Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

A HERETIC I AM

(24,380 posts)
Fri Oct 19, 2018, 11:59 PM Oct 2018

One last post on the killing of Jamal Khashoggi. I worked in a slaughterhouse when I was younger.

I'm going to get gruesome here. If you can't stomach gruesome, click away and read another thread.







My dad was CIA and we traveled overseas several times when I was young.
In 1973 we went to Australia. At the age of 15 I got a job at a small Abattoir in Alice Springs, where my dad was stationed at Pine Gap and I was able to get a job at the only facility in town that supplied meat for the town and surrounding villages.

It taught me a LOT about anatomy.

It taught me how a body comes apart, how joints work, how bones are cut and how they break, how meat separates, how blood pools and coagulates, how much life is left in a being after the heart stops beating and all of this in a very real and practical way.

We dispatched the cattle with a .22 round to the center of one of the two curls of hair that every bovine has. One on the center of the forehead and one just behind the line of the horns or top of the skull. A single twenty two round in the middle of either of those will cause a fully grown bullock to drop like a sack of flour.

I learned a lot about how animals die and watched hundreds of them do so, cattle, pigs and sheep.

In my life and career I've had the opportunity to travel to many places, and to England several times. I once visited Warwick Castle which has an actual dungeon and torture chamber, complete with an "oubliette", basically a dungeon within a dungeon. It was a small hole, no larger than a 55 gallon drum in the floor of one of the rooms and the doomed was placed in there, a grate was locked over them and they were left.

To starve to death or die of thirst in their own filth.

I say all of this to make the following point;

The amazing and wondrous ways humans have discovered to cause pain and terror on other humans is simply astounding. The depravity required to come up with the various devices and methods used to inflict pain in a human body over the centuries is mind boggling. Ways to cause pain but not death have become almost a science in some parts of civilization, as anyone can find out with some simple and basic research.

Burning, crushing, impalement, stretching, hanging, starvation, etc. etc. Ways to hurt humans are unbeleivably numerous and have been used throughout the centuries.

Most advanced societies no longer practice such atrocities. The last execution by guillotine in France was done in the 70's, behind a wall at a prison yet it was surreptitiously filmed and caused such an uproar that the French government forever banned the practice. The fact that we still execute criminals in this country is a disgrace, but that is mostly a reflection of our religious society more than anything else.

But we don't do public hangings anymore. We don't put people in the stocks. We don't whip or flog offenders. We don't stone people to death. We don't burn people at the stake anymore.

And we sure as hell don't dismember people while they are still alive for the sole purpose of making their deaths as painful as possible.

No country or government that would tolerate such a thing, much less order it, has any business being considered part of the modern world. No one that thinks this is an appropriate way of ridding themselves of a perceived enemy can POSSIBLY BE CONSIDERED as a friend of a modern civilization.

It just can not be tolerated. The human race must move away from this backward notion that causing unspeakable pain during execution serves a purpose.

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
One last post on the killing of Jamal Khashoggi. I worked in a slaughterhouse when I was younger. (Original Post) A HERETIC I AM Oct 2018 OP
Thank you for this post, my dear HERETIC. CaliforniaPeggy Oct 2018 #1
Thanks. A HERETIC I AM Oct 2018 #2
I view the world much more darkly anymore. fleabiscuit Oct 2018 #3
If our government won't act, will the Hague? RainCaster Oct 2018 #4
So far, authorities at The Hague have been silent. Haggis for Breakfast Oct 2018 #5
Thanks for that info... BigmanPigman Oct 2018 #10
I won't post a picture, but I will post a short article about saw torture ProudLib72 Oct 2018 #6
What you posted is what I first thought of Wellstone ruled Oct 2018 #7
I remember seeing an exhibit on medieval torture on a trip to Italy ProudLib72 Oct 2018 #8
I wouldn't mind seeing Karma and BigmanPigman Oct 2018 #13
A continuous loop in their prison cells ProudLib72 Oct 2018 #16
I don't want them to have their own prison block. I want them separated far away from each other, NBachers Oct 2018 #20
Nance outlined how this story ends this morning. Wellstone ruled Oct 2018 #25
So what do they do with their "chosen martyr"? BigmanPigman Oct 2018 #30
Public Spectical most likely. Wellstone ruled Oct 2018 #32
Khashoggi is one of the contemporary world's great martyrs DemocracyMouse Oct 2018 #9
You're right. I understand you mean that he is a martyr a broad sense ProudLib72 Oct 2018 #12
I went to a Museum of Torture in London. LastLiberal in PalmSprings Oct 2018 #17
When I see something horrific, I stand there like a deer in headlights. ProudLib72 Oct 2018 #18
I remember thinking, "God, they were barbaric in those days." LastLiberal in PalmSprings Oct 2018 #19
Let's not forget... llmart Oct 2018 #33
mportant to set this out bluntly in all its horror. NOT ACCEPTABLE bobbieinok Oct 2018 #11
Trump is selling our national soul one slice at a time grantcart Oct 2018 #14
Excellent statement KT2000 Oct 2018 #28
I worked in bookstores for years. Are_grits_groceries Oct 2018 #15
in some respects, the World History section contains even more horrific content anarch Oct 2018 #23
K&R Paka Oct 2018 #21
i have a book on the inquisition & there torture methods, w/ photos AND pansypoo53219 Oct 2018 #22
We are but Chimps with great weapons HAB911 Oct 2018 #24
But it DOES serve a purpose! Eyeball_Kid Oct 2018 #26
100 years ago lapfog_1 Oct 2018 #27
When WWI ended the Brits drew up the borderlines for these countries FakeNoose Oct 2018 #31
ISIS made a video where they executed people in a slaughter house. joshcryer Oct 2018 #29
America's role has been to uphold international rules Hortensis Oct 2018 #34
The purpose is abundantly clear: to frighten dissidents and journalists into silence. Nitram Oct 2018 #35
$$$$$$$$$$! Trumps all morals and humanity Hulk Oct 2018 #36
K&R orangecrush Oct 2018 #37

CaliforniaPeggy

(149,727 posts)
1. Thank you for this post, my dear HERETIC.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:09 AM
Oct 2018

It's excellent. We need to be reminded of the history that surrounds these practices.

And I agree completely with your conclusion:

It just can not be tolerated. The human race must move away from this backward notion that causing unspeakable pain during execution serves a purpose.



fleabiscuit

(4,542 posts)
3. I view the world much more darkly anymore.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:18 AM
Oct 2018

Before the confirmation of what the Saudis did to Khashoggi I was already sure of what really happened. Hell, they still support public beheadings as a means of control.

RainCaster

(10,927 posts)
4. If our government won't act, will the Hague?
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:21 AM
Oct 2018

Look at the major news outlets around the world - almost all have this horrifying mess on the front page top. The only one I've found that has ignored this is "the Age", Rupert Murdock's hometown paper. BBC, CBC, Al Jazeera, they are all appalled at the brutal regime responsible for this. Most of them are also appalled at DFT's inaction.

Once again, he has made our country the laughing stock.

Haggis for Breakfast

(6,831 posts)
5. So far, authorities at The Hague have been silent.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:35 AM
Oct 2018

I am hoping they release a statement soon.

In a civilized world, this cannot be allowed to stand without investigation.

BigmanPigman

(51,638 posts)
10. Thanks for that info...
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:14 AM
Oct 2018

I hope it doesn't "fall off the front page" in a few days. I am glad this and the moron's behavior is being covered and criticized in other countries.

ProudLib72

(17,984 posts)
6. I won't post a picture, but I will post a short article about saw torture
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:47 AM
Oct 2018
The Saw was widely used throughout the Middle Ages, mainly because the tools required were found in most houses and no complex devices were required. It was a cheap way to torture and kill a victim who was often accused of: witchery, adultery, murder, blasphemy or even theft.

The victim was tied to an inverted position. This had several "benefits": first, it assured sufficient blood diverted to the brain, second, it slowed down the loss of blood and third, it humiliated the victim.

Depending on the victim and torturer, this torture could last several hours. When a confession was required, the victim was frequently forced to watch someone else be subject to this method. If he didn't confess, he'd be slowly cut in half.

During the Inquisition, this method became even more popular as the inquisitors traveled from village to village often without any torture devices at their disposal.

While some victims were cut completely in half as a symbolical gesture, most had only up to their abdomen cut, this was done to prolongue the time of death.
http://www.medievality.com/saw.html


What the saudis did was medieval torture, end of story! It is barbaric and needs to be condemned in the strongest possible language worldwide. MBS must be held personally accountable, and he should stand trial. I cannot believe that we are living in a world where medieval torture not only takes place but is fully supported by our government. This is sickening!
 

Wellstone ruled

(34,661 posts)
7. What you posted is what I first thought of
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 12:59 AM
Oct 2018

when this story first broke. Do remember reading about the torture methods used during medieval era. And that came to mind when the story broke about the saw. When we learned of ISIS beheading and delimbing people,you wonder just how far Civilization has not come.

ProudLib72

(17,984 posts)
8. I remember seeing an exhibit on medieval torture on a trip to Italy
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:02 AM
Oct 2018

That was nearly forty years ago, and the "Saw Torture" stuck in mind for all this time as being the single most gruesome method of torture ever devised.

BigmanPigman

(51,638 posts)
13. I wouldn't mind seeing Karma and
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:21 AM
Oct 2018

"An eye for an eye" happens to tRump, his family and his admin over this. Maybe if Jared saw a bone saw coming with his name on it he would begin to feel the fear that the journalist felt. Jared and his daddy-in-law need need a quick lesson on what the results of their "enemy lists" looks like in person. They should force all of them to have to listen to the audio tape on Volume #11 on a non stop 24 hour loop.

ProudLib72

(17,984 posts)
16. A continuous loop in their prison cells
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:38 AM
Oct 2018

So long as they all get their own prison block. I'm really hoping Kushner goes down for life over this.

NBachers

(17,149 posts)
20. I don't want them to have their own prison block. I want them separated far away from each other,
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 02:05 AM
Oct 2018

isolated from their fellow traitors.

 

Wellstone ruled

(34,661 posts)
25. Nance outlined how this story ends this morning.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:55 PM
Oct 2018

Had a very close Friend growing up that spent a couple of decades working the Saudi Area while in the Air Force. His stories of how a person is singled out to be a Martyr for the sake of the King and how certain perks are given to his Tribe as a token of service to the Kingdom. This AM Malcolm Nance spoke of this same thing will happen in order for the Arms Sales to go forward. He claims it will be the Youngest of the Death Squad,and the rest banished to Mecca.

BigmanPigman

(51,638 posts)
30. So what do they do with their "chosen martyr"?
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 03:08 PM
Oct 2018

Do they send him to prison as a fall guy or do they harm him physically (are they doing it to appease the US and it is just for show)?

DemocracyMouse

(2,275 posts)
9. Khashoggi is one of the contemporary world's great martyrs
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:03 AM
Oct 2018

We must start erecting statues (and internet memes) in his honor.

Long may his light shine.

ProudLib72

(17,984 posts)
12. You're right. I understand you mean that he is a martyr a broad sense
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:18 AM
Oct 2018

But he is martyr in the specific sense for journalists around the world. I would like to see his death translate into action by the media. I know it seems like a horrible thought, but maybe some "good" can come from this.

17. I went to a Museum of Torture in London.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:46 AM
Oct 2018

It was nice and dark inside, as befitting any dungeon, and there were eerie sounds and shrieks of pain throughout the exhibits, more associated with a house of horrors than a museum, but in reality that's what torture is -- a horror show often done in public. I can't recall all the details, I just remember feeling a little ill to my stomach at all the things man was capable of doing to his fellow men and women.

If Trump saw it, God help us. It may give him ideas.

ProudLib72

(17,984 posts)
18. When I see something horrific, I stand there like a deer in headlights.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:49 AM
Oct 2018

Transfixed. I know that's how I must have remembered the saw torture at the exhibit. At the same time, though, I was taking comfort in the knowledge that this kind of torture was centuries old and not likely to happen again. Got that wrong!

19. I remember thinking, "God, they were barbaric in those days."
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:57 AM
Oct 2018

I was right, but I was wrong in thinking it was over.

llmart

(15,556 posts)
33. Let's not forget...
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 05:35 PM
Oct 2018

that during George W. Bush's/Dick Cheney's tenure in the WH, they and their administration sanctioned torture such as waterboarding. Remember Abu Ghraib? Those pictures were chilling and nausea inducing to me.

KT2000

(20,590 posts)
28. Excellent statement
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 02:39 PM
Oct 2018

If you can, send it far and wide on social media. It says so much in few words.

Are_grits_groceries

(17,111 posts)
15. I worked in bookstores for years.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 01:38 AM
Oct 2018

Peole would come in and ask where the horror section was. I showed them and then I asked if they really wanted horror. They nodded. I would take them to the true crime section. People will do anything to other people. If they really read that stuff, they might not sleep soundly again.

Know all those police and crime shows? Know all the interesting and at times weird illegal acts you read about? They get a lot of them from police blotters. They don’t lack for stories.

anarch

(6,535 posts)
23. in some respects, the World History section contains even more horrific content
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 05:12 AM
Oct 2018

than the True Crime section does. Human history is, on the whole, not very pretty.

pansypoo53219

(21,004 posts)
22. i have a book on the inquisition & there torture methods, w/ photos AND
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 04:19 AM
Oct 2018

old etchings. the REAL rack, the wheel(oy, the wheel). you do not wanna know the real drawn & quartered. the anal pear, the vaginal pear. finger crushers. SKULL CRUSHERS. hell, the guillotine was awesome compared to a guy bashing your neck w/ a club til your head falls off. most times it took more than 1 whack to cut a head off.

HAB911

(8,919 posts)
24. We are but Chimps with great weapons
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 09:46 AM
Oct 2018

Most Brutal Chimpanzee Society Ever Discovered | Rise of the Warrior Apes




Eyeball_Kid

(7,434 posts)
26. But it DOES serve a purpose!
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 02:23 PM
Oct 2018

Torturing a person while alive and then killing them is an exercise of power over life and death. It is an exercise of power by the person ordering the torture and execution. It's raw power in its most gruesome form. The executor positions him/herself as God, and attributes to him/herself the power to kill-- by convenience. It may as well be done on a whim. It is the kind of power to which Trumpy envisions for himself and to which he aspires. Trumpy admires people like Putin and Duterte because they exercise that same kind of power, and do it with impunity. Since Trumpy has no conscience and no sense of compassion, killing is merely a means to an end. He is restrained only by the values that emanate from western civilization and from the founding legal documents on which the US is built. He does not, himself, embrace these values. He is only constrained by them.

To have elected him, there had to have been hundreds, even thousands of people willing to finance his rise to power, KNOWING that Trumpy is amoral, power-drunk, and generally evil. Trumpy, alone, doesn't deserve sole accountability for the destruction of the fabric of the nation. The accountability also rests with his financial and emotional supporters. And there are plenty.

lapfog_1

(29,227 posts)
27. 100 years ago
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 02:27 PM
Oct 2018

What is now Jordan, Iraq, Israel, Syria, Yemen, and Saudi Arabia was almost entirely not that much different than the same region 1000 years earlier. It was very tribal, and life was much like life during the time of Mohamed (or even earlier). Raids by one tribe against another was the norm. killings happened all the time. To speak out against the king or prince of something or other was to take your life in your hands.

We have dragged these people and their culture kicking and screaming into the 20th (and now 21st) century... because of their oil.

What we have witnessed in the last 40 or 50 years is backlash against the West and modernity. Starting with the overthrow of the Shah of Iran. Even Saddam Hussein was hated in his country for trying to make it more secular... which is why it was entirely laughable that Bush 2 would try to link secular Saddam with religious (and Sunni) fundamentalist Osama bin Laden (another Saudi).

We should not be shocked or even surprised at MBS and the killing of Khashoggi. Disgusted, sure... but in some ways it would be better to almost wall off the middle east and let them slowly adapt to the modern world... with the reduction of religion as the main explanation of the world around them and of history. Christians have long ago (most of them anyway) decided that the creation story is metaphor at best or possibly just outright fiction.

However, they have our money because they have the oil and we build (again, unfortunately) a fossil fuel based economy and oil was the most useful form of fossil fuel.

I don't have an answer... only to say that many people long for stability... and to the Arabian peninsula, that looks like what existed more than 100 years ago (even if that was for a small fraction of the population that exists today... and it wasn't all that ideal then either).

FakeNoose

(32,794 posts)
31. When WWI ended the Brits drew up the borderlines for these countries
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 04:28 PM
Oct 2018

Before that, there weren't any borders or maps. It was all nomadic land with constant warfare between tribes.
It seems they still think & behave that way, but the oil money made them into definite winners and losers.



joshcryer

(62,277 posts)
29. ISIS made a video where they executed people in a slaughter house.
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 03:06 PM
Oct 2018

I would not suggest looking this video up, and I feel uneasy talking about it, but let's just say they slit the throats of about two dozen men and strung them up like cattle.

Now let me be perfectly clear here: the video I speak of is filmed in high quality HD, expertly edited, with extremely gruesome closeups. The quality of the production is so good it's almost unreal, like it's out of a horror movie. But it's not. It's real. Men executed en masse and forced to bleed out like halal / kosher killing of animals. But they're not animals.

Evil exists in the world. And it's a thing that a certain country and a certain religious sect actually approves of and funds. The HD cameras, film equipment (I'm talking about gyro stabilized RED Cameras that are tens of thousands of dollars), editing equipment, it's funded by someone. A certain group of people with more money than they know what to do with to fund wholesale slaughter of people they disagree with.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
34. America's role has been to uphold international rules
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 05:39 PM
Oct 2018

that replace assassinations, torture, mutilation, mass murder, wars. Most of those who voted for Trump had no idea that they were voting for a return to what you've described, and unfortunately still don't.

 

Hulk

(6,699 posts)
36. $$$$$$$$$$! Trumps all morals and humanity
Sat Oct 20, 2018, 10:40 PM
Oct 2018

You see....jobs, jobs, jobs. This is ALL that matters to this heinous thug in the White House, this whole administration, the entire RepuKKKe party and 38% of amerKKKaners today. Nada mas!

Our economy is dependent on "the war machine". We have left any semblance of moral values after we left the shores of Europe and Asia in 1945. WE are the factory of war and destruction. Russia, China, Israel...they compete, but "We are #1"...by a mile.

You suggest cutting ties with one of our biggest customers....well, you might as well go bark at the moon.

Sorry folks...this is who WE are today. It's who we have been for the past 70 years. Do you think they buy our tv's?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»One last post on the kill...