General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMontana newspaper disciplines copy editor for adding ‘allegedly’ to AP’s 'Obama was born in Hawaii’'
http://jimromenesko.com/2012/11/20/montana-newspaper-disciplines-copy-editor-for-obama-allegedly-born-in-hawaii-line/The Helena (MT) Independent Record has disciplined a copy editor for changing a line in an Associated Press story to read, Obama was allegedly born in Hawaii. A retired AP staffer who worked 28 years in the Helena bureau was one of the readers who complained about the addition of allegedly. He tells the paper: That right-wing notion (that the president isn't a U.S. citizen) has been so thoroughly discredited that only Donald Trump and assorted other loonies still cling to it. Neither the AP nor I hope The Independent Record belongs in their company.
An editors note in the Lee Enterprises-owned paper says:
Panasonic
(2,921 posts)Birthers should have no jobs.
yellowcanine
(35,699 posts)No one is laughing.
democrattotheend
(11,605 posts)Irresponsible, but not necessarily malicious.
yellowcanine
(35,699 posts)I would definitely consider firing him. A copy editor who changes copy to make a joke is not someone you want working at a newspaper. At the least a serious printed mea culpa with his name attached is in order.
NYC Liberal
(20,136 posts)"It was just a joke! Lighten up!"
Brother Buzz
(36,440 posts)It was deliberate.
RebelOne
(30,947 posts)and I only corrected punctuation, spelling and grammatical errors and never anything to change the tone of the stories I read. This copy editor was definitely in the wrong.
Aristus
(66,380 posts)...of...I don't know! Somebody help me out here with a metaphor! Those guys are just insanely stupid!...
tblue37
(65,393 posts)Aristus
(66,380 posts)Thank you!
Cha
(297,275 posts)freshwest
(53,661 posts)ROBROX
(392 posts)This little paper has TWO copy editors!!! I guess it is time to hire a THIRD person to catch mistakes..
Jackpine Radical
(45,274 posts)They have 2 proofreaders because they have a lot of text that needs proofing. It's not like they need a fail-safe system here. These are news stories fer Chrissake, not SALT agreements.
The excuse doesn't meet the smell test.
kestrel91316
(51,666 posts)so it contained a deliberate, provable lie.
Cha
(297,275 posts)in there.
Thanks Newsjock..
Hekate
(90,708 posts)I read this as a good news story, myself. Here we have a birther trying to slyly slip the lie in -- he gets caught -- and his boss prints the retraction/public apology.
That's one for our side, right enough.
The fact that the boss called it "a poor attempt at humor and a poor decision, but was not intended to be printed in the paper" is just a way of saving face for the paper, not a bad thing. Take note of the last sentence: "Those responsible have been disciplined." I'd hate to be on the receiving end of that chewing-out, and disciplinary actions in the workplace cover a wide range of penalties.
I'd say we're winning.
ibegurpard
(16,685 posts)Hekate
(90,708 posts)... referring to the local Planned Parenthood as "an abortion clinic." This was some years ago, and one of their newscasters (a woman, Debby) just kept doing that. Once she had on a group of women who were protesters outside PP and otherwise anti-choice, and in the course of the interview said, "So you're really upset that little babies are being killed?" in this syrupy voice.
Every damned time she'd call PP an abortion clinic I'd phone the viewer comment line and leave a fairly polite message pointing out that abortions are only about 3% or 5% of what PP does, would list their other activities in detail, and so on. The only time I got really heated was that interview, and I demanded to know if Debby couldn't at least pretend to be objective in the name of good journalism.
And you know what? She stopped. And no one else has ever taken it up again.
So you keep on it. We're going to win, even if it's in small increments. The truth matters.
Hekate