Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Mkap

(223 posts)
Thu Nov 1, 2012, 06:41 PM Nov 2012

Why we need regulation

I've been a liberal since reading Upton Sinclairs "The Jungle" and John Stienback's "Grapes of Wrath" as a teenager

Those books tell the horror that was america before the age of regulation, when businesses grinded rat droppings into their meat grinder and business's hired thugs to destroy unions and deny americans their constitutional right to form an assembly

This article at cleveland.com is just as powerful.

http://www.cleveland.com/opinion/index.ssf/2012/11/our_grandfathers_and_fathers_e.html#incart_river_default

[quote]

Why we should re-elect Barack Obama: Victor R. Balest

There are two major perceptions of the function of government in our lives.

One is that government is heavy-handed and intrusive and its regulations are an imposition on our liberties and freedoms. This perception has been a mainstay of the conservative political Right and embraced largely by the Republican Party and its client political appendage, the Tea "Party."

The second perception of government is that it is the last and most important barrier between me and the avaricious and oppressive plutocracy that wants to dominate me and subject me to its arbitrary will. Tyranny can come from many quarters. The debate has been going on for centuries and it is not in danger of ending any time soon.

Because human experience is necessarily limited from one generation to another, and the knowledge acquired may not always be adequately passed forward, we depend upon our knowledge of history to protect us from repeating the mistakes of past generations. This is one major reason why education is so vital to our democratic/republican form of government.

My father is now 96 years old, and he has been witness to a tumultuous century with firsthand experience of the first Great Depression, many wars, the advance of air and automobile travel, radio, television, computers and more. He was a successful business owner working seven days a week for many years. He never thought about whether his success was all of his own making, or whether he had help from the hired employees and/or from government, but he has always held the view that government was largely a force of good in his life. He probably never considered government in a bad light because his intentions were always selfless and not avaricious and greedy. He just made a decent living and he was satisfied with that.

My father experienced firsthand also what can happen to a person in a nation where government does not serve as a protector from the avarice of a minority of powerful and unrestrained plutocrats.

When working as a coal miner in western Pennsylvania beside his father when he was a 16-year-old, in 1932 in the depths of the Great Depression, my father was witness to the following event. His father (my grandfather), Paul Balest, was approached one day by his boss. The boss introduced him to a man who was running for political office. The mine boss "advised" my grandfather that he should vote in the upcoming election for this candidate, and this candidate was a Republican. My grandfather replied respectfully that his intention was to vote Democratic in the upcoming election. Bear in mind that this was the same period in our history that unionization of workers was a growing movement in this nation. Put this within the context that overall working conditions were mediocre at best and more often quite dangerous in the mining industry. Know that just prior to this there had been a collapse of the roof in that same mine and one man and one mule were killed, and that the owner of the mine was more upset over the death of the mule than over the worker since the owner would have to pay for the replacement of the mule while replacement of the lost worker was just a matter of hiring another unemployed and desperate human. My grandfather was one of the best workers in that mine and he had one of the best labor jobs.

When my grandfather arrived for work the next day, much to his surprise, he was instructed by management to report to his new position in one of the worst and most dangerous jobs in the mine. He worked for several weeks in that part of the mine where water was knee-deep. My grandfather was no fool, and he understood that this was a clear demonstration of retaliation by the ownership, and this event only strengthened my grandfather's resolve. Eventually the owner relented and put my grandfather back in the job where he had excelled. My grandfather understood that, without union or governmental protections, the plutocrats and their sycophants (otherwise euphemistically referred to as upper and middle management) will grind you into the ground if given the chance, due to a combination of greed and fear; greed because they want their large piece of the pie and all others can fight over what remains, and fear because they refused to relinquish the advantages that they have gained through cunning, wit, deceit, connivance, social and political connections and, yes, some degree of hard work.

Needless to say, to this day my father remains a staunch Democrat, and I am saddened to see that the current generation of younger Americans has little knowledge of the sacrifices made and battles fought by men like John L. Lewis, my grandfather and my father back in the decade of the 1930s. Most if not all of the benefits enjoyed by workers today are due not to the benign altruism of the plutocrat owners but to the efforts and sacrifices of men like my father and grandfather. The hard-won gains of these men -- unionization benefits, decent and safe working conditions, decent pay and shorter work days -- should not be taken as givens in today's workplace. Like political liberty and freedom, if one is not vigilant in fighting and protecting those basic rights of employment, those rights and benefits WILL disappear. Make note all you religious fundamentalists and Tea Party people out there, rules and regulations exist for a reason, for if people were saints we would not need rules and regulations.

In the upcoming presidential election you have four choices. You can vote for 1) the severely conservative Romney of the Republican primaries, or 2) you can vote for the moderate governor of Massachusetts Romney, or 3) for the liberal/progressive dovish, nonhawkish Romney of the most recent two debates, or 4) you can vote for the authentic real deal, Barack Obama. If you are part of the 47 percent of whom candidates Romney and Ryan speak you need to reassess your position in a realistic and brutally honest fashion and recognize who you are and who you must support in an upcoming election that will either thrust this nation back 50 years or will move us forward. I ask of the middle 70 percent in this nation to just do what the plutocrats unabashedly do so well -- I ask that you vote in your own best interest and vote for the re-election of President Barack Obama. [/quote]

5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why we need regulation (Original Post) Mkap Nov 2012 OP
Try Orwell's ' Down and out in Paris and London ' orpupilofnature57 Nov 2012 #1
looks good, read later. postulater Nov 2012 #2
Thanks for sharing your story libodem Nov 2012 #3
Good post. Reminds me of the story about the cows, and unfettered capitalism... Scuba Nov 2012 #4
ShrubCo orpupilofnature57 Nov 2012 #5
 

orpupilofnature57

(15,472 posts)
1. Try Orwell's ' Down and out in Paris and London '
Thu Nov 1, 2012, 06:47 PM
Nov 2012

The bumpy times we have now are a minuscule of the misery we will enjoy if Mitty, the Dominion theocracy, and the 1% ever fully get the reigns again .

libodem

(19,288 posts)
3. Thanks for sharing your story
Thu Nov 1, 2012, 06:58 PM
Nov 2012

Both my grandfathers were union men. My dad's father was born in England and his family were miners. He was a convert to Mormonism and emigrated to the US, he never let the church dictate his political party or his union membership.. (Although my personal experience is that there is pressure to be nonunion and vote Republic.)
Oddly you can find a few union, Democratic, Mormons in western railroad towns. Not often but it happens.

 

Scuba

(53,475 posts)
4. Good post. Reminds me of the story about the cows, and unfettered capitalism...
Thu Nov 1, 2012, 07:11 PM
Nov 2012

This is an oldie, but just as relevant as ever...


Unregulated Capitalism Defined

You have two cows.
You outsource their milking to increase profits.
You set up an offshore shell corporation on a Caribbean island to avoid all taxes.
You manipulate the futures markets to vastly increase the price of milk.
You sell all your milk on the international market.
You start a faux-political party to escape all criticism and responsibility for rampant unemployment and milk shortage at home.
You obfuscate the truth of your manipulation and treachery with your party's battle cry, "Milk baby milk!"
Production increases at your overseas slave labor milking operations but all the milk is still sold on the international markets.
You get your paid congress-critter to gut food safety regs.
You get the Supreme Court to outlaw class action lawsuits, so when milk contamination kills 400 people each survivor must sue on his own. You tie them up in courts for decades.
The milk market collapses so you get bailed out by the taxpayers whose jobs you outsourced.
You get billions of dollars in government subsidies from the politicians you bought with your profits.
You tell the unemployed, starving workers in your now depression ravaged country that it's their own fault and they'd better get used to it because this is "The new normal".
It's all OK because you still keep all profits, pay no taxes, continue to manipulate markets, and still get government subsidies.
You are convinced that American Capitalism is the best economic system ever.
You try to convince everyone else of this obvious fact or else you'll accuse them of being un-American.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why we need regulation