General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHow Abortion Could Threaten GOP Control of the Senate
Cook Political ReportAnd Republican-controlled states enacting laws that effectively ban all abortions threatens to make a bad situation worse for Republicans in many suburbs. This is not to make a moral, ethical, or legal statement, just a political one. A third of the electorate, at most, supports measures this aggressive. Its been said that Americans are antiabortion and pro-choice. Most dont like the idea of abortionmany believe there should be some limits and are extremely uncomfortable with late-term abortionsbut still take a very dim view of outlawing all or almost all abortions, given the many different circumstances that might lead a woman to contemplate one.
President Trump is a heavy enough lift with many college-educated, suburban, white women. The perception of overwhelmingly male state legislatures telling women what they can and cant do in very absolute terms is highly problematic.
There was a time when the decisions to set up court tests of abortion laws were made carefully by antiabortion lawyers and strategists on the national level, picking cases very carefully to maximize their chances of victory. Today the decision-making is both decentralized and organic, and apparently by tone-deaf people who seem to oblivious of the consequences to their cause. When the Rev. Pat Robertson thinks an antiabortion measure goes too far, there is a fair chance its too far. There isnt a pro-choice bone in Robertsons body, but the Yale Law School class of 1955 graduate knows a bad case when he sees one.
This is all a long way of saying that while the Republican majority in the Senate probably shouldnt be in much danger, if one were going to construct a scenario in which Democrats reach a 50-seat majority (with a White House win) or 51 (without one), an uncompromising assault on legal abortion would likely be an element of it.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)...they're french-kissing it!
shanny
(6,709 posts)Amishman
(5,558 posts)The only way they could give us a bigger gift would be disbanding
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)They've really screwed themselves with this. It is not going to work out in their favor.
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)Bucking the Standard Media Narrative and pondering the possibility that Republicans have overplayed their hand or pandered too heavily to their extremists doesn't happen very often if at all. It is to be celebrated that someone, somewhere with a media platform is speaking the unspeakable.
Here's hoping more media outlets begin picking this up.
pecosbob
(7,542 posts)posited on some election turnouts. This concerted push on abortion is coming because they (the root and stem GOP) smell a sea change in the Supreme Court...they can't help themselves, while Washington GOPers are backpedalling and it appears they have no control over their party and are terrified of what this will mean for the elections.
OliverQ
(3,363 posts)more than 25% support in favor of banning abortion. Even most Republicans don't want an outright ban, although many may want stronger restrictions.
keithbvadu2
(36,838 posts)Gynotician
Play doctor in the legislature
?v=1556047874