-of-trayvon-martin-using-new-teamdueprocess-no-joke#sthash.SdCjbImx.dpuf
Original Wagist collumn: http://www.wagist.com/2012/dan-linehan/was-trayvon-martin-a-drug-dealer
Discussion of smear campaign against Trayvon Martin: http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2012/03/26/452310/what-everyone-needs-to-know-about-the-smear-campaign-against-trayvon-martin-1995-2012/
"5. Without any evidence, a right-wing columnist alleged that Martin assaulted a bus driver. Unlike Zimmerman, Trayvon has no documented history of violence. This allegation continues to be advanced by a blogger on the Examiner even after the real reason was leaked to the police and confirmed by the family."
The bus driver comment that was taken up by the media came from the same sources as the pictures which have been proven to NOT be the dead Trayvon Martin.
http://www.truthorfiction.com/rumors/m/MARTIN-PHOTO.htm#.UdBPSNimVGE
Stardust
(3,894 posts)Dawgs
(14,755 posts)If Zimmerman was doing NOTHING WRONG then why would Martin attack him? Just for the fun of it?
Seems like quite an assumption that Martin would just attack Zimmerman for no reason.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)Dawgs
(14,755 posts)arcane1
(38,613 posts)WTF? If that bullshit was true, how on Earth would they end up on the ground, away from the car???
Did Mean old Martin force the car door open, drag Zimmerman out of it, and dragged him down the sidewalk?
"Evidence" my ass.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)arcane1
(38,613 posts)That is not in dispute.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)arcane1
(38,613 posts)Logic Fail!
Fact Fail!
Father
arcane1
(38,613 posts)Raine
(30,541 posts)when he was still in his car"? Please link to it ... I'm sure Zimmerman himself said he was FOLLOWING Martin.
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)TM approached Z while Z was in his truck. Then TM stopped approaching and ran away. Then Z got out of his truck and began to follow TM.
csziggy
(34,138 posts)Here is a map of the subdivision:
Trayvon cut through between two of the town houses at the NW corner (upper right) George was driving down that road (George lived at the SW corner) and saw Trayvon cutting through. George drove on up to the clubhouse across from the north gate into the sibdivision. He sat there, talking to the Sanford PD operator as Trayvon continued up the road, passed him, then took shelter under the roof over the mailboxes next to the clubhouse. From where Trayvon would have emerged onto the road at the cut through to the mailboxes is roughly 400 feet and at a normal walking pace would have taken 90 seconds to travel. At 1 minute and 16 seconds into George's call, George says "he's coming to check me out."
Trayvon was just walking past George who was sitting in his truck all that time. Then he took shelter from the rain and watched George continue to sit there, telling Rachel Jeantel about the creepy ass cracker who was watching him. Then Trayvon started walking on down the road and George followed in his truck so Trayvon ran. He was still headed towards his father's fiance's townhouse and taking the most direct route home.
After the operator told him not to follow I don't think George was pursuing Trayvon on foot - I think he drove towards the back gate to cut off that escape route. I think he ended up frightening Trayvon away from his safe haven - Trayvon could have seen George's truck cat the end of the block,the end of the sidewalk Trayvon was walking down. I think Trayvon doubled back towards the T and I think George saw Trayvon turning back and drove back to intercept him.
Rachel Jeantel testified that Trayvon said he was almost home then that the creepy guy was back. I think he said that when he saw George's truck at the end of the block.
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)0:49 Dispatcher: OK. Its just its 1 1 1 1 Retreat View? Or 111?
0:53 Zimmerman: Thats the, thats the clubhouse (unintelligible)
0:55 Dispatcher: Thats the clubhouse.
0:56 Zimmerman: (unintelligible)
0:57 Dispatcher: Do you know what the hes near the clubhouse right now?
0:58 Zimmerman: Yeah. Now hes comin towards me.
1:00 Dispatcher: OK.
1:01 (sound of windshield wipers, gear selector)
1:03 Zimmerman: Hes got his hand in his waistband.
1:05 (sound of a ding)
1:06 (sound of window rolling up?)
Zimmerman: And hes a black male.
1:09 (sound of gear selector)
1:10 Dispatcher: OK. How old would you say he
1:11 Zimmerman: Hes got
1:12 Dispatcher: looks?
1:13 Zimmerman: a button on his shirt. Late teens.
1:14 Dispatcher: Late teens. OK.
1:16 Zimmerman: Um hum.
1:16 (sound of windshield wipers)
1:17 Zimmerman: Sumpins wrong with him.
1:19 (sound like a thump noise)
1:21 Zimmerman: Yup. Hes comin to check me out. Hes got sumpin in his hands. I dont know what his deal is.
1:27 Dispatcher: OK, just let me know
1:28 Zimmerman: Please get an officer
csziggy
(34,138 posts)My times are slightly off the ones on the transcript you're working from by about five seconds but it is still close.
Martin's path was the shortest route to get back to where he was staying. If he took a shortcut between townhouses to get off the main road, then walked to the mail boxes next to the club house he would have passed Zimmerman just as Zimmerman told the operator "He's coming to check me out." at 19:10:50. Martin told his friend that he was taking shelter - probably under the mailbox structure - then talked to her about the "creepy ass cracker" watching him. He told her he was going to run and their call dropped before 19:12. Zimmerman said "He's running" at 19:11:40.
If we assume that Zimmerman was telling the dispatcher the truth as things happened up to that point, the timing works.
From the point Zimmerman could have seen Martin taking a shortcut between the townhouses to the stop sign in front of the club house is about 350' and another 75 to the mailboxes at an average walking speed of 4.4 feet per second (3 mph) it would have taken Martin about 80 seconds to travel to where Zimmerman says he stopped to make the call - in front of the club house. At 1 minute and 16-21 seconds after the beginning of Zimmerman's call, "he'd coming to check me out."
Martin was not "approaching Zimmerman" except that he had to pass Zimmerman's vehicle along his direct route home.
Martin was not hurrying. He'd taken over a half hour to walk the mile to the 7-11. He was talking to his friend, as she said "Just goofing." He may have slowed down, concerned about the truck he saw pass him that was now sitting in front of the club house. By the time Martin took shelter from the rain for a bit, he was beginning to be really worried about the intentions of the guy in that truck, so he ran (~2:06 or ~40 seconds after he passed Zimmerman).
Maybe before Martin ran Zimmerman cruised around the corner to keep an eye on the "suspicious character" and that triggered Martin's fear. If Zimmerman had done that, he would have been cutting Martin off from he safe haven - the townhouse where he was staying.
The real point is that Martin really didn't have time according the timeline of Zimmerman's call to Sanford PD to go out of his way to check out Zimmerman. He pretty much moved at a normal walking pace in order to arrive at the point where Zimmerman describes in his call when Zimmerman says he does. That part of their interaction is pretty set by Zimmerman's statements to the dispatcher and the times that the dispatcher entered information on his log.
Martin didn't even hang around under the mailbox shelter for long - it would have taken maybe 15 seconds for him to walk from Zimmerman's truck to the shelter, leaving less than 30 seconds for him to be under the shelter.
This is all from Zimmerman's call, accepting his words as truth. It also jibes with Rachel Jeantel's statements of what Martin told her over the phone.
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)He got out of the truck to follow TM. He was a dumbshit to do that. He went against Neighborhood Watch protocol and against what is taught in CCW classes. I have a Texas Concealed Handgun License so I know what is taught in the classes. We are supposed to avoid confrontations if reasonably possible. Z was overdoing it when he got out of his truck to follow TM and thereby set the stage for a disaster.
avebury
(10,952 posts)vehicle when the confrontation broke out between the two. Had Zimmerman announced that he was with Neighborhood Watch you had better belief that his legal team would have been screaming that to the rafters.
I think that the phone records for the numerous calls Zimmerman made to the police provide more then ample evidence that he had a tendency to profile the type of individuals that he deemed suspicious. Martin had every right to be there that night. Much has been made that Martin was weaving around. I got to admit, that if I were there that night and it started raining I would have been trying to find a shortcut to get to my destination. It would be absurd to think that anybody (without rain gear or an umbrella) would take the long way in the rain (and remember that Martin might not have been as familiar with the area as Zimmerman).
I totally believe that if the incident had not happened that night with Martin, it would have only been a matter of time before Zimmerman got into a confrontation with someone else in a similar type of circumstance. Zimmerman was an accident waiting to happen.
He is not someone that I would want to be a member of the Neighborhood Watch where I live.
Hugabear
(10,340 posts)Is it a crime for a young black man to be walking around after dark?
Vattel
(9,289 posts)CatWoman
(79,302 posts)when facts fly straight over your head?
Hugabear
(10,340 posts)It's a free country, Trayvon could have been taking his time walking around the whole neighborhood and it shouldn't have made a difference.
Voice for Peace
(13,141 posts)while talking on the phone to his friend about
some weird guy in a car who is watching him.
meanwhile zimmerman is also on the phone,
telling them there is a black guy who is
acting weird and watching him.
I think this may be a classic example
of projection on Z's part.
treestar
(82,383 posts)But he'd already made up his mind, talking about effing punks and so forth.
hlthe2b
(102,396 posts)Last edited Sat Jun 29, 2013, 05:24 PM - Edit history (1)
I hate what is rapidly becoming the "norm" in this country--that we have no right to expect to walk down our street (or heaven forbid, knock on a stranger's door for help) without being shot to death.
Pretty soon, fear over being shot by the "bad" guys--criminals-- is going to be widely and understandably overtaken by fear of being shot by a "responsible" gun owner....
KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)hlthe2b
(102,396 posts)sigh.... How barbaric the world must (rightfully) view us.
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)I have a CCW, and by everything I have been taught, that was a bad shoot.
KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)More guns!!!!1!1!1!11
(Maybe not the answer)
Lithos
(26,404 posts)You have to show them who's boss... Teach them a lesson, drive the point home. Kick their butt.
(Yes, it's sarcasm on my part)
Cirque du So-What
(25,989 posts)that Trayvon Martin was a 'punk' (or a n-word, depending upon how his 911 call is interpreted). Add to that the fact that he had a loaded weapon secreted upon his person, coupled with the assumption that he was a badass and filled with delusions of imaginary power and authority, it's hard for me to imagine that he approached Trayvon in a respectful manner.
Lithos
(26,404 posts)Sorry if I misfired my sarcasm
I totally agree that Zimmerman had already had assumed Trayvon guilty of walking while black/young and that someone it was up to Zimmerman to make things right, and right then. Zimmerman had an over-inflated sense of self as cop/enforcer - well documented as it was the reason he failed his admission to police academy; I was just taking things over the top.
L0-
Cirque du So-What
(25,989 posts)There are a lot of things about this case that drive me over-the-top as well, although mine translates into anger as well as sarcasm.
arcane1
(38,613 posts)I don't think he sought out to kill him, but he definitely wanted to detain Martin until police arrived. His gun made him feel invincible.
patricia92243
(12,604 posts)there is a grain of truth in it.
csziggy
(34,138 posts)She said that Martin asked Zimmerman "Why are you following me?" and that Zimmerman responded by "What are you doing here?"
Zimmerman in at least one of his stories said Martin said "What is your problem?" and Zimmerman said he didn't have a problem.
In both cases, Zimmerman didn't provide a proper response to defuse the situation.
If Zimmerman really wanted to reduce crime in his neighborhood, when Martin passed him as Zimmerman was talking to the Sanford PD, he would have stuck his head out his car window and greeted Martin. If Martin had been "up to no good" that should have been enough to scare him off.
One of the functions of neighborhood watch is to let people know that there are eyes keeping watch on the neighborhood. It is definitely not following and shooting people walking through the neighborhood!
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)chelsea0011
(10,115 posts)to "always get away with it". (in quotes because Zimmerman has said that). Problem is the "it" was just a walk.
KittyWampus
(55,894 posts)arcane1
(38,613 posts)MrScorpio
(73,631 posts)I seriously doubt that he has either the requisite intelligence or tact to make such an approach other than as aggressive and confrontational.
He had a belief in his own phony-baloney authority and liked to push people around.
In short, he was an asshole with a gun.
Cirque du So-What
(25,989 posts)'Asshole with a gun' sums it up nicely.
DesertFlower
(11,649 posts)all american girl
(1,788 posts)On previous non-emergency 911 calls, he would state that he didn't want to confront the people he was calling on. What changed this time that he felt the need to get out of his vehicle and follow this kid? Did he have someone with him and he was trying to act like a big man? Did he have a bad day and decided that he had just had enough? Did his MMA classes make him feel more powerful and in control? I just don't get the change of behavior.
arcane1
(38,613 posts)Or maybe he got tired of the fact that "They always get away" and wanted to make sure this one didn't.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)ecstatic
(32,734 posts)but imho, he sounds drunk on the 911 tape.
1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)Hoyt
(54,770 posts)was bothering him.
pipi_k
(21,020 posts)was being poisoned.
Testosterone and adrenaline often don't mix very well.
Tom Ripley
(4,945 posts)GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)TM had approached Z while Z was in the truck, then TM turned and ran away from Z while Z was in the truck. At that point Z got out of the truck. Getting out of his vehicle was completely against NW protocol. If a suspicious person sees you, give them a friendly wave. If they are up to no good, then they will know that they have been seen and can be identified. Almost always they will quit what they are doing. If they are not up to anything, then they will not be alarmed by a friendly person waving.
Always avoid a possible confrontation.
Z was totally wrong to get out of his truck.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)He denies that. If you think you know that his denial is a lie, then you must have psychic powers.
Voice for Peace
(13,141 posts)tape of that interview is worth listening to.. it's with the esquire article
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10023130108
Vattel
(9,289 posts)What is in dispute is whether Zimmerman was following Martin after the dispatcher suggested that he not do that.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Hugabear
(10,340 posts)Did Trayvon pull him out?
What about the part where Trayvon tells his friend about some creepy guy following him?
bravenak
(34,648 posts)Not denies, admits. There is a transcript.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)CatWoman
(79,302 posts)JI7
(89,276 posts)Response to JI7 (Reply #55)
Post removed
GreenStormCloud
(12,072 posts)2:08 Dispatcher: Hes running? Which way is he running?
2:10 (door opens, sound of door alarm)
2:10 Zimmerman: Ah, down towards the, ah, other entrance of the neighborhood.
2:14 (door closes)
2:14 Dispatcher: OK. Which entrance is that that hes heading towards?
2:17 Zimmerman; The back entrance. Fucking punks.
2:20 (wind noise)
2:23 Dispatcher: Are you following him?
2:25 Zimmerman: Yeah.
2:26 Dispatcher: OK, we don't need you to do that.
markpkessinger
(8,409 posts)LittleBlue
(10,362 posts)Do you see much intelligence there? I don't. He's an idiot on top of having some sort of mental disorder. No normal person tries to take it on himself to police the community.
Nye Bevan
(25,406 posts)But everything is wrong with the concept of wannabe cops strutting about with guns.
naaman fletcher
(7,362 posts)I can't believe I just read that on DU.
WhataKnight
(40 posts)This is what hurts my heart. Just ask the young man what he was up to and identify yourself as a neighborhood watch person and this all could have been avoided.
Nye Bevan
(25,406 posts)and the fight ensued.
There will always be people who argue and fight. But if people were not allowed to carry guns on the street, deaths would be much less likely to result from such incidents.
HockeyMom
(14,337 posts)Are you lost? Are you looking for a certain address? I have done this myself in my development. Did Zimmerman say anything like this, or just assume that a strange person meant a criminal, and go on the offensive, thereby putting the other person (Trayvon) also on the offensive?
nyquil_man
(1,443 posts)Last edited Sun Jun 30, 2013, 06:06 PM - Edit history (2)
After all, Zimmerman says on the 911 call that Martin is approaching his truck. He later tells the detectives that Martin was about a car length away from him.
His first reason for not talking to Martin at that point was that it was raining and he (Zimmerman) was talking on the phone. His second was that he was afraid to do so.
Yet, about a minute later, he's out of the truck and retracing Martin's steps, following a path which he says was so dark that he tried to turn on his flashlight in order to walk back.
rustydog
(9,186 posts)He already ignored the 911 instructions not to follow Trayvon. Why in hell this armed gutless piece of shit decided to confront a much smaller, much younger completely innocent pedestrian is anyone's guess, but nutless Zimmerman does know why.
His problem is Florida's "stand your ground" law included Trayvon's right to defend himself against an armed stalker and he did. The instigator picked a fight with an unarmed teenager and had his ass handed to him. In traditional armed coward fashion, Zimmerman shot and murdered an unarmed male after starting the confrontation.
hunter
(38,334 posts)When assholes have guns, bad things happen.
Response to JaneyVee (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed