General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsBitter Pill: Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us
I am cross-posting this because of the treasure trove of information in this week's Time magazine article on health care costs. Be warned that if you have high blood pressure, you need to make sure you have taken your medication prior to reading this.
I strongly encourage every DUer to take the time to read this very informative article on why our health care costs so much more than it should. It will open your eyes and infuriate you. The problems go much, much deeper than the greedy insurance companies.
The article goes into case studies of what people are billed, how much the treatments/ care actually cost, and the obscene profits being raked in by CEOs and top managers at hospitals (including "non-profits" , medical device companies, and drug companies.
Highlights include:
- Uninsured patient billed $7,997.54 for a stress test using a radioactive dye for which Medicare will pay $554
- Patient billed $49,237 for a Medtronic stimulator, which cost the hospital no more than $19,000
- Medtronics, which manufactures the device has a 75.1% gross profit margin on its devices.
- Patient is billed $13,702 per dose of Rituxan, a cancer drug, for which the hospital paid less than $4,000.
- Rituxan costs about $300 per dose to make, test, package and ship
- Average profit margin for "non-profit" hospitals is 11.7%, even when including hospitals operating at a loss
- Uninsured patient billed $157.61 for a CBC for which Medicare pays $11.02
- 71% more CT scans per capita are performed in the US than in Germany due to profit motives
Excerpt from the article:
Indeed, the only player in the system that seems to have to balance countervailing interests the way market players in a real market usually do is Medicare. It has to answer to Congress and the taxpayers for wasting money, and it has to answer to portions of the same groups for trying to hold on to money it shouldnt. Hospitals, drug companies and other suppliers, even the insurance companies, dont have those worries.
Moreover, the only players in the private sector who seem to operate efficiently are the private contractors working dare I say it? under the governments supervision. Theyre the Medicare claims processors that handle claims like Alan A.s for 84¢ each. With these and all other Medicare costs added together, Medicares total management, administrative and processing expenses are about $3.8 billion for processing more than a billion claims a year worth $550 billion. Thats an overall administrative and management cost of about two-thirds of 1% of the amount of the claims, or less than $3.80 per claim. According to its latest SEC filing, Aetna spent $6.9 billion on operating expenses (including claims processing, accounting, sales and executive management) in 2012. Thats about $30 for each of the 229 million claims Aetna processed, and it amounts to about 29% of the $23.7 billion Aetna pays out in claims.
The real issue isnt whether we have a single payer or multiple payers. Its whether whoever pays has a fair chance in a fair market. Congress has given Medicare that power when it comes to dealing with hospitals and doctors, and we have seen how that works to drive down the prices Medicare pays, just as weve seen what happens when Congress handcuffs Medicare when it comes to evaluating and buying drugs, medical devices and equipment. Stripping away what is now the sellers overwhelming leverage in dealing with Medicare in those areas and with private payers in all aspects of the market would inject fairness into the market. We dont have to scrap our system and arent likely to. But we can reduce the $750 billion that we overspend on health care in the U.S. in part by acknowledging what other countries have: because the health care market deals in a life-or-death product, it cannot be left to its own devices.
Read more: http://healthland.time.com/2013/02/20/bitter-pill-why-medical-bills-are-killing-us/#ixzz2LdnarWT9