5 Biggest Lies About America's Public Schools -- Debunked
http://www.alternet.org/education/5-biggest-lies-about-americas-public-schools-debunked
***SNIP
Lie #1: Unions are undermining the quality of education in America.
Teachers unions have gotten a bad rap in recent years, but as education professor Paul Thomas of Furman University tells AlterNet, The anti-union message
has no basis in evidence. In fact, Furman points out, Union states tend to correlate with higher test scores. As a 2010 study conducted by Albert Shanker Fellow Matthew Di Carlo found, [T]he states in which there are no teachers covered under binding agreements score lower [on standardized assessment tests] than the states that have them
If anything, it seems that the presence of teacher contracts in a state has a positive effect on achievement by as much as three to five points in reading and math at varying grade levels.
***SNIP
Lie #2: Your students teacher has an easy and over-compensated job.
One talking point that circulated around the Chicago teachers strike was that public school teachers are overpaid for easy jobs with plentiful time off. This is a longstanding gem that has little basis in fact. As political scientist Corey Robin of Brooklyn College/CUNY Graduate Center writes in the Washington Post , when he was growing up his affluent childhood community was embattled every year because the community so looked down on teachers. Teachers had opted out of the capitalist game in the minds of local parents and the assumption, according to Robin, was there could be only one reason for that: they were losers.
***SNIP
Lie #3: If your child doesnt get picked in a charter school lottery, he or she is doomed.
The popular film Waiting for Superman characterizes charter schools as a silver bullet perfectly positioned to save public education -- if only they could replace traditional public schools as quickly as possible. The film picks up on the consequences of social inequality, but goes a step further, presuming that traditional public schools cannot be redeemed, and charters are the last hope for education.
***SNIP
Lie #4: Your child will automatically be better off if your school district adopts a school choice assignment plan.
One way charters often take root in communities is that theyre introduced through school choice plans that purport to give parents a measure of autonomy in choosing their childs school. In some cases, this means parents are offered vouchers that can be used to transfer public school dollars to private (often religiously affiliated) schools; in other cases, parent are asked to select two or three of their top school choices, and will be assigned to one of them. The fact that poor parents working multiple jobs might not have the capacity to fully research their options is never discussed.