The Atlantic: Pelosi and McConnell Are Playing High-Stakes Poker

[Dennis Donovan]

Last edited Tue Jan 7, 2020, 05:22 PM - Edit history (1)

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/01/house-senate-impeachment-standoff/604531/

Benjamin Wittes and Quinta Jurecec

<snip>

It’s time for some game theory.

The standoff stems from McConnell’s proposal for how to proceed with the impeachment trial of President Donald Trump: Pelosi has accused McConnell of violating his oath of office, while Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has suggested a trial procedure that would guarantee that at least four witnesses are called to testify. McConnell has balked at agreeing in advance to call witnesses. Instead, he has argued, the Senate should begin the proceedings without such an agreement and address the question of witnesses only after the House has made its opening argument against the president and Trump’s team has responded.

For this reason, the articles of impeachment remain stalled between the House and the Senate, with Pelosi refusing to deliver them to the other side of the Capitol until McConnell reaches some kind of accommodation with Schumer. There’s no reason, the Democratic leadership argues, to provide the articles to the Senate only for them to be quickly quashed. So Pelosi has withheld the articles until, as she puts it, McConnell agrees to proceed “in a manner worthy of the Constitution.”

Who will blink first?

This sort of strategic tangle is quite different from the debates that led up to the president’s impeachment, which were charged with a kind of moral and legal urgency. The questions then presented a challenge of immediate importance: What sort of behavior by a president so steps outside the bounds of what Americans should consider acceptable that the House should act to remove him from office? To this question, there was a clear right answer, and the House acted to establish its view that Trump had breached his oath of office.

</snip>

The Speaker has the upper hand.

[triron]

1. Embarrassing that even 'The Atlantic' has to go with the both-sidism BS.

This is all on mcConnell. Nancy is playing fair.

[Wellstone ruled]

2. As on Guardian Report stated,

the MSM of the USA has no clue how to report about what the Orange Anus and his Pal Moscow Mitch are doing.

[Dennis Donovan]

3. Read the article. It says Nancy's got the upper hand in all of this

[Phoenix61]

4. My money is McConnell blinks first.

His ego is all wrapped up in this. Pelosi is doing what she believes the constitution requires he to do. I’ll bet on calm, cool logic any day of the week.

[Dennis Donovan]

5. House should subpoena Bolton & withhold the articles until he testifies, then amend the existing art

Link to tweet

"House should now subpoena Bolton & withhold the articles until he testifies - they can decide whether to amend them"