General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsUnfortunately, Trump has an easy-out on his $1 mil Warren bet.
He said he'd give a million dollars if Warren could prove she was a native American. But the DNA test only proves she has a native American heritage, 10 generations ago, not that she is a native American. It's not the same thing. I'm of German/Irish heritage, it doesn't mean I'm actually German OR Irish. Semantics, I know...but Trump is a crook and a con-man who always finds a way out of paying his debts or keeping his word.
jcgoldie
(11,631 posts)Everyone knows what he meant.
fescuerescue
(4,448 posts)I don't think he does either.
former9thward
(32,025 posts)"A DNA test is useless to determine tribal citizenship. Current DNA tests do not even distinguish whether a person's ancestors were indigenous to North or South America. Sovereign tribal nations set their own legal requirements for citizenship, and while DNA tests can be used to determine lineage, such as paternity to an individual, it is not evidence for tribal affiliation. Using a DNA test to lay claim to any connection to the Cherokee Nation or any tribal nation, even vaguely, is inappropriate and wrong. It makes a mockery out of DNA tests and its legitimate uses while also dishonoring legitimate tribal governments and their citizens, whose ancestors are well documented and whose heritage is prove. Senator Warren is undermining tribal interests with her continued claims of tribal heritage."
https://www.kjrh.com/news/local-news/cherokee-nation-issues-statement-on-sen-elizabeth-warren-s-dna-test-results
SWBTATTReg
(22,143 posts)Just ask all of his former contractors.
malaise
(269,054 posts)or he's beyond brazen for this morning's denial.
marylandblue
(12,344 posts)He did not provide a DNA test, a long-form birth certificate , or veterinarian exam.
TheBlackAdder
(28,209 posts)lark
(23,105 posts)Now he's saying he has to administer the test. Such bullshit! Does he also do the reading and reporting.
There is no decency, no honor. no humanity anywhere in that bald, bulging, soft, pile of ugly orange wrinkles & bad skin.
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)they would give him a 10-minute swirly in his sick freaking solid-gold republican toilet. It is so unAmerican. So lacking in honor.
* republican Draft-Dodger-in-Chief
stonecutter357
(12,697 posts)marybourg
(12,633 posts)Atman
(31,464 posts)But listen to what Trump bet on...his bet wasn't that she had some native American heritage. He said she had to prove she was a native American. Big difference.
Crutchez_CuiBono
(7,725 posts)Why the fox news thing atman? No one I know would be associated w that. Why here? Even if it's a joke.
Atman
(31,464 posts)It says "The Fox News Presidency."
Crutchez_CuiBono
(7,725 posts)Cannot stand to look at it. Sorry.
Atman
(31,464 posts)Just curious, because I made it myself.
madaboutharry
(40,212 posts)Don't let them dictate the narrative, it can be anywhere between 6 and 10 generations.
fescuerescue
(4,448 posts)My 6th Generation Grandfather is a Revolutionary war veteran.
Ancestry is fun, but generally speaking at 6 to 10 generations back, we are more related to a random stranger than a 6th or 10th generation grand parent.
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)The man chisels on his taxes, cheats his employees and contractors, defrauds people (Trump University, anyone?) and welshes on bets. Why any decent person would get mixed up with this deadbeat is beyond me.
hlthe2b
(102,293 posts)With six generations back on the DNA, it is unlikely, but slightly possible she could meet that if she knew what tribe. She could then petition for tribal membership, which, if granted means the US Government has not a GD thing they could say about it. She would BE Native American.
Just sayin... She, of course, is not likely interested in doing so.
world wide wally
(21,744 posts)His word is as good as an overcooked noodle at Taco Bell.
Raven123
(4,849 posts)But Kavanaugh ....
ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)Or maybe he promised to pay her a million doll hairs. That's more his speed. Classic fifth grade.
DVRacer
(707 posts)"A DNA test is useless to determine tribal citizenship. Current DNA tests do not even distinguish whether a person's ancestors were indigenous to North or South America. Sovereign tribal nations set their own legal requirements for citizenship, and while DNA tests can be used to determine lineage, such as paternity to an individual, it is not evidence for tribal affiliation. Using a DNA test to lay claim to any connection to the Cherokee Nation or any tribal nation, even vaguely, is inappropriate and wrong. It makes a mockery out of DNA tests and its legitimate uses while also dishonoring legitimate tribal governments and their citizens, who ancestors are well documented and whose heritage is prove. Senator Warren is undermining tribal interests with her continued claims of tribal heritage."
- Cherokee Nation Secretary of State Chuck Hoskin, Jr.
kentuck
(111,103 posts)If the different tribes put some weight behind the words that are passed down from one generation to the next by word of mouth?
DVRacer
(707 posts)Everyone claims some relationship to a tribe but you are obligated to prove it for benefits. You more or less have to show a direct lineage to a person on the Dawes rolls. DNA tests are not something that is acceptable due to not being able to differentiate between North and South America or something. Sen Warren is being chewed up on local news today for her claims keep in mind we are home to the five major tribes. I feel that she would have been better off not saying anything. I have not wanted to look at my social media I glimpsed earlier and its bad here even among Democratic Party members which the tribes consist mainly of.
marybourg
(12,633 posts)She only claimed a native ancestor, based on family lore.
0rganism
(23,957 posts)> "DNA tests can be used to determine lineage"
iirc, all she said was that she had a Native American ancestor many generations back, which, apparently, is exactly what the results of the DNA test suggest
d_r
(6,907 posts)their basic point is that if you are not on the Dawes roll then you are not a Cherokee. That means if your ancestors were assimilated enough to pass for white or black by 1898 and 1914 to not be on the reservation to be listed on that roll you are not Cherokee. On the one hand, I totally get that if you didn't grow up Cherokee but grew up as white or black then you are not are not a part of that community, on the other hand, there are a lot of white and black folks in the south east who had Cherokee ancestors. I know that it is a joke that every one in the south has a Cherokee "princess" in their family line, and I get that, but at the same time there was a ton of confusion between the five south eastern nations, slaves, white folks. The Cherokee were so assimilated in north Georgia and SE Tennessee. The Dawes rolls only has those people who were in North Georgia on Cherokee tribal land and were sent on trail of tears. That got shrunk several times, so land that was Cherokee at one time point wasn't by then. For that matter, the Choctaw and Chickasaw were also so interwovan with white and black folks. I get that is why the trail of tears and the land grab was even more horrible than horrible, and I get why there was resentment of cousins who weren't living in the Cherokee territory and didn't get put on the trail of tears. I do get that. And I again, I understand that anyone not raised in the culture shouldn't appropriate it. But there should be some sort of other ground for the folks who have ancestors who were assimilated.
In her video she was pretty clear that she wasn't trying to appropriate the culture and that what really bothered her was the mocking of the culture.
I agree with him about the problems with the DNA tests, though. The Cherokee leaders are scared to death that wannabe cousins are going to start coming out of the wood pile waving DNA test results.
spanone
(135,844 posts)FUCK HIM
The Wielding Truth
(11,415 posts)kentuck
(111,103 posts)..to back down his $1 million dollar bet.
She should keep on his ass until he pays up.
What a weasel!!
Atman
(31,464 posts)She didn't claim to be "a native American," she only claimed ancestry. Trump's bet was that she was a native American. Yes, of course he'll try to weasel out of it, but he is on video making a very different bet than "she has native American ancestors several generations in her past."
fescuerescue
(4,448 posts)10 Gens back isn't the same as being a native American.
I have a grandmother that is native America, so my DNA test should show a very strong connection. But that's not enough for me to declare myself Cherokee.
badhair77
(4,218 posts)Everything he does is a gimmick.
C_U_L8R
(45,003 posts)What a weak pathetic baby. Pay up, you deadbeat.
malaise
(269,054 posts)pure Native American.
Atman
(31,464 posts)Read the sub line of my OP again...I said Trump has an out, not that he isn't a lying weasel. He is on video making his bet, which is not the same as Warren's claim.
malaise
(269,054 posts)Alwaysna
(574 posts)tblue37
(65,408 posts)Baltimike
(4,146 posts)flotsam
(3,268 posts)Can you prove your a native American?
Yes, you honor-If he means by blood, here are my DNA results and if that's not enough here is my Oklahoma birth certificate and being born here means I'm a native American...