Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Stinky The Clown

(67,831 posts)
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:02 PM Apr 22

SEE THE OP EDIT . . Your best guess. Are the anti Jewish protester organizers paid in rubles or rials?

Last edited Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:18 PM - Edit history (1)

These campus "protests" clearly have central command and control.

***************************
OP above

Edit below

From the OP: "protester organizers"

Those words do NOT refer to the people you see on Twitter, TicToc, the Evening Nooz, or cable nooz. They refer to whoever is sprinkling the gasoline and lighting the matches to stir up the people you see. The OPERATIVES. Payment refers to the operatives being paid. It takes money to stir up this shit.

The central question in the OP is who is paying for this, Iran? Russia?, Maybe China.

This is NOT ABOUT THE PROTESTERS YOU CAN SEE.

Now reread what you posted. Reading comprehension may well have changed what/how you replied.

105 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
SEE THE OP EDIT . . Your best guess. Are the anti Jewish protester organizers paid in rubles or rials? (Original Post) Stinky The Clown Apr 22 OP
bitcoin.... getagrip_already Apr 22 #1
Hamas has one hell of a propaganda machine. nt LexVegas Apr 22 #2
Exactly.. agingdem Apr 22 #13
Because Oct 7 exists in a bubble. intheflow Apr 22 #50
I highly recommend the following video wnylib Apr 22 #57
Malcolm Nance is terrific, I've learned so much from him! betsuni Apr 22 #60
You will learn a LOT from him about the history of wnylib Apr 22 #65
Thanks for posting! whathehell Apr 23 #103
Part one is at the same thread, below part two. wnylib Apr 23 #104
Okay, thanks. whathehell Apr 23 #105
They've convinced many that Israel has to fight on Hamas' terms. Coventina Apr 22 #14
It's pretty risky to be paid to protest if you end up in jail. jimfields33 Apr 22 #3
I have no doubt the overwhelming majority sarisataka Apr 22 #4
I'm sure of that as well Stinky The Clown Apr 22 #6
If one were to follow the money, sarisataka Apr 22 #9
Agreed Stinky The Clown Apr 22 #12
When I was young, H2O Man Apr 22 #18
Not just MLK Jr. Ms. Toad Apr 22 #38
Lots of people! H2O Man Apr 22 #39
Yup. Ms. Toad Apr 22 #64
But of course the Soviets were such good, aboveboard guys wnylib Apr 22 #46
+1 betsuni Apr 22 #63
The USSR H2O Man Apr 22 #69
Which ones are paid? maxsolomon Apr 22 #21
This message was self-deleted by its author Mosby Apr 22 #66
They are doing it out of their love for hating Jews. No inducement needed. tritsofme Apr 22 #5
I'm asking about the high level leadership, not the people you see on cable nooz. Stinky The Clown Apr 22 #8
The young do not have a hatred for Jews womanofthehills Apr 22 #23
Wrong.. The Protesters Raging in the Streets.. Attacking, at times Violently, and Harassing Jewish Students Cha Apr 22 #25
Yes, those vile protesters certainly do discern wnylib Apr 22 #48
TY.. It's so obvious and there's No Excuse Cha Apr 22 #49
Absolutely agree. wnylib Apr 22 #52
And yet dead Yemenis, Sudanese, Congolese etc children not so much...strange that EX500rider Apr 22 #33
Yelling "Go back to Poland" (Auswitz) is just random, then? n/t Coventina Apr 22 #40
That didn't happen on campus. intheflow Apr 23 #89
President Biden said that Columbia was dangerous for Jewish students: Coventina Apr 23 #91
President Biden is not on campus. intheflow Apr 23 #92
Godwin's Law Coventina Apr 23 #93
And so... what? yardwork Apr 22 #43
The vast majority of protesters are protesting Netanyahu and the government of Israel Sky Jewels Apr 22 #7
There is plenty of evidence hate for Jews is rampant Coventina Apr 22 #10
you're dead fucking wrong. Stinky The Clown Apr 22 #11
If the shoe was on the other foot. TheRealNorth Apr 22 #19
For real. n/t Coventina Apr 22 #41
WRONG. Cha Apr 22 #26
Have you read the signs and banners? nocoincidences Apr 22 #28
"BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY" is a particularly chilling one IMO EX500rider Apr 22 #34
Really.. TY! Cha Apr 22 #36
Pretend otherwise? yardwork Apr 22 #44
The accusation of genocide by Israel is generated and promoted wnylib Apr 22 #51
Like when I protested against Trump, I got paid by George Soros? progressoid Apr 22 #15
Especially anti-Semitic protesters who direct vile wnylib Apr 22 #54
I don't think they need to be paid. EllieBC Apr 22 #16
Does that include the Jews that are protesting the slaughter in Gaza? Ping Tung Apr 23 #98
Are they harassing jewish students? EllieBC Apr 23 #99
Why would Jews harass other Jews? Ping Tung Apr 23 #100
Lol Polybius Apr 22 #17
And, some Obvious things are. Cha Apr 22 #37
Rials probably. Elessar Zappa Apr 22 #20
If the goal is to maintain/increase division, it's working brilliantly. Torchlight Apr 22 #22
Fascinating jimfields33 Apr 22 #24
I think most do it because they see it as trendy or they hate Jews. BannonsLiver Apr 22 #27
They're paid in Hummus for Hamas. nt JustABozoOnThisBus Apr 22 #29
Oh, the bitterness it takes to make crap up. Jirel Apr 22 #30
Jews will not replace us/Go back to Poland EllieBC Apr 22 #32
"Bitterness" is telling Jews that they belong in Auschwitz. yardwork Apr 22 #45
You're absolutely right that I do not share wnylib Apr 22 #61
Fukc these Anit Semitic Assholes Screaming "Never forget the 7th of October. That will happen not one more time,.. Cha Apr 22 #82
Don't forget yuan. Irish_Dem Apr 22 #31
I have Rebl2 Apr 22 #35
I read that Columbia closes its campus to non-student protesters AloeVera Apr 22 #70
The FBI gets paid in dollars. Duncan Grant Apr 22 #42
Lol BannonsLiver Apr 22 #56
Gee, Let's Beat Up Each Other Some More Over the Gaza War DJ Synikus Makisimus Apr 22 #47
Can you at least condemn the attacks on American Jews? Coventina Apr 22 #53
Better get comfortable sarisataka Apr 22 #55
Of course. DJ Synikus Makisimus Apr 22 #59
This thread is about protests on American campuses, where Jewish students are being Coventina Apr 22 #62
+100,000 wnylib Apr 22 #71
It appears to me that when a beleagured group receives sympathies, Torchlight Apr 22 #75
That's what they used to say about the Vietnam protests. viva la Apr 22 #58
Different time, different issues. wnylib Apr 22 #73
Are the russians paying Ilhan Omars daughter? Mosby Apr 22 #67
I remember similar claims about protesters against the Vietnam War DBoon Apr 22 #68
It is my suspicion that a lot of the protestors just can't tolerate the thought of what is happening to real people in Chainfire Apr 22 #72
Then why aren't they protesting what is happening to 24 MILLION children in Sudan? Coventina Apr 22 #74
Whataboutism defined. Chainfire Apr 22 #76
It's a reasonable question why they care so much about one people suffering but not a peep about worse tragedies EX500rider Apr 22 #85
Your post said they were protesting what is happening to "real people" in Gaza. Coventina Apr 23 #87
Post removed Post removed Apr 23 #88
I'm saying that these protestors are motivated by antisemitism and not concern for people. n/t Coventina Apr 23 #90
Well, you would just have to ask them, wouldn't you? Chainfire Apr 23 #94
They have already told everyone who they are. I believe them. Coventina Apr 23 #95
All of them, right? Chainfire Apr 23 #96
I haven't heard any disavowel of the hate being leveled at Jews worldwide generally or Coventina Apr 23 #97
couldn't it also be American republicans? ecstatic Apr 22 #77
Stop Ontheboundry Apr 22 #78
He asked who is paying for the demonstrations. ecstatic Apr 22 #79
This was s fairly clear Ontheboundry Apr 22 #80
Are you kidding? Their interference and shit stirring is well documented. ecstatic Apr 22 #81
In this situation? Ontheboundry Apr 22 #84
Both...Iran has more influence and more opportunity for influence. LeftInTX Apr 22 #83
K&R betsuni Apr 23 #86
Vietnam Nam era enid602 Apr 23 #101
Paid in Trump Bucks? keithbvadu2 Apr 23 #102

agingdem

(7,865 posts)
13. Exactly..
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:30 PM
Apr 22

Hamas has done a masterful job of corralling Jewish hatred ...Hamas invades Israel, slaughters Israeli Jews and somehow Hamas and the Palestinians are the real victims...right!..

the way I see it..antisemites are fucking pissed because Israelis refuse to play the victim...

intheflow

(28,506 posts)
50. Because Oct 7 exists in a bubble.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:56 PM
Apr 22

Nothing happened before it, Hamas just woke up on Oct 7 and thought, “Today’s a good day to attack Israel.” Plenty of war crimes and blame to go around on both sides, dating back decades, centuries, millennia. October 7 happened because the State of Israel had been hostile towards Palestinians, stealing land and denying water rights. It is not antisemitic, supporting terrorism or condoning Hamas to place October 7 in historical context and understand that Netanyahu’s disproportionate response has exactly proven the point Hamas was trying to make: Israel’s leadership treats Palestinians much like the Germans treated Jews in the decades leading up to WWII.

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
65. You will learn a LOT from him about the history of
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:30 PM
Apr 22

the Israel/Palestine issues in that video. The background explains what is happening there today.

Every poster on DU would benefit from seeing that video.

whathehell

(29,096 posts)
103. Thanks for posting!
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 07:36 PM
Apr 23

Mr. Whathehell and I started to listen last night, then realized we were listening to p
Part 2 before hearing Part 1..Can you repost part 1 too?..Thanks again.

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
14. They've convinced many that Israel has to fight on Hamas' terms.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:33 PM
Apr 22

My guess is a lot of it is coming from Putin's troll farms.

If Biden is taken down by the left, he wins so much. Ukraine will be just the beginning of what Trump gives him.

Stinky The Clown

(67,831 posts)
6. I'm sure of that as well
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:14 PM
Apr 22

The OP is about the top of the pyramid. They are not student protesters. They are not working gratis. They are paid professional operatives. The question is who is paying them.

My guess is the source money is Russian, then through Iran, then through some unnamed Hamas-linked operatives.

sarisataka

(18,821 posts)
9. If one were to follow the money,
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:20 PM
Apr 22

I think all roads lead to Moscow. I also think Putin views it as one of his best investments. Every ruble is returned threefold with instability in the Middle East, distraction from Ukraine and fractures in US politics.

H2O Man

(73,637 posts)
18. When I was young,
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 03:15 PM
Apr 22

the FBI "knew" that both the anti-war and civil rights movement were funded and controlled by the Soviet Union. Both LBJ and Nixon pressured the agency to find those links. This included spying on Martin Luther King, Jr.

Ms. Toad

(34,117 posts)
38. Not just MLK Jr.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:09 PM
Apr 22

Tons of others, including my father, me, and an organization in which we both served in leadership roles.

Ms. Toad

(34,117 posts)
64. Yup.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:29 PM
Apr 22

I only know about my dad and me because the organization requested the files from the FBI and we were in them. There were a whole lot of people in there, including a bunch who were long-dead at the time they were doing their spying, as well as random people caught in the net.

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
46. But of course the Soviets were such good, aboveboard guys
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:42 PM
Apr 22

that they never did engage in any infiltrations or spy ops against the US throughout the Cold War. Bad US, good Soviets, then. Bad US, good Russians, Iranians, and Hamas today.

Wasn't that paranoid J. Edgar Hoover's FBI? His hatred of liberals, including the Kennedys was well known even then.

H2O Man

(73,637 posts)
69. The USSR
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 07:29 PM
Apr 22

spied on the US mlitary. If anyone here can document their having anything to do with the anti-war or civil rights movement, I would request they post it ..... because the FBI couldn't find anything. The closest they came was studying the Beatles' "Back in the USSR."

maxsolomon

(33,432 posts)
21. Which ones are paid?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 03:54 PM
Apr 22

Jewish Voices for Peace? The Muslim protestors in every crowd?

Do you have anything that backs up your assertions?

Response to maxsolomon (Reply #21)

womanofthehills

(8,781 posts)
23. The young do not have a hatred for Jews
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 04:18 PM
Apr 22

They are horrified by seeing dead and limbless children & babies on their phones everyday.

Almost all of my Jewish girlfriends married & had kids by non Jewish men Their young adult kids now have last names like Garcia, Romero, Tumer etc. American kids are way less into race than our generations. If I asked my grandkids if they knew any Jewish kids, they would not even really know what I was talking about - they are all mixed races.

Cha

(297,799 posts)
25. Wrong.. The Protesters Raging in the Streets.. Attacking, at times Violently, and Harassing Jewish Students
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 04:29 PM
Apr 22

and Jewish Professors, Smearing Jewish Businesses, are Ugly Antisemitics.

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
48. Yes, those vile protesters certainly do discern
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:46 PM
Apr 22

between Jewish and non Jewish and aim their hatred directly at Jews.

intheflow

(28,506 posts)
89. That didn't happen on campus.
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 11:26 AM
Apr 23

It was agitators right off campus who yelled that and other antisemitic things. There is little indication that any Columbia student has been participating and engaging in antisemitism.

intheflow

(28,506 posts)
92. President Biden is not on campus.
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 12:54 PM
Apr 23

Like both of us, he only hears what's being reported by various people and news organizations. Also, I don't walk in lockstep with everything Biden does because that's the kind of thing Nazi's do. It is not my patriotic duty to blindly believe everything that comes out of the president's mouth, even a president I admire, respect, and voted for.

yardwork

(61,715 posts)
43. And so... what?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:38 PM
Apr 22

People named Garcia don't care about antisemitism? I know for a fact that you are wrong.

Sky Jewels

(7,171 posts)
7. The vast majority of protesters are protesting Netanyahu and the government of Israel
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:16 PM
Apr 22

and its genocidal destruction of Gaza, not "Jews." Those are two very different things.

But you know that ... and choose to pretend otherwise.

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
10. There is plenty of evidence hate for Jews is rampant
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:21 PM
Apr 22

“While every American has the right to peaceful protest, calls for violence and physical intimidation targeting Jewish students and the Jewish community are blatantly Antisemitic, unconscionable, and dangerous — they have absolutely no place on any college campus, or anywhere in the United States of America,” White House deputy press secretary Andrew Bates said in a statement, after video emerged on social media over the weekend that appeared to show pro-Palestinian activists telling Jewish students, “The 7th of October is going to be every day for you,” in reference to the deadly Hamas-led attack on Israel last fall.

“Echoing the rhetoric of terrorist organizations, especially in the wake of the worst massacre committed against the Jewish people since the Holocaust, is despicable. We condemn these statements in the strongest terms,” Bates added.

https://www.politico.com/news/2024/04/21/chaos-columbia-jewish-moskowitz-santos-white-house-00153545

Stinky The Clown

(67,831 posts)
11. you're dead fucking wrong.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:21 PM
Apr 22

but since you ask, while what you say may be true, it is also likely true that some of it is pure antisemitism..

In either case, DO NOT ascribe motive to my post because you have no fucking clue.

nocoincidences

(2,231 posts)
28. Have you read the signs and banners?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 04:46 PM
Apr 22

When people are telling you who they are, believe them.

Go back to Poland? Does that sound like they don't like Bibi?

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
51. The accusation of genocide by Israel is generated and promoted
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:58 PM
Apr 22

by the pro Hamas organizers mentioned in the OP.

It is a war, declared by Hamas on Israel. Israel is fighting to destroy Hamas. People who genuinely care about the Gaza civilians are misdirecting their anger, thanks to Hamas propaganda.

There is an excellent video at the Liberal YouTubers Forum by Malcolm Nance on Israel/Palestine that I highly recommend.


https://www.democraticunderground.com/132220269

progressoid

(50,000 posts)
15. Like when I protested against Trump, I got paid by George Soros?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 01:59 PM
Apr 22

It is possible for people to protest without the help of an oligarch.

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
54. Especially anti-Semitic protesters who direct vile
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:10 PM
Apr 22

threats at Jewish students. They don't need "oligarchs" except as a smoke screen to validate their anti-Semitism.

EllieBC

(3,042 posts)
16. I don't think they need to be paid.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 02:54 PM
Apr 22

Jews will not replace us/Go back to Poland.

Same type of people. Jew hating trashbags.

If you mean farther up the food chain? I’d guess Rials are being paid out often.

Ping Tung

(739 posts)
98. Does that include the Jews that are protesting the slaughter in Gaza?
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 04:15 PM
Apr 23

Are the Dems who are calling for an end to providing arms to Israel anti-Semites? Bernie Sanders? Nancy Pelosi? Are they getting paid off?

When I was protesting the Vietnam slaughter I was called a Commie being paid off by (take your pick) the Kremlin, Chairman Mao, Che Guevara, Ho Chi Minh and other assorted Reds.

All the money must've gotten lost in the mail or I'd be rich according to Right Wing "Patriots" who wanted to lynch us.

EllieBC

(3,042 posts)
99. Are they harassing jewish students?
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 05:41 PM
Apr 23

Do keep up. We are speaking of the wave of antisemitism on campuses. The whole, “go back to Poland” thing which sounds eerily similar to, “Jews will not replace us.”

So yeah. Harassing Jewish students on US campuses makes you a piece of human trash.

Torchlight

(3,374 posts)
22. If the goal is to maintain/increase division, it's working brilliantly.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 03:59 PM
Apr 22

And I figure there are some pretty easy guesses who a) benefits from western divisions, and b) who has the means (the political reach as well as the financing) to see it enacted. Applying that seems to whittle down the number to a level low enough and manageable enough for even me to take a guess that today's rubles are tomorrow's trump nft's.

BannonsLiver

(16,508 posts)
27. I think most do it because they see it as trendy or they hate Jews.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 04:42 PM
Apr 22

Possibly both. Some probably have legitimate concerns, but I think most are doing it to be part of a cause that they view as trendy and for social media clout, which is a valuable commodity especially for that age group.

Jirel

(2,026 posts)
30. Oh, the bitterness it takes to make crap up.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 04:58 PM
Apr 22

They’re real. They’re unpaid. And it takes a very bitter, angry person to insist falsely that protestors with a view they don’t like are paid in some kind of conspiracy.

EllieBC

(3,042 posts)
32. Jews will not replace us/Go back to Poland
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:01 PM
Apr 22

At this point someone should set up a dating service for the far left and far right. They have their strong hatred of Jews in common.

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
61. You're absolutely right that I do not share
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:25 PM
Apr 22

the views of people who spew vitriolic hatred at American Jewish students, saying things like, "Go back to Poland (Auschwitz)," and, "By any means necessary."

My question is how so many people are so OK with obvious anti-Semitism that they try to gaslight the rest of us into not seeing or hearing what is being said and done by the protesters.

Reminds me of Father Coughlin, Charles Lindbergh, and Henry Ford in the 1930s.




Cha

(297,799 posts)
82. Fukc these Anit Semitic Assholes Screaming "Never forget the 7th of October. That will happen not one more time,..
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 10:51 PM
Apr 22


Protestors screamed this at two Jewish
@Columbia
students right outside campus gates tonight
.

AloeVera

(997 posts)
70. I read that Columbia closes its campus to non-student protesters
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 07:35 PM
Apr 22

The student protesters are a different breed from the agitators including a few anti-semitic swine that are barred from campus and protest on the street, but whose voices are amplified in the media unfortunately.

Some of them manage to sneak onto campus and agitate and spew, tarnishing the students.

It's a shame.

Duncan Grant

(8,296 posts)
42. The FBI gets paid in dollars.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:35 PM
Apr 22

Our gov’t has infiltrated protest movements in the past. Maybe the efforts to delegitimize pro-Palestinian protestors are an attempt to protect the status quo? It would make sense — and it’s just as plausible as the OP.

There were right-wing racists among BLM protestors, who broke windows and burned buildings, etc. — trying to discredit BLM. It’s not a leap to think similar players are at work now.

47. Gee, Let's Beat Up Each Other Some More Over the Gaza War
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 05:43 PM
Apr 22

Last edited Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:48 PM - Edit history (1)

We won’t know for months or years, or perhap will never know, if “outside agitators” have had any participation in the protests at Columbia University, WHICH I'D LIKE TO REMIND EVERYONE AT LEAST STARTED OUT AS A DIVESTMENT CAMPAIGN to get the University to sell the Israeli Government Bonds in it's portfolio (and presumably holdings in the Israeli War Industry and Surveillance sector), similar to the divestment campaigns against the South African government during the apartheid era.

Whether there were “Hamas Agents” or “Mossad Agents” or agents from the fucking Trilateral Commission and Illuminati flown in on U.N. black helicopters covered in tinfoil, the net effect has been to set folks at each others’ throats. I am reminded of the “anarchist agitator” who set fire to a Post Office during the police/protester standoff in Minneapolis after the George Floyd murder. That “anarchist” turned out to be a “Boogaloo Boy” who traded his dimestore aloha shirt for a black outfit, which “everyone knows” means you’re an anarchist (whatever that means, but it must be bad).

We are in the “fog of war” period both in the Palestinian/Israeli and in the Ukrainian/Russian conflicts. Much of the infomation coming out cannot be trusted because it’s really easy to play on people’s biases if you’re propaganda is of any “quality” (and I use that word hesitantly).

I’m more interested in looking at the effects both of the protests on the war or U.S. policy (negligable) and the effects on U.S. politics that has resulted (huge). MAGAGOP Congresscritters in the House are taking advantage to bash “elite” universities. That’s a win for the anti-intellectual far right. AIPAC has committed a vast sum to get rid of “progressive” politicians, apparently whether they have said “bad things about Israel” or not. That’s a win for the right and far-right. Youthful protesters who oppose war are being bashed, and some of them will be discouraged from participation in politics forever (including voting). That’s a win for the right and far-right. I sense a pattern here.

So I urge folks to step back and think about what we think we know, as opposed to what we’ve heard or read about what’s going on. Unless of course you’re acting as an agent for one of the combatants. In that case I'm sure you would label yourself as such (uh-huh).

NOTE: Just to be clear, I don't take sides in blood feuds, especially not those that have been ongoing for 2000-3000 years. There are no political actors in this war that I'd wish to be associated with - on either side. The leadership elite of both political entities see hostility toward the other as a major key to their keeping power. They sound like MAGA GOPs magnified exponentially. I see no resolution, none of the people with power interested in peace, and only more bloodshed now and in the future. Therefore there's no one to support. People suffer when their leaders make them war. I DO, however, support the extension of aid for food deliveries and reconstruction wherever needed.

59. Of course.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:15 PM
Apr 22

And attacks on Palestinian-Americans and Palestinian students studying abroad, and against Druze- and Samaritan- and Israeli-Arab-Bedoin Americans/students studying abroad. And any other victims of prejudicial bigoted attacks on the basis of skin color, religion or lack thereof, national origin, citizenship status, and so on. I must say I puzzle over the "at least."

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
62. This thread is about protests on American campuses, where Jewish students are being
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:26 PM
Apr 22

attacked, harassed, and intimidated.

Your post seemed to criticize getting involved in the issues at all.

I think when Americans are being attacked for what is going on in a foreign country is horrific.

I disagree with the protestors for many other things, but attacking people who have nothing to do with it is a display of bigotry that should be condemned in the strongest possible way (expulsion from the school, and if they are on a visa, expulsion from the country).

Torchlight

(3,374 posts)
75. It appears to me that when a beleagured group receives sympathies,
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 08:22 PM
Apr 22

that sympathy is often trivialized to a variation of the All Lives Matter routine. So yeah, seriously: "step back and think about what we think we know..."

wnylib

(21,662 posts)
73. Different time, different issues.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 08:13 PM
Apr 22

Although there were some outside agitators, from our own FBI COINTEL Program.

I have a hunch, though, that our adversaries abroad were not unhappy to see the polarization.

The problem with the current protests at places like Columbia is not that students are taking sides in a foreign conflict. The problem is in HOW they are doing it. They are attacking an ethnic/religious segment of the US population with bigoted, hate-filled slogans and threats. Their rhetoric defines them as anti-Semitic.

"Peace will come when they love their own children more than they hate Israel." - Golda Meir.







Mosby

(16,384 posts)
67. Are the russians paying Ilhan Omars daughter?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 06:35 PM
Apr 22

Of course not, she is protesting against Israel because she thinks they are guilty of something. A lot of the kids protesting at Columbia come from very wealthy families, they don't need anyone's money. Same with the kids from the gulf who attend college here.

DBoon

(22,403 posts)
68. I remember similar claims about protesters against the Vietnam War
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 07:09 PM
Apr 22

Accusing protestors opposed to the war of being foreign agents lent comfort to those perpetuating brutal atrocities against civilians. Napalm, toxic defoliants, fragmentation bombs of plastic projectiles that x-rays could not see, ...

Chainfire

(17,663 posts)
72. It is my suspicion that a lot of the protestors just can't tolerate the thought of what is happening to real people in
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 08:02 PM
Apr 22

Gaza and would like to see the killing stop. What happened in October was horrible, what is happening in Gaza is horrible squared. Israel is trying to kill their way to security and I don't give the policy much of a chance to succeed in the long run. Israel has spent a hell of a lot of good will in the last few months. There may come a day when they deeply regret how they have been prosecuting this "war." All of my life I have been a defender and supporter of the Israeli State and the people, but I can not excuse what they are doing today. There is just too damn many dead civilians in Gaza.

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
74. Then why aren't they protesting what is happening to 24 MILLION children in Sudan?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 08:20 PM
Apr 22

And that's just the CHILDREN, per the UN.

EX500rider

(10,881 posts)
85. It's a reasonable question why they care so much about one people suffering but not a peep about worse tragedies
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 11:17 PM
Apr 22

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
87. Your post said they were protesting what is happening to "real people" in Gaza.
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 12:30 AM
Apr 23

Are the Sudanese not real people?

Response to Coventina (Reply #87)

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
95. They have already told everyone who they are. I believe them.
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 03:28 PM
Apr 23

"Go back to Poland" (Auschwitz)

"By any means necessary"

"Oct 7th will be every day for you"

Chainfire

(17,663 posts)
96. All of them, right?
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 03:42 PM
Apr 23

And anyone who defends their right to protest? If the protestors are breaking the law, arrest the lawbreakers. It is that simple. In my opinion, protesting ain't nearly as bad as bombing relief providers, women, children, etc. Perhaps my moral code is off kilter.

People keep stating as fact, or back-handedly insinuating, that anyone who has any empathy for the Palestinians is anti-Semetic may find that the empathetic parties come to believe it themselves.

Coventina

(27,215 posts)
97. I haven't heard any disavowel of the hate being leveled at Jews worldwide generally or
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 03:52 PM
Apr 23

American Jews specifically.

Silence is consent and approval.

The death of non-combatants in any war is a terrible thing. And every war has them.
Hamas started this and could end it tomorrow by releasing their hostages and surrendering for their crimes.
They choose, intentionally, to put their own people in harm's way.
That is an actual war crime.

Empathy for any suffering is not hateful, but these protests are not empathetic in any way I can see.
They should be fundraising for relief causes, not screaming at Jews that they should be in death camps.

ecstatic

(32,747 posts)
77. couldn't it also be American republicans?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 10:25 PM
Apr 22

They are enjoying seeing us fracture. I'm steeling myself for what's ahead this fall.

Ontheboundry

(91 posts)
80. This was s fairly clear
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 10:45 PM
Apr 22

A student driven movement now. I mean faculty are involved. . How we gonna tie GOP to this. They are gonna let us burn this up without giving us any help

ecstatic

(32,747 posts)
81. Are you kidding? Their interference and shit stirring is well documented.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 10:49 PM
Apr 22

The goal is to further divide us by pretending to be from the left and organizing or instigating protests, etc. They've done this in the past as well.

Ontheboundry

(91 posts)
84. In this situation?
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 11:06 PM
Apr 22

They don't need to do anything . We are doing ng a fine job all by ourselves most of these protestors are not unknowns, and from local university groups.


LeftInTX

(25,607 posts)
83. Both...Iran has more influence and more opportunity for influence.
Mon Apr 22, 2024, 10:51 PM
Apr 22

Last edited Mon Apr 22, 2024, 11:38 PM - Edit history (2)

You would be surprised how tight-knit some ethnic groups can be. We have Palestinians in the US who are in touch with Palestinians overseas who are in touch with Hamas or Hezbollah just disgruntled Palestinians over there. We also have tons of Lebanese in the US.
All Iran has to do is provide support for organizing etc. It's not a stretch and it doesn't cost much money. Although Iranians don't speak Arabic, they manage to communicate effectively with Hezbollah and Hamas.

I'm thinking a Lebanon Hezbollah connection is quite common. Many years ago, a Palestinian college student who hung with our group was affiliated with the PLO.

That imam who was chanting "Death to America" over in Dearborn spent years studying in Iran. (He's born and raised in the US)

Iran definitely has more opportunity. Although we associate Russia with agitators, crisis actors etc, Iran does a pretty good job themselves. Khomeini spent decades at this himself creating drama. Vile man blamed the shah's father for his father's death in 1905. (Yep 1905) The shah's father did not become a shah until 20 years after Khomeini's father died. Additionally, the Iranian royalty switched families, so there was no connection. The future shah was in the Iran Cossacks up in the Caucacus and Khomeini grew up in a different part of the country. Khomeini just made up victim bullshit to justify his religious coup.

keithbvadu2

(36,962 posts)
102. Paid in Trump Bucks?
Tue Apr 23, 2024, 07:28 PM
Apr 23
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100217951553

MAGAs believed $99 "Trump Bucks" could be cashed for $10K, "Now I realize, well, that was stupid"

Trump Supporters Scammed By Novelty Items—‘Trump Bucks’—Advertised As Legal Tender
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»SEE THE OP EDIT . . Your ...