General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMeasles is back because states give parents too many ways to avoid vaccines
https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2019/2/16/18223764/measles-outbreak-2019-vaccines-anti-vaxMore than 120 people across the country, mostly small children, have been infected by the super contagious measles virus in ongoing outbreaks since January.
In New York City, the virus has been spreading since September among Orthodox Jews, some of whom reject vaccines because of unfounded safety concerns. In Washington, mistrust of health officials and pharmaceutical companies appears to be driving parents to opt out, leading to 65 cases. There are also cases in Texas, Oregon, and western and southern New York State.
These outbreaks will cost states and the federal government millions of dollars to contain. Theyll distract from other important public health programs. Most importantly, theyll put people who cant be immunized newborn babies, kids with vaccine allergies at risk.
But heres the most frustrating part: This is all entirely avoidable. By 2000, thanks to the measles vaccine, the virus was declared eliminated in the US. Its absurd that outbreaks have reappeared, yet theres a single reason why: Too many states make it way too easy for parents to avoid vaccines on behalf of their kids. In other words, measles is making a comeback because of a policy failure.
Most of the people with measles right now werent immunized from the virus. They all live in places that permit a variety of nonmedical religious or philosophical exemptions from vaccines, a problem that recently caught the attention of the head of the Food and Drug Administration, Scott Gottlieb. Some states are engaging in such wide exemptions that theyre creating the opportunity for outbreaks on a scale that is going to have national implications, he told CNN. If certain states continue down the path that theyre on, I think theyre going to force the hand of the federal health agencies.
Sid
HopeAgain
(4,407 posts)to fail to vaccinate kids. The parens patriae doctrine has always recognized the state can require parents do what is in the child's best interests and overriden even religious positions by other groups including thr Jehovahs Witnesses and the Christian Scientists.
Buckeyeblue
(5,500 posts)It's really a national security concern. And there is nothing in the bible that even hints that people shouldn't vaccinate.
KitSileya
(4,035 posts)What's worse, is that they put plenty of other people's lives at risk too. They have decided they care less about the lives of infants (too young to get the vaccine), those allergic to the vaccine, those who are immuno-compromised (people on chemotherapy, chronically ill people, people with Crohn's disease, to mention a few) and those of the elderly. These huge swathes of the population are worth less to them than their own false beliefs.
Right now, Costa Rica is having their first case of measles in 4 years - a five-year old unvaccinated French boy was brought into the country while infected, and now all those who were in contact with him, or even entered a room he was in up to two hours after he left it, are at risk. If the boy doesn't have a medical exemption, I say bill the parents for all the costs the Costa Rican health system incurs because of this. And if he infected someone, they should be allowed to sue for damages. In addition, the parents should be charged with biological terrorism if it spreads to one other individual.
riverboatgambler
(1 post)Yup, thanks to Cheeto, mothers feel justified in being selfish instead of vaccinating their kids for the good of others. This MAGA world makes me sick. We need to get back to thinking about others first before ourselves.
Buckeyeblue
(5,500 posts)Igel
(35,350 posts)They were around in the '70s and '80s. I knew a lot of people who had various kinds of exemptions. They weren't always easy to get. But if you were motivated to get them, you could. But you had to document that you fell into one of the exempted categories.
They were part of the process that led to the 2000 declaration. We act like the exemptions are new. They're not. And they worked. How do we know? Because they were part of the process that got us to being declared measles free.
What changed?
Big Pharma. Or, more precisely, the attitude towards it. It became seen as evil.
"Back to nature." Anything that messes with the natural state of affairs must be wrong.
Those two, and the abolition of the horribly restrictive requirement that parents document that they fall into a "exempt class". Now all you have to do is say, "Sorry, don't think so."
Between that and the anti-vaxxers' "distrust big pharma" and the back-to-nature "distrust science" folk, it's easy to have a bunch of people who don't get their kids vaccinated and at the drop of a hat change their minds because it's not a real belief or deeply held view. It's just a passing fad. But once you've passed on the vaccinations for your kids, very seldom does the issue come up very much. The school paperwork's in place, the doctor's chart has a note in it, and that's that. Even if there is more school paperwork, it's easier than taking your kid in for vaccinations.
Some cite the cost. Most cities and states have free vaccination programs for those in poverty. And it's something you do once a year, for a limited number of years (per kid), so it's not just a huge time suck.
The West Coast led the way with liberalizing the requirements, by the way. A lot of us thought this was a bad idea. But it was deemed restrictive. This isn't MAGA. Quit using it to mean "anything I don't happen to like today."
Your freedom doesn't have to result in a government family-separation policy.
Mariana
(14,860 posts)That's what really set up the current anti-vaccine attitudes. People still believe Wakefield's crap.
crazycatlady
(4,492 posts)The internet is both a blessing and a curse here. It is not hard to find someone who agrees with you (on any given issue).
Rhiannon12866
(205,927 posts)Mariana
(14,860 posts)Wakefield published his fraudulent paper about vaccines and autism back in 1998. Even before that, there were stories that the polio vaccine caused AIDS.
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)Good first post!
stonecutter357
(12,697 posts)WhiteTara
(29,721 posts)easily manipulated. Here's some astounding information in my latest Free Parking.
http://eureka.news/free-parking-67/
Measles, Facebook and Russia seem like non-sequiturs that shouldnt be grouped in the same sentence; but horrifying enough, they all belong together.
According to the CDC, measles is the most infectious of all preventable diseases; being airborne, it can transmit with stunning efficacy each time an infected person exhales. Unlike the flu virus, which requires close proximity, the measles virus spreads over space and time.
Considered eradicated in the U.S. since 2000 because of vaccinations, WHO now fears a global comeback as measles cases have recently spiked 30% worldwide. Shockingly, they cite Russias worldwide vaccination disinformation campaign being spread through Facebook and other social media.
please read the rest here http://eureka.news/free-parking-67/
brer cat
(24,596 posts)I didn't realize the Russians were pushing the anti-vac propaganda. You do outstanding work!
WhiteTara
(29,721 posts)cases there were in Ukraine. And here we are. Now I see that personal apps funnel your information to FB, so they know when you are pregnant as soon as you do. Maybe sooner? Yikes.
lindysalsagal
(20,726 posts)as simple as that. What's the percentage of idiots who think the world is flat? That the sun revolves around th earth???
Not every opinion is an expert or informed one. Some people are stubbornly ignorant.
ck4829
(35,085 posts)yortsed snacilbuper
(7,939 posts)you can get chicken pox again, you can die!