Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LucasD

(74 posts)
Sat Oct 20, 2012, 10:59 PM Oct 2012

Apparently the movie Argo rewrote history

My wife and I went to see Argo, and both of us agreed that it was a very good film.

I won't be giving anything away (most of you know the story anyway) by saying
that during the final credits, a photo is displayed on the screen of Jimmy Carter
shaking hands with Tony Mendez, while present day Jimmy Carter narrates a brief statement
of the hostage freeing mission.

As we were standing up to leave, I overheard the man next to me lean over to the
woman he was with and say "Carter didn't get the hostages out, Reagan did. He
threatened to nuke Iran, so they released 'em."

Needless to say I almost puked up my popcorn. Man, that Reagan was a damn miracle
worker. I've heard him credited for an amazing number of great deeds. I guess
I should burn my history books and jump on the Reagan bandwagon.


16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
 

quinnox

(20,600 posts)
1. I heard it was really good
Sat Oct 20, 2012, 11:03 PM
Oct 2012

Ben Affleck has been on a roll lately. ("The Town" also was a great movie)

 

qkvhj

(57 posts)
3. Reality check
Sat Oct 20, 2012, 11:34 PM
Oct 2012

Why Iran turned the hostages loose is a matter of differing opinions, but Carter owns the attempted hostage rescue lock stock and barrel.

I will tell you three things
.
During that time I was an AB Ranger
The Rangers were and are Delta Force
Delta force personnel were positioned in the middle of the Egyptian desert and deployed from there on this mission.

It was the biggest cluster ""ck I have ever been a part of.
and that was all on Carter.

Carter was what he was. He was and is an honest man in a pool of political sharks. This mission was a total disaster.

upi402

(16,854 posts)
10. They were involved in 'Eagle Claw'
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 02:58 AM
Oct 2012

but not Delta Force from what I know. Trained at Ranger School or 75th. I have (had) a Ranger buddy. Not certain.

 

braddy

(3,585 posts)
13. Rangers, and Special forces were the labor pool for the original Delta, at first the Regiment
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 03:15 AM
Oct 2012

was blocking Rangers from trying out for Delta because they didn't want to lose the men, but Beckwith went to the Pentagon to force the issue.

That means that the original Delta was made up of roughly 100 ex-Rangers, and ex-Army Special Forces, Ranger units were also at Desert one, and at an air strip for the after portion of the raid, serving as "Rangers", not "Delta".

 

Electric Monk

(13,869 posts)
11. On the internet, everyone was in Delta Force. And we're all astronauts, too.
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 03:04 AM
Oct 2012

And nuclear physicists. And doctors.

Didn't you know that already?

Newb ;p

jmowreader

(50,567 posts)
8. The Rangers are not nor ever were Delta Force
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 02:40 AM
Oct 2012

Everyone in Delta Force has been to Ranger School at least once, often as instructors. But SFOD-D and the 75th Ranger Regiment are two completely separate groups.

US Army Special Operations Command is in charge of the Army's special operators. Under them are the Special Forces groups, 160th Aviation and 75th Rangers.

The Navy Special Operations Command owns all the SEAL teams EXCEPT for SEAL Team 6, which is the Team that greased Osama.

There are also Air Force Special Operations Command and Marine Corps Special Operations Command, but they're not germane to this discussion.

There is another command called JSOC, or Joint Special Operations Command. It is at Fort Bragg but there are blue-suiters and green-suiters in it. JSOC owns US Army Special Forces Operational Detachment-Delta (Delta Force) and SEAL Team 6.

upi402

(16,854 posts)
9. Carter forgot to have someone put the pre-filters on and oil them
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 02:48 AM
Oct 2012

to prevent sand clog? That's what I read.

A little PJ-1 or No-Toil baby!

 

Electric Monk

(13,869 posts)
12. The "Canadian Caper" in Argo seems like Canadians just happened to be there
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 03:09 AM
Oct 2012

instead of an integral part.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Caper

Robert Anders, Cora Amburn-Lijek, Mark Lijek, Joseph Stafford, Kathleen Stafford and Lee Schatz were the six American diplomats who were harbored and exfiltrated from Tehran in 1980. They were working in the consulate, a separate building in the embassy compound, when the students swarmed over the wall. Two groups of diplomats fled into Tehran's streets with orders to walk to the British Embassy: The Anders group, along with two Americans seeking services (one eventually obtained an exit visa and was able to get a plane out of Iran with the help of a local embassy employee); and another group, including Consul General Richard Morefield, that took an indirect route and was soon captured and returned to the compound. The Anders group neared the British embassy but saw a huge crowd staging a protest in their path. Robert Anders invited the others to his home, as he lived nearby. That began a six-day odyssey as the group, aided by Thai cook Somchai "Sam" Sriweawnetr, went from house to house and spent one night at the British residential compound. After three days, the Bazargan government fell, and everyone realized the ordeal would not be over quickly. Looking for options, Robert contacted his old friend John Sheardown, a Canadian immigration officer, and received an enthusiastic invitation for the entire group. On November 10, the five arrived at the Sheardown residence, where, in addition to John and Zana Sheardown, they were greeted by Canadian Ambassador Ken Taylor. The Staffords joined Ken and his wife Pat at their home, while the other three stayed with the Sheardowns. Two weeks later,[2] Lee Schatz from the US Agriculture Department, joined the Staffords at the Taylor home. He had initially slept on the floor at the Swedish embassy and had then stayed at the apartment of Swedish consul Cecilia Lithander. The six were now in hiding and would remain there for 79 days.[3]
Movie poster created by the CIA as part of the cover story

The operation itself was initiated at great personal risk by then Canadian ambassador to Iran, Ken Taylor, and Canadian immigration officer John Sheardown who provided sanctuary in their own private residences for the six endangered American diplomats. Two "friendly-country" embassy officials assisted as well, and an unoccupied diplomatic residence was used for several weeks.

Ambassador Taylor contacted then Canadian Secretary of State for External Affairs, Flora MacDonald and Canadian Prime Minister Joe Clark for assistance, who expressed support for the effort. They decided to smuggle the six Americans out of Iran on an international flight using Canadian passports. To do so, an Order in Council was made for the issuance of Canadian passports to the American diplomats in Canadian sanctuary. The granted passports contained a set of forged Iranian visas prepared by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency that would be used to attempt an escape from Iran.

The CIA enlisted its disguise and exfiltration expert, Tony Mendez, to provide a cover story, documents, appropriate clothing, and materials to change their appearance. Mendez worked closely with Canadian government staff in Ottawa, who forwarded the passports and other supporting material to the Canadian embassy through a Canadian diplomatic courier. Mendez then flew to Tehran with an associate to assist with the rescue. There were alternate passports and identities for a variety of scenarios, but the cover story selected had the six being a Hollywood crew scouting movie locations. The elaborate back-story involved a film named Argo, for a Middle-Eastern feel, and a functioning office in Hollywood set up with the help of John Chambers, a veteran Hollywood make-up artist. The script used had been based on the science fiction novel Lord of Light. The six were told that telephone calls to the "Studio Six" office in Los Angeles would be answered. Display ads for the "Studio Six" production were placed in Hollywood publications and one paper was carried by Cora Lijek as part of her cover materials. (The movie scenario was considered one way to get an armed team into Tehran to retake the embassy.)[3]

SoCalDem

(103,856 posts)
14. Actually Jim Baker "got the hostages released" AFTER he got them held longer
Sun Oct 21, 2012, 05:47 AM
Oct 2012

He was part of a delegation that convinced the Ayatollah that he would get a "better deal" from Reagan than from Carter.

and Jim Baker also was instrumental in getting the "almost-there"
Peace Process in the I/P negotiations stalled before GW was inaugurated.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Apparently the movie Argo...